Cloudbuild Example","permissions":{"edit":false,"delete":false,"__typename":"Permissions"},"publishedAt":"2019-06-05T14:39:00Z","decisionType":"giveAdvice","rootComments":[],"subjectTools":[{"id":"101231778086278044","fans":320,"name":"Google Cloud Build","path":"/google-cloud-build","slug":"google-cloud-build","title":"Continuously build, test, and deploy.","votes":4,"stacks":492,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/9309/PoHJY3K8_400x400.jpg","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/google-cloud-build","followContext":null}],"upvotesCount":4,"commentsCount":0},"__typename":"StackDecisionEdge"},{"node":{"id":"101947949895188911","link":null,"user":{"id":"101232116468327845","path":"/akarsh3007","title":null,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/244413/default_fd332a4eefedfca42f251f060bf8b454d8181713.jpeg","username":"akarsh3007","__typename":"User","companyName":null,"displayName":"akarsh3007"},"draft":false,"topics":[],"company":null,"flagged":false,"private":false,"toTools":[],"upvoted":false,"publicId":"101947949895188911","services":[{"id":"101231773636491087","fans":9387,"name":"Travis CI","path":"/travis-ci","slug":"travis-ci","title":"A hosted continuous integration service for open source and private projects","votes":1749,"stacks":26379,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/460/Lu6cGu0z_400x400.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/travis-ci","followContext":null}],"createdAt":"2019-04-18T15:44:22Z","fromTools":[],"viewCount":502986,"__typename":"StackDecision","bookmarked":false,"rawContent":"I use @{Travis CI}|tool:460| because of various reasons -\r\n1. Cloud based system so no dedicated server required, and you do not need to administrate it.\r\n2. Easy YAML configuration.\r\n3. Supports Major Programming Languages.\r\n4. Support of build matrix\r\n6. Supports AWS, Azure, Docker, Heroku, Google Cloud, Github Pages, PyPi and lot more. \r\n7. Slack Notifications.","htmlContent":"I use Travis CI because of various reasons -\r\n1. Cloud based system so no dedicated server required, and you do not need to administrate it.\r\n2. Easy YAML configuration.\r\n3. Supports Major Programming Languages.\r\n4. Support of build matrix\r\n6. Supports AWS, Azure, Docker, Heroku, Google Cloud, Github Pages, PyPi and lot more. \r\n7. Slack Notifications.","permissions":{"edit":false,"delete":false,"__typename":"Permissions"},"publishedAt":"2019-04-18T15:44:00Z","decisionType":"giveAdvice","rootComments":[],"subjectTools":[{"id":"101231773636491087","fans":9387,"name":"Travis CI","path":"/travis-ci","slug":"travis-ci","title":"A hosted continuous integration service for open source and private projects","votes":1749,"stacks":26379,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/460/Lu6cGu0z_400x400.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/travis-ci","followContext":null}],"upvotesCount":3,"commentsCount":0},"__typename":"StackDecisionEdge"},{"node":{"id":"104047714336945946","link":null,"user":{"id":"101232017476386990","path":"/guss77","title":"CTO","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/56435/default_7e490f6d3969671c7031decf1c38fb57eb0e8e65.png","username":"guss77","__typename":"User","companyName":"Cloudonix LTD.","displayName":"Oded Arbel"},"draft":false,"topics":[],"company":null,"flagged":false,"private":false,"toTools":[],"upvoted":false,"publicId":"104047714336945946","services":[],"createdAt":"2020-04-23T11:42:05Z","fromTools":[],"viewCount":501206,"__typename":"StackDecision","bookmarked":false,"rawContent":"You are probably looking at another hosted solution: Jenkins is a good tool but it way too work intensive to be used as just a backup solution. \n\nI have good experience with Circle-CI, Codeship, Drone.io and Travis (as well as problematic experiences with all of them), but my go-to tool is Gitlab CI: simple, powerful and if you have problems with their limitations or pricing, you can always install runners somewhere and use Gitlab just for scheduling and management. Even if you don't host your git repository at Gitlab, you can have Gitlab pull changes automatically from wherever you repo lives.","htmlContent":"You are probably looking at another hosted solution: Jenkins is a good tool but it way too work intensive to be used as just a backup solution. \n\n
