-
Peer Review in 3 Minutes
How do articles get peer reviewed? What role does peer review play in scholarly research and publication? This video will explain.
This video is published under a Creative Commons 3.0 BY-NC-SA US license.
License, credits, and contact information can be found here: http://www.lib.ncsu.edu/tutorials/peerreview/
Feel free to link to / embed our videos!
published: 01 May 2014
-
What is Peer Review?
Peer review is a quality control process used in academic and scholarly work. This video explains the term, the process and how to identify a peer reviewed article.
Key links from the video:
- Learn more about finding peer review resources: https://deakin.libguides.com/peer_review
- Learn more skills for your studies: https://www.deakin.edu.au/library/skills-for-study
published: 10 Jul 2020
-
What is peer review?
What is Peer Review?
Brought to you by the University of Houston Libraries
As part of your own research, it is important to show that you are engaged in the scholarly conversation in your subject area, and one way of doing that is by reading and citing articles from peer-reviewed journals. You may hear articles in these journals referred to as academic or scholarly articles as well, but peer review refers to the specific process the articles goes through to be published in one of these journals.
The process starts with the submission of a research paper to a journal. The editor checks the quality of the paper and determines if the paper fits the scope of the journal before sending it out for review. If so, they pass it on to two or three other reviewers. These reviewers are other experts...
published: 13 Nov 2019
-
How to Write Effective Peer Review Comments
What's the difference between higher-order and lower-order concerns in peer review, and how can I write effective peer review comments? Find out in this video.
Video creators: Tim Becker, Julia Feerrar, Yemi Awotayo
Video contributors: Chloe Robertson, Kayla McNabb, Katlyn Griffin, Lisa Becksford
For other videos in this series, visit odyssey.lib.vt.edu.
published: 19 Aug 2020
-
Scientific Peer Review, ca. 1945
Herr Professor has his latest manuscript reviews back, and he's not thrilled with the editorial decision.
published: 19 Nov 2009
-
How to Peer-Review Like a Pro (Step-by-Step Guide)
In this episode of Navigating Academia, Dr. Singh discusses step-by-step how you can do a peer review for an article that you've been assigned by an academic journal.
Knowing how to do a peer-review for academic journal articles is an absolutely critical skill to know for your career in academia.
👉Learn how to get on the editorial board of an academic journal in this video:
https://youtu.be/zYu0tmLzO7
Especially if you don't have a lot of experience with a peer-review process this can be pretty daunting. A lot of people even report to me that they experienced a little bit of what they call impostor syndrome insofar as this feeling of Who am I to be asked to review somebody else's work?
What is peer review and where does it fit in academia? Let's say I've written an article and I w...
published: 23 Jul 2019
-
The Problem With Peer Review - Eric Weinstein | The Portal Podcast Clips
"Peer review is a cancer from outer space. It came from the biomedical community. It invaded science." - Eric Weinstein
In this portal podcast clip, Eric Weinstein discusses the issue of peer review with Bret Weinstein.
Please give this clip a LIKE and SUBSCRIBE for more clips every Wednesday.
--LINK TO MAIN EPISODE:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLb5hZLw44s
--CLIP SUGGESTION CREDITS:
BeefSandwich27, boqu, afke.
--WEBSITE:
https://ericweinstein.org/
--TWITTER:
https://twitter.com/ThePortalClips
--INSTAGRAM:
https://www.instagram.com/theportalclips/
We're trying to share important messages in bite-sized packets. If you enjoyed this clip, please share the video, it really does help a lot.
--SHARE THIS VIDEO:
https://youtu.be/U5sRYsMjiAQ
--QUOTES FROM THIS VIDEO:
"Peer-review is...
published: 09 Apr 2020
-
What's peer review?
In university, we constantly throw around the term “peer review.” What does it mean, and why is it important? This video will explain.
Visit us at https://brocku.ca/library
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/)
published: 23 Sep 2021
-
Open Peer Review: Transparency or Compromise? Interview with Gareth Dyke from ReviewerCredits
In celebration of Peer Review Week 2024, the Asian Council of Science Editors brings you an exclusive interview series with Industry experts on the most pressing topics in peer review!
In this interview, Gareth shares his journey in the field, explores the benefits and challenges of open peer review, and addresses key concerns like confidentiality. He also offers a future outlook on whether open peer review will become the standard and provides valuable advice for early-career researchers. Tune in to explore more about transparency, innovation, and the future of peer review.