I have good experience with Circle-CI, Codeship, Drone.io and Travis (as well as problematic experiences with all of them), but my go-to tool is Gitlab CI: simple, powerful and if you have problems with their limitations or pricing, you can always install runners somewhere and use Gitlab just for scheduling and management. Even if you don't host your git repository at Gitlab, you can have Gitlab pull changes automatically from wherever you repo lives.","permissions":{"edit":false,"delete":false,"__typename":"Permissions"},"publishedAt":"2020-04-23T11:42:05Z","decisionType":"giveAdvice","rootComments":[],"subjectTools":[{"id":"101231776189486570","fans":2279,"name":"GitLab CI","path":"/gitlab-ci","slug":"gitlab-ci","title":"GitLab integrated CI to test, build and deploy your code","votes":75,"stacks":2299,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/5545/9pAwHBR0.jpg","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/gitlab-ci","followContext":null}],"upvotesCount":2,"commentsCount":0},"__typename":"StackDecisionEdge"},{"node":{"id":"103563095144095359","link":null,"user":{"id":"101231989244311357","path":"/andyshinn","title":null,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/249/default_f741058d0fae95ce91baf2873eceddba9cf6a028.png","username":"andyshinn","__typename":"User","companyName":null,"displayName":"Andy Shinn"},"draft":false,"topics":[],"company":null,"flagged":false,"private":false,"toTools":[],"upvoted":false,"publicId":"103563095144095359","services":[],"createdAt":"2020-01-28T21:37:03Z","fromTools":[],"viewCount":501133,"__typename":"StackDecision","bookmarked":false,"rawContent":"If you are considering Jenkins I would recommend at least checking out Buildkite. The agents are self-hosted (like Jenkins) but the interface is hosted for you. It meshes up some of the things I like about hosted services (pipeline definitions in YAML, managed interface and authentication) with things I like about Jenkins (local customizable agent images, secrets only on own instances, custom agent level scripts, sizing instances to your needs).","htmlContent":"
If you are considering Jenkins I would recommend at least checking out Buildkite. The agents are self-hosted (like Jenkins) but the interface is hosted for you. It meshes up some of the things I like about hosted services (pipeline definitions in YAML, managed interface and authentication) with things I like about Jenkins (local customizable agent images, secrets only on own instances, custom agent level scripts, sizing instances to your needs).","permissions":{"edit":false,"delete":false,"__typename":"Permissions"},"publishedAt":"2020-01-28T21:37:03Z","decisionType":"giveAdvice","rootComments":[],"subjectTools":[{"id":"101231773665355731","fans":280,"name":"Buildkite","path":"/buildkite","slug":"buildkite","title":"Fast, secure and scalable CI/CD for all your software projects","votes":115,"stacks":212,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/577/default_2d19e0c5c214c1ba5cd484c8463d7dfe88eb2328.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/buildkite","followContext":null}],"upvotesCount":1,"commentsCount":0},"__typename":"StackDecisionEdge"}],"pageInfo":{"endCursor":"Ng","__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false},"__typename":"StackDecisionConnection"},"company":null,"private":false,"toTools":[],"publicId":"102651056680533966","services":[],"fromTools":[],"viewCount":504462,"__typename":"StackDecision","htmlContent":"
From a StackShare Community member: \"Currently we use Travis CI and have optimized it as much as we can so our builds are fairly quick. Our boss is all about redundancy so we are looking for another solution to fall back on in case Travis goes down and/or jacks prices way up (they were recently acquired). Could someone recommend which CI we should go with and if they have time, an explanation of how they're different?\"","publishedAt":"2019-04-17T19:53:00Z","decisionType":"getAdvice","subjectTools":[{"id":"101231773703650742","fans":58553,"name":"Jenkins","path":"/jenkins","slug":"jenkins","title":"An extendable open source continuous integration server","votes":2219,"stacks":58368,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/670/jenkins.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/jenkins","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773636491087","fans":9387,"name":"Travis CI","path":"/travis-ci","slug":"travis-ci","title":"A hosted continuous integration service for open source and private projects","votes":1749,"stacks":26379,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/460/Lu6cGu0z_400x400.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/travis-ci","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773501041914","fans":9480,"name":"CircleCI","path":"/circleci","slug":"circleci","title":"Automate your development process quickly, safely, and at scale","votes":974,"stacks":12828,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/190/CvqrSSFs_400x400.jpg","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/circleci","followContext":null}],"upvotesCount":3},"__typename":"StackDecisionEdge"}],"pageInfo":{"endCursor":"NA","__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false},"__typename":"StackDecisionConnection"}},"privateStackDecisionsGetAdvice({\"first\":3})":{"type":"id","generated":true,"id":"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).privateStackDecisionsGetAdvice({\"first\":3})","typename":"StackDecisionConnection"},"cachedStackDecisions":{"type":"json","json":{"count":8,"edges":[{"node":{"id":"107145898820600911","user":{"id":"107145557076312948","title":"Engineering Team Lead","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/1058890/default_192f8b7c38943c6c24658acc4888bb9d313cb215.jpg","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/1058890/thumb_192f8b7c38943c6c24658acc4888bb9d313cb215.jpg","username":"astolze","__typename":"User","companyName":"DCMN