Stay tuned, share your thoughts, and join the conversation as we explore the future of scholarly publishing together! 🌟
#acse2024 #PeerReview #InnovationInPublishing #AIInPeerReview #ScholarlyPublishing#PRW2024#Pee...
published: 22 Sep 2024
3:15
Peer Review in 3 Minutes
How do articles get peer reviewed? What role does peer review play in scholarly research and publication? This video will explain.
This video is published unde...
How do articles get peer reviewed? What role does peer review play in scholarly research and publication? This video will explain.
This video is published under a Creative Commons 3.0 BY-NC-SA US license.
License, credits, and contact information can be found here: http://www.lib.ncsu.edu/tutorials/peerreview/
Feel free to link to / embed our videos!
https://wn.com/Peer_Review_In_3_Minutes
How do articles get peer reviewed? What role does peer review play in scholarly research and publication? This video will explain.
This video is published under a Creative Commons 3.0 BY-NC-SA US license.
License, credits, and contact information can be found here: http://www.lib.ncsu.edu/tutorials/peerreview/
Feel free to link to / embed our videos!
- published: 01 May 2014
- views: 978061
3:42
What is Peer Review?
Peer review is a quality control process used in academic and scholarly work. This video explains the term, the process and how to identify a peer reviewed arti...
Peer review is a quality control process used in academic and scholarly work. This video explains the term, the process and how to identify a peer reviewed article.
Key links from the video:
- Learn more about finding peer review resources: https://deakin.libguides.com/peer_review
- Learn more skills for your studies: https://www.deakin.edu.au/library/skills-for-study
https://wn.com/What_Is_Peer_Review
Peer review is a quality control process used in academic and scholarly work. This video explains the term, the process and how to identify a peer reviewed article.
Key links from the video:
- Learn more about finding peer review resources: https://deakin.libguides.com/peer_review
- Learn more skills for your studies: https://www.deakin.edu.au/library/skills-for-study
- published: 10 Jul 2020
- views: 47363
2:38
What is peer review?
What is Peer Review?
Brought to you by the University of Houston Libraries
As part of your own research, it is important to show that you are engaged in the sc...
What is Peer Review?
Brought to you by the University of Houston Libraries
As part of your own research, it is important to show that you are engaged in the scholarly conversation in your subject area, and one way of doing that is by reading and citing articles from peer-reviewed journals. You may hear articles in these journals referred to as academic or scholarly articles as well, but peer review refers to the specific process the articles goes through to be published in one of these journals.
The process starts with the submission of a research paper to a journal. The editor checks the quality of the paper and determines if the paper fits the scope of the journal before sending it out for review. If so, they pass it on to two or three other reviewers. These reviewers are other experts within the same discipline who have the necessary knowledge to determine whether the paper offers original, quality research. They read the paper, make comments and suggestions, and recommend to the editor whether the paper should be accepted, rejected, or revised. If there are revisions to be made, those are sent to the author, who can then resubmit their article for further review after making the necessary changes. Once a paper is accepted, it is published and available to read.
This process takes time, and can sometimes mean that research is published many months after it’s been submitted, but the careful consideration of each paper is what helps ensure its quality.
However, it’s important to remember that this process isn’t fool-proof. Just because an article has gone through peer-review does not mean you can automatically assume it is perfect. You should still evaluate each article just as you would any other piece of information, especially since quality can vary between journals and the scholarly conversation continues well after publication. Peer-reviewed articles can be and have been critiqued, or, in extreme cases, outright retracted, so always keep a critical eye on what you read.
Not all academic journals have a peer-review process. If you want to confirm whether a research article is peer-reviewed, you will want to research the journal’s publication process. You can do this by investigating the journal website online or on the Ulrichsweb database available through the UH Library library’s website. Many other academic databases also have features that allow you to limit search results to peer-reviewed articles.
As you start you to look for peer-reviewed articles for your research, you can always reach out to the UH Libraries for help.
https://wn.com/What_Is_Peer_Review
What is Peer Review?
Brought to you by the University of Houston Libraries
As part of your own research, it is important to show that you are engaged in the scholarly conversation in your subject area, and one way of doing that is by reading and citing articles from peer-reviewed journals. You may hear articles in these journals referred to as academic or scholarly articles as well, but peer review refers to the specific process the articles goes through to be published in one of these journals.
The process starts with the submission of a research paper to a journal. The editor checks the quality of the paper and determines if the paper fits the scope of the journal before sending it out for review. If so, they pass it on to two or three other reviewers. These reviewers are other experts within the same discipline who have the necessary knowledge to determine whether the paper offers original, quality research. They read the paper, make comments and suggestions, and recommend to the editor whether the paper should be accepted, rejected, or revised. If there are revisions to be made, those are sent to the author, who can then resubmit their article for further review after making the necessary changes. Once a paper is accepted, it is published and available to read.
This process takes time, and can sometimes mean that research is published many months after it’s been submitted, but the careful consideration of each paper is what helps ensure its quality.
However, it’s important to remember that this process isn’t fool-proof. Just because an article has gone through peer-review does not mean you can automatically assume it is perfect. You should still evaluate each article just as you would any other piece of information, especially since quality can vary between journals and the scholarly conversation continues well after publication. Peer-reviewed articles can be and have been critiqued, or, in extreme cases, outright retracted, so always keep a critical eye on what you read.
Not all academic journals have a peer-review process. If you want to confirm whether a research article is peer-reviewed, you will want to research the journal’s publication process. You can do this by investigating the journal website online or on the Ulrichsweb database available through the UH Library library’s website. Many other academic databases also have features that allow you to limit search results to peer-reviewed articles.
As you start you to look for peer-reviewed articles for your research, you can always reach out to the UH Libraries for help.
- published: 13 Nov 2019
- views: 3924
4:51
How to Write Effective Peer Review Comments
What's the difference between higher-order and lower-order concerns in peer review, and how can I write effective peer review comments? Find out in this video. ...
What's the difference between higher-order and lower-order concerns in peer review, and how can I write effective peer review comments? Find out in this video.
Video creators: Tim Becker, Julia Feerrar, Yemi Awotayo
Video contributors: Chloe Robertson, Kayla McNabb, Katlyn Griffin, Lisa Becksford
For other videos in this series, visit odyssey.lib.vt.edu.
https://wn.com/How_To_Write_Effective_Peer_Review_Comments
What's the difference between higher-order and lower-order concerns in peer review, and how can I write effective peer review comments? Find out in this video.
Video creators: Tim Becker, Julia Feerrar, Yemi Awotayo
Video contributors: Chloe Robertson, Kayla McNabb, Katlyn Griffin, Lisa Becksford
For other videos in this series, visit odyssey.lib.vt.edu.
- published: 19 Aug 2020
- views: 100051
3:50
Scientific Peer Review, ca. 1945
Herr Professor has his latest manuscript reviews back, and he's not thrilled with the editorial decision.
Herr Professor has his latest manuscript reviews back, and he's not thrilled with the editorial decision.
https://wn.com/Scientific_Peer_Review,_Ca._1945
Herr Professor has his latest manuscript reviews back, and he's not thrilled with the editorial decision.
- published: 19 Nov 2009
- views: 1301802
17:01
How to Peer-Review Like a Pro (Step-by-Step Guide)
In this episode of Navigating Academia, Dr. Singh discusses step-by-step how you can do a peer review for an article that you've been assigned by an academic jo...
In this episode of Navigating Academia, Dr. Singh discusses step-by-step how you can do a peer review for an article that you've been assigned by an academic journal.
Knowing how to do a peer-review for academic journal articles is an absolutely critical skill to know for your career in academia.
👉Learn how to get on the editorial board of an academic journal in this video:
https://youtu.be/zYu0tmLzO7
Especially if you don't have a lot of experience with a peer-review process this can be pretty daunting. A lot of people even report to me that they experienced a little bit of what they call impostor syndrome insofar as this feeling of Who am I to be asked to review somebody else's work?
What is peer review and where does it fit in academia? Let's say I've written an article and I want to get it published in an academic journal and hopefully a really good one with the high impact factor.
Step 1 - Download and read the entire article
Step 2 - Write a summary paragraph of the article
Step 3 - Make a list of all the sections
Step 4 - Make bulleted comments under each section heading
Step 5 - Submit it
Navigating Academia is your leading source for professional guidance on how to advance your career in academia. Hosted by internationally-renowned Cambridge and UPenn faculty member, Dr. Jay Phoenix Singh, this series provides practical advice for tackling the field’s biggest challenges.