GmbH","displayName":"A Stolze"},"stack":null,"topics":[],"company":{"name":"DCMN GmbH","path":"/companies/dcmn","features":[],"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/171047/default_9987f6d05a3a5242dd84f69226fbca85eb9d5f24.png","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/171047/thumb_9987f6d05a3a5242dd84f69226fbca85eb9d5f24.png","__typename":"Company"},"private":false,"toTools":[{"id":"103249435143679064","fans":4792,"name":"GitHub Actions","path":"/github-actions","slug":"github-actions","title":"Automate your workflow from idea to production","votes":27,"stacks":23550,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/11563/actions.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/github-actions","followContext":null}],"publicId":"107145898820600911","services":[],"fromTools":[{"id":"101231776475458733","fans":614,"name":"AWS CodeBuild","path":"/aws-codebuild","slug":"aws-codebuild","title":"Build and test code with continuous scaling","votes":43,"stacks":375,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/6086/aws-codebuild.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/aws-codebuild","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773703650742","fans":58553,"name":"Jenkins","path":"/jenkins","slug":"jenkins","title":"An extendable open source continuous integration server","votes":2219,"stacks":58368,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/670/jenkins.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/jenkins","followContext":null}],"viewCount":69686,"__typename":"StackDecision","htmlContent":"
Github Actions allowed us to drop previous CI/CD technologies like Jenkins or AWS CodeBuild. The main advantages for us are:\n- The Infrastructure-as-Code approach of Github Actions enables us to keep CI/CD configurations next to the code.\n- Github as a single platform for repositories and CI/CD simplifies our stack and effort to manage it on the daily basis.\n\n
TVcloud Team <3 Github Actions","publishedAt":"2021-10-22T15:31:08Z","decisionType":"tool","subjectTools":[{"id":"103249435143679064","fans":4792,"name":"GitHub Actions","path":"/github-actions","slug":"github-actions","title":"Automate your workflow from idea to production","votes":27,"stacks":23550,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/11563/actions.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/github-actions","followContext":null},{"id":"101231776475458733","fans":614,"name":"AWS CodeBuild","path":"/aws-codebuild","slug":"aws-codebuild","title":"Build and test code with continuous scaling","votes":43,"stacks":375,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/6086/aws-codebuild.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/aws-codebuild","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773703650742","fans":58553,"name":"Jenkins","path":"/jenkins","slug":"jenkins","title":"An extendable open source continuous integration server","votes":2219,"stacks":58368,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/670/jenkins.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/jenkins","followContext":null}],"upvotesCount":7},"__typename":"StackDecisionEdge"},{"node":{"id":"106177743645259195","user":{"id":"106177115562555307","title":"Head of Engineering","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/960110/default_8bc395ca2df6b9f0df455b07beb4d0f59f2607db.jpg","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/960110/thumb_8bc395ca2df6b9f0df455b07beb4d0f59f2607db.jpg","username":"pedrocarvalho7317","__typename":"User","companyName":"Lengoo GmbH","displayName":"Pedro Gil Carvalho"},"stack":{"id":"101231803637560527","name":"lengoo GmbH","path":"/lengoo-gmbh/lengoo-gmbh","owner":{"id":"101231721557601641","name":"lengoo GmbH","slug":"lengoo-gmbh","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/25789/default_b95bb6a5ef8de592c6ce176a7ea0f3db30372508.png","__typename":"Company"},"private":false,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/stack/57395/default_6c31ad1ecc16a566fb6b686f543effe36eee0676.png","__typename":"Stack","identifier":"lengoo-gmbh/lengoo-gmbh"},"topics":[],"company":{"name":"lengoo GmbH","path":"/companies/lengoo-gmbh","features":[],"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/25789/default_b95bb6a5ef8de592c6ce176a7ea0f3db30372508.png","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/25789/thumb_b95bb6a5ef8de592c6ce176a7ea0f3db30372508.png","__typename":"Company"},"private":false,"toTools":[{"id":"103249435143679064","fans":4792,"name":"GitHub Actions","path":"/github-actions","slug":"github-actions","title":"Automate your workflow from idea to production","votes":27,"stacks":23550,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/11563/actions.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/github-actions","followContext":null}],"publicId":"106177743645259195","services":[],"fromTools":[{"id":"101231773703650742","fans":58553,"name":"Jenkins","path":"/jenkins","slug":"jenkins","title":"An extendable open source continuous integration server","votes":2219,"stacks":58368,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/670/jenkins.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/jenkins","followContext":null}],"viewCount":74107,"__typename":"StackDecision","htmlContent":"