SCHEDULE A COACHING SESSION: https://www.jayphoenixsingh.com
SCHEDULE A SPEAKING ENGAGEMENT:
[email protected]
DONATE TO OUR CHANNEL: https://www.venmo.com/drphoenixsingh
FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA:
@DrPhoenixSingh
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/drphoenixsingh
Twitter: https://twitter.com/drphoenixsingh
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/drphoenixsingh
Snapchat: @DrPhoenixSingh
#NavigatingAcademia
ABOUT DR. SINGH
Jay Phoenix Singh, PhD, PhD is a Fulbright Scholar, faculty at both UPenn as well as Cambridge, and the internationally award-winning Founder of the Global Institute of Forensic Research (successful 2017 exit as CEO).
Author of over 75 peer-reviewed articles and books, he completed his graduate doctoral studies in psychiatry at the University of Oxford and clinical psychology at Universitat Konstanz. He was named the youngest tenured Full Professor in Norway in 2014 and, since this time, has become the only psychology professor to have lectured for all eight Ivy League universities (Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Columbia, Cornell, Brown, Dartmouth, UPenn) as well as both Oxford and Cambridge. Dr. Singh is a charismatic academic mentor and coach who uses evidence-based practices to improve the lives of academics of all levels. #phdlife
https://wn.com/How_To_Peer_Review_Like_A_Pro_(Step_By_Step_Guide)
In this episode of Navigating Academia, Dr. Singh discusses step-by-step how you can do a peer review for an article that you've been assigned by an academic journal.
Knowing how to do a peer-review for academic journal articles is an absolutely critical skill to know for your career in academia.
👉Learn how to get on the editorial board of an academic journal in this video:
https://youtu.be/zYu0tmLzO7
Especially if you don't have a lot of experience with a peer-review process this can be pretty daunting. A lot of people even report to me that they experienced a little bit of what they call impostor syndrome insofar as this feeling of Who am I to be asked to review somebody else's work?
What is peer review and where does it fit in academia? Let's say I've written an article and I want to get it published in an academic journal and hopefully a really good one with the high impact factor.
Step 1 - Download and read the entire article
Step 2 - Write a summary paragraph of the article
Step 3 - Make a list of all the sections
Step 4 - Make bulleted comments under each section heading
Step 5 - Submit it
Navigating Academia is your leading source for professional guidance on how to advance your career in academia. Hosted by internationally-renowned Cambridge and UPenn faculty member, Dr. Jay Phoenix Singh, this series provides practical advice for tackling the field’s biggest challenges.
SCHEDULE A COACHING SESSION: https://www.jayphoenixsingh.com
SCHEDULE A SPEAKING ENGAGEMENT:
[email protected]
DONATE TO OUR CHANNEL: https://www.venmo.com/drphoenixsingh
FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA:
@DrPhoenixSingh
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/drphoenixsingh
Twitter: https://twitter.com/drphoenixsingh
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/drphoenixsingh
Snapchat: @DrPhoenixSingh
#NavigatingAcademia
ABOUT DR. SINGH
Jay Phoenix Singh, PhD, PhD is a Fulbright Scholar, faculty at both UPenn as well as Cambridge, and the internationally award-winning Founder of the Global Institute of Forensic Research (successful 2017 exit as CEO).
Author of over 75 peer-reviewed articles and books, he completed his graduate doctoral studies in psychiatry at the University of Oxford and clinical psychology at Universitat Konstanz. He was named the youngest tenured Full Professor in Norway in 2014 and, since this time, has become the only psychology professor to have lectured for all eight Ivy League universities (Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Columbia, Cornell, Brown, Dartmouth, UPenn) as well as both Oxford and Cambridge. Dr. Singh is a charismatic academic mentor and coach who uses evidence-based practices to improve the lives of academics of all levels. #phdlife
- published: 23 Jul 2019
- views: 67223
6:18
The Problem With Peer Review - Eric Weinstein | The Portal Podcast Clips
"Peer review is a cancer from outer space. It came from the biomedical community. It invaded science." - Eric Weinstein
In this portal podcast clip, Eric Wein...
"Peer review is a cancer from outer space. It came from the biomedical community. It invaded science." - Eric Weinstein
In this portal podcast clip, Eric Weinstein discusses the issue of peer review with Bret Weinstein.
Please give this clip a LIKE and SUBSCRIBE for more clips every Wednesday.
--LINK TO MAIN EPISODE:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLb5hZLw44s
--CLIP SUGGESTION CREDITS:
BeefSandwich27, boqu, afke.