We replaced Jenkins with Github Actions for all our repositories hosted on Github. GA has two significant benefits for us compared to an external build tool: it's simpler, and it sits at eye level.\n\n
Its simplicity and smooth user experience makes it easier for all developers to adopt, giving them more autonomy.\n\n
Sitting at eye level means it's completely run and configured right alongside the code, so that it's easier to observe and adjust our builds as we go.\n\n
These two benefits have made \"the build\" less of a system engineer responsibility and more of a developer tool, giving developers more ownership from code to release.","publishedAt":"2021-05-04T15:56:32Z","decisionType":"tool","subjectTools":[{"id":"103249435143679064","fans":4792,"name":"GitHub Actions","path":"/github-actions","slug":"github-actions","title":"Automate your workflow from idea to production","votes":27,"stacks":23550,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/11563/actions.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/github-actions","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773703650742","fans":58553,"name":"Jenkins","path":"/jenkins","slug":"jenkins","title":"An extendable open source continuous integration server","votes":2219,"stacks":58368,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/670/jenkins.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/jenkins","followContext":null}],"upvotesCount":6},"__typename":"StackDecisionEdge"},{"node":{"id":"105748076426902723","user":{"id":"105582170996797394","title":"GO/C developer","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/852897/default_f849b8f82aa33a93afaf7cad8c322817c4e48a8e.jpg","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/852897/thumb_f849b8f82aa33a93afaf7cad8c322817c4e48a8e.jpg","username":"ducklingsoftware","__typename":"User","companyName":null,"displayName":"Kirill Mikhailov"},"stack":{"id":"105645572548407698","name":"Duckling Sales","path":"/duckling-sales/duckling-sales","owner":{"id":"105645565068484055","name":"Duckling Sales","slug":"duckling-sales","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/167358/default_86ad5cebe22e90de8fa56064d885126a03376cc8.png","__typename":"Company"},"private":false,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/stack/803761/default_998321e1565807c8bdc85d2b7eb977af94e1dbdb.png","__typename":"Stack","identifier":"duckling-sales/duckling-sales"},"topics":[],"company":{"name":"Duckling Sales","path":"/companies/duckling-sales","features":[],"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/167358/default_86ad5cebe22e90de8fa56064d885126a03376cc8.png","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/167358/thumb_86ad5cebe22e90de8fa56064d885126a03376cc8.png","__typename":"Company"},"private":false,"toTools":[{"id":"101231773703650742","fans":58553,"name":"Jenkins","path":"/jenkins","slug":"jenkins","title":"An extendable open source continuous integration server","votes":2219,"stacks":58368,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/670/jenkins.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/jenkins","followContext":null}],"publicId":"105748076426902723","services":[],"fromTools":[{"id":"101231777164258494","fans":474,"name":"Bitbucket Pipelines","path":"/bitbucket-pipeline","slug":"bitbucket-pipeline","title":"An Integrated continuous integration and continuous deployment for Bitbucket","votes":0,"stacks":348,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/7452/35O2KIRX_400x400.jpg","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/bitbucket-pipeline","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773501041914","fans":9480,"name":"CircleCI","path":"/circleci","slug":"circleci","title":"Automate your development process quickly, safely, and at scale","votes":974,"stacks":12828,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/190/CvqrSSFs_400x400.jpg","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/circleci","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773636491087","fans":9387,"name":"Travis CI","path":"/travis-ci","slug":"travis-ci","title":"A hosted continuous integration service for open source and private projects","votes":1749,"stacks":26379,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/460/Lu6cGu0z_400x400.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/travis-ci","followContext":null}],"viewCount":143953,"__typename":"StackDecision","htmlContent":"
Jenkins is a friend of mine. 😀\n\n
There are not much space for Jenkins competitors for now from my point of view. With declarative pipelines now in place, its super easy to maintain them and create new ones(altho I prefer scripted still). Self-hosted, free, huge community makes it the top choice so honestly for me it was an easy pick.","publishedAt":"2021-02-17T18:46:31Z","decisionType":"tool","subjectTools":[{"id":"101231773703650742","fans":58553,"name":"Jenkins","path":"/jenkins","slug":"jenkins","title":"An extendable open source continuous integration server","votes":2219,"stacks":58368,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/670/jenkins.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/jenkins","followContext":null},{"id":"101231777164258494","fans":474,"name":"Bitbucket Pipelines","path":"/bitbucket-pipeline","slug":"bitbucket-pipeline","title":"An Integrated continuous integration and continuous deployment for Bitbucket","votes":0,"stacks":348,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/7452/35O2KIRX_400x400.jpg","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/bitbucket-pipeline","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773501041914","fans":9480,"name":"CircleCI","path":"/circleci","slug":"circleci","title":"Automate your development process quickly, safely, and at scale","votes":974,"stacks":12828,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/190/CvqrSSFs_400x400.jpg","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/circleci","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773636491087","fans":9387,"name":"Travis CI","path":"/travis-ci","slug":"travis-ci","title":"A hosted continuous integration service for open source and private projects","votes":1749,"stacks":26379,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/460/Lu6cGu0z_400x400.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/travis-ci","followContext":null}],"upvotesCount":3},"__typename":"StackDecisionEdge"},{"node":{"id":"105707463604220713","user":{"id":"105702517100043649","title":"","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/876370/default_c89ec26db895bc802042c7f816b13cf6232e28c2.jpeg","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/876370/thumb_c89ec26db895bc802042c7f816b13cf6232e28c2.jpeg","username":"johngiorgi","__typename":"User","companyName":"","displayName":"John Giorgi"},"stack":{"id":"105704089690050964","name":"Athology","path":"/dcsil/athology","owner":{"id":"103516412385155261","name":"DCSIL","slug":"dcsil","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/160458/default_5bd666023dd9ef07268ae13d7cc98a7e19ed9e63.png","__typename":"Company"},"private":false,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/stack/810009/default_dc454c91b5c000714d2f9f85581cf772560b1250.png","__typename":"Stack","identifier":"dcsil/athology"},"topics":[],"company":{"name":"DCSIL","path":"/companies/dcsil","features":[],"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/160458/default_5bd666023dd9ef07268ae13d7cc98a7e19ed9e63.png","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/160458/thumb_5bd666023dd9ef07268ae13d7cc98a7e19ed9e63.png","__typename":"Company"},"private":false,"toTools":[{"id":"103249435143679064","fans":4792,"name":"GitHub Actions","path":"/github-actions","slug":"github-actions","title":"Automate your workflow from idea to production","votes":27,"stacks":23550,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/11563/actions.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/github-actions","followContext":null}],"publicId":"105707463604220713","services":[],"fromTools":[{"id":"101231773636491087","fans":9387,"name":"Travis CI","path":"/travis-ci","slug":"travis-ci","title":"A hosted continuous integration service for open source and private projects","votes":1749,"stacks":26379,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/460/Lu6cGu0z_400x400.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/travis-ci","followContext":null}],"viewCount":33587,"__typename":"StackDecision","htmlContent":"
When choosing a tool to help automate our CI/CD, the decision came down to GitHub Actions (GA) or TravisCI. Both are great, but the team has more experience with GA. Given GAs broad support of languages and workflows, it's hard to go wrong with this decision. We will also be using GitHub for version control and project management, so having everything in one place is convenient.","publishedAt":"2021-02-10T14:38:09Z","decisionType":"tool","subjectTools":[{"id":"103249435143679064","fans":4792,"name":"GitHub Actions","path":"/github-actions","slug":"github-actions","title":"Automate your workflow from idea to production","votes":27,"stacks":23550,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/11563/actions.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/github-actions","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773636491087","fans":9387,"name":"Travis CI","path":"/travis-ci","slug":"travis-ci","title":"A hosted continuous integration service for open source and private projects","votes":1749,"stacks":26379,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/460/Lu6cGu0z_400x400.