--WEBSITE:
https://ericweinstein.org/
--TWITTER:
https://twitter.com/ThePortalClips
--INSTAGRAM:
https://www.instagram.com/theportalclips/
We're trying to share important messages in bite-sized packets. If you enjoyed this clip, please share the video, it really does help a lot.
--SHARE THIS VIDEO:
https://youtu.be/U5sRYsMjiAQ
--QUOTES FROM THIS VIDEO:
"Peer-review is not peer-review. It sounds like peer-review. It is peer-injunction. It is the ability for your peers to keep the world from learning about your work."
"There are reasons that great work cannot be peer-reviewed. Furthermore, you have entire fields that are existing now with electronic archives that are not peer-reviewed."
#ericweinstein #peerreview #theportalpodcast
https://wn.com/The_Problem_With_Peer_Review_Eric_Weinstein_|_The_Portal_Podcast_Clips
"Peer review is a cancer from outer space. It came from the biomedical community. It invaded science." - Eric Weinstein
In this portal podcast clip, Eric Weinstein discusses the issue of peer review with Bret Weinstein.
Please give this clip a LIKE and SUBSCRIBE for more clips every Wednesday.
--LINK TO MAIN EPISODE:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLb5hZLw44s
--CLIP SUGGESTION CREDITS:
BeefSandwich27, boqu, afke.
--WEBSITE:
https://ericweinstein.org/
--TWITTER:
https://twitter.com/ThePortalClips
--INSTAGRAM:
https://www.instagram.com/theportalclips/
We're trying to share important messages in bite-sized packets. If you enjoyed this clip, please share the video, it really does help a lot.
--SHARE THIS VIDEO:
https://youtu.be/U5sRYsMjiAQ
--QUOTES FROM THIS VIDEO:
"Peer-review is not peer-review. It sounds like peer-review. It is peer-injunction. It is the ability for your peers to keep the world from learning about your work."
"There are reasons that great work cannot be peer-reviewed. Furthermore, you have entire fields that are existing now with electronic archives that are not peer-reviewed."
#ericweinstein #peerreview #theportalpodcast
- published: 09 Apr 2020
- views: 87867
1:34
What's peer review?
In university, we constantly throw around the term “peer review.” What does it mean, and why is it important? This video will explain.
Visit us at https://broc...
In university, we constantly throw around the term “peer review.” What does it mean, and why is it important? This video will explain.
Visit us at https://brocku.ca/library
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/)
https://wn.com/What's_Peer_Review
In university, we constantly throw around the term “peer review.” What does it mean, and why is it important? This video will explain.
Visit us at https://brocku.ca/library
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/)
- published: 23 Sep 2021
- views: 3876
11:46
Open Peer Review: Transparency or Compromise? Interview with Gareth Dyke from ReviewerCredits
In celebration of Peer Review Week 2024, the Asian Council of Science Editors brings you an exclusive interview series with Industry experts on the most pressin...
In celebration of Peer Review Week 2024, the Asian Council of Science Editors brings you an exclusive interview series with Industry experts on the most pressing topics in peer review!
In this interview, Gareth shares his journey in the field, explores the benefits and challenges of open peer review, and addresses key concerns like confidentiality. He also offers a future outlook on whether open peer review will become the standard and provides valuable advice for early-career researchers. Tune in to explore more about transparency, innovation, and the future of peer review.
Stay tuned, share your thoughts, and join the conversation as we explore the future of scholarly publishing together! 🌟
#acse2024 #PeerReview #InnovationInPublishing #AIInPeerReview #ScholarlyPublishing#PRW2024#PeerReviewWeek
https://wn.com/Open_Peer_Review_Transparency_Or_Compromise_Interview_With_Gareth_Dyke_From_Reviewercredits
In celebration of Peer Review Week 2024, the Asian Council of Science Editors brings you an exclusive interview series with Industry experts on the most pressing topics in peer review!
In this interview, Gareth shares his journey in the field, explores the benefits and challenges of open peer review, and addresses key concerns like confidentiality. He also offers a future outlook on whether open peer review will become the standard and provides valuable advice for early-career researchers. Tune in to explore more about transparency, innovation, and the future of peer review.
Stay tuned, share your thoughts, and join the conversation as we explore the future of scholarly publishing together! 🌟
#acse2024 #PeerReview #InnovationInPublishing #AIInPeerReview #ScholarlyPublishing#PRW2024#PeerReviewWeek
- published: 22 Sep 2024
- views: 378