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/travis-ci","followContext":null}],"upvotesCount":2},"__typename":"StackDecisionEdge"},{"node":{"id":"105182910688605191","user":{"id":"105072032120823938","title":"Senior DevOps Engineer","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/770167/default_a8db1989494fa5e7ff5a724be964a5aa3efb5f67.png","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/770167/thumb_a8db1989494fa5e7ff5a724be964a5aa3efb5f67.png","username":"stephenbadger","__typename":"User","companyName":"Vital Beats","displayName":"Stephen Badger | Vital Beats"},"stack":{"id":"104749764726425189","name":"Vital Beats","path":"/vital-beats/vital-beats","owner":{"id":"104749758567370040","name":"Vital Beats","slug":"vital-beats","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/165290/default_bf3bcb159fa3fb4954e6073eb26407d71fabd22f.png","__typename":"Company"},"private":false,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/stack/712018/default_d64c107f285133493854bd28bf7525aed404a5ad.png","__typename":"Stack","identifier":"vital-beats/vital-beats"},"topics":[],"company":{"name":"Vital Beats","path":"/companies/vital-beats","features":[],"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/165290/default_bf3bcb159fa3fb4954e6073eb26407d71fabd22f.png","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/165290/thumb_bf3bcb159fa3fb4954e6073eb26407d71fabd22f.png","__typename":"Company"},"private":false,"toTools":[{"id":"101231773703650742","fans":58553,"name":"Jenkins","path":"/jenkins","slug":"jenkins","title":"An extendable open source continuous integration server","votes":2219,"stacks":58368,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/670/jenkins.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/jenkins","followContext":null}],"publicId":"105182910688605191","services":[],"fromTools":[{"id":"103249435143679064","fans":4792,"name":"GitHub Actions","path":"/github-actions","slug":"github-actions","title":"Automate your workflow from idea to production","votes":27,"stacks":23550,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/11563/actions.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/github-actions","followContext":null}],"viewCount":231104,"__typename":"StackDecision","htmlContent":"
Within our deployment pipeline, we have a need to deploy to multiple customer environments, and manage secrets specifically in a way that integrates well with AWS, Kubernetes Secrets, Terraform and our pipelines ourselves.\n\n
Jenkins offered us the ability to choose one of a number of credentials/secrets management approaches, and models secrets as a more dynamic concept that GitHub Actions provided.\n\n
Additionally, we are operating Jenkins within our development Kubernetes cluster as a kind of system-wide orchestrator, allowing us to use Kubernetes pods as build agents, avoiding the ongoing direct costs associated with GitHub Actions minutes / per-user pricing. Obviously as a consequence we take on the indirect costs of maintain Jenkins itself, patching it, upgrading etc. However our experience with managing Jenkins via Kubernetes and declarative Jenkins configuration has led us to believe that this cost is small, particularly as the majority of actual building and testing is handled inside docker containers and Kubernetes, alleviating the need for less supported plugins that may make Jenkins administration more difficult.","publishedAt":"2020-11-09T23:17:26Z","decisionType":"tool","subjectTools":[{"id":"101231773703650742","fans":58553,"name":"Jenkins","path":"/jenkins","slug":"jenkins","title":"An extendable open source continuous integration server","votes":2219,"stacks":58368,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/670/jenkins.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/jenkins","followContext":null},{"id":"103249435143679064","fans":4792,"name":"GitHub Actions","path":"/github-actions","slug":"github-actions","title":"Automate your workflow from idea to production","votes":27,"stacks":23550,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/11563/actions.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/github-actions","followContext":null}],"upvotesCount":2},"__typename":"StackDecisionEdge"},{"node":{"id":"104221435272037519","user":{"id":"104186891633225440","title":"","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/594914/default_af75bf3e1b1662b7db80aee7cb8855171cbf5bb3.jpeg","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/594914/thumb_af75bf3e1b1662b7db80aee7cb8855171cbf5bb3.jpeg","username":"felipelincoln","__typename":"User","companyName":"","displayName":"Felipe Lincoln"},"stack":{"id":"104215443456465816","name":"drafthub","path":"/drafthub/drafthub","owner":{"id":"104215430706858444","name":"drafthub","slug":"drafthub","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/162057/default_bcc55446d091858a5351045279a8615a342330a6.png","__typename":"Company"},"private":false,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/stack/651778/default_b170f101811f8d959a87940a891619971a0eebb0.png","__typename":"Stack","identifier":"drafthub/drafthub"},"topics":[{"name":"Codecov","__typename":"Topic"}],"company":{"name":"drafthub","path":"/companies/drafthub","features":[],"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/162057/default_bcc55446d091858a5351045279a8615a342330a6.png","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/162057/thumb_bcc55446d091858a5351045279a8615a342330a6.png","__typename":"Company"},"private":false,"toTools":[],"publicId":"104221435272037519","services":[],"fromTools":[],"viewCount":187690,"__typename":"StackDecision","htmlContent":"
My website is brand new and one of the few requirements of testings I had to implement was code coverage. Never though it was so hard to implement using a #docker container.\nGiven my lack of experience, every attempt I tried on making a simple code coverage test using the 4 combinations of #TravisCI, #CircleCi with #Coveralls, #Codecov I failed. The main problem was I was generating the .coverage file within the docker container and couldn't access it with #TravisCi or #CircleCi, every attempt to solve this problem seems to be very hacky and this was not the kind of complexity I want to introduce to my newborn website.\nThis problem was solved using a specific action for #GitHubActions, it was a 3 line solution I had to put in my github workflow file and I was able to access the .coverage file from my docker container and get the coverage report with #Codecov.","publishedAt":"2020-05-24T04:01:36Z","decisionType":"freeform","subjectTools":[{"id":"101231773501041914","fans":9480,"name":"CircleCI","path":"/circleci","slug":"circleci","title":"Automate your development process quickly, safely, and at scale","votes":974,"stacks":12828,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/190/CvqrSSFs_400x400.jpg","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/circleci","followContext":null},{"id":"101231774531819761","fans":788,"name":"Codecov","path":"/codecov","slug":"codecov","title":"Hosted coverage reports with awesome features to enhance your CI workflow","votes":102,"stacks":2416,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/2673/Codecov_Mark_Circle_Pink.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/codecov","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773706845100","fans":625,"name":"Coveralls","path":"/coveralls","slug":"coveralls","title":"Track your project's code coverage over time, changes to files, and badge your GitHub repo","votes":68,"stacks":1360,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/680/a43e4a04cb9f778842de43f95db59a14.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/coveralls","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773669807419","fans":160848,"name":"Docker","path":"/docker","slug":"docker","title":"Enterprise Container Platform for High-Velocity Innovation.","votes":3857,"stacks":174409,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/586/n4u37v9t_400x400.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/docker","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773636491087","fans":9387,"name":"Travis CI","path":"/travis-ci","slug":"travis-ci","title":"A hosted continuous integration service for open source and private projects","votes":1749,"stacks":26379,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/460/Lu6cGu0z_400x400.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/travis-ci","followContext":null}],"upvotesCount":5},"__typename":"StackDecisionEdge"},{"node":{"id":"103285861617133156","user":{"id":"103241000390232585","title":"","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/322117/default_94e7f322e1c55a2c6933e225655f72e154034888.png","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/322117/thumb_94e7f322e1c55a2c6933e225655f72e154034888.png","username":"awatson1978","__typename":"User","companyName":"","displayName":"Abigail Watson"},"stack":{"id":"103281040246256187","name":"node-on-fhir","path":"/symptomatic-llc/node-on-fhir","owner":{"id":"103281033486168711","name":"Symptomatic, LLC","slug":"symptomatic-llc","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/159998/default_fd82ab62f0da36f082f88c5f5b3274f5d0e83901.png","__typename":"Company"},"private":false,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/stack/520113/default_8fc8fcd618e28b4497809bd37465a37b0f2efc45.png","__typename":"Stack","identifier":"symptomatic-llc/node-on-fhir"},"topics":[],"company":{"name":"Symptomatic, LLC","path":"/companies/symptomatic-llc","features":[],"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/159998/default_fd82ab62f0da36f082f88c5f5b3274f5d0e83901.png","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/company/159998/thumb_fd82ab62f0da36f082f88c5f5b3274f5d0e83901.png","__typename":"Company"},"private":false,"toTools":[{"id":"101231773501041914","fans":9480,"name":"CircleCI","path":"/circleci","slug":"circleci","title":"Automate your development process quickly, safely, and at scale","votes":974,"stacks":12828,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/190/CvqrSSFs_400x400.jpg","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/circleci","followContext":null}],"publicId":"103285861617133156","services":[],"fromTools":[{"id":"101231773636491087","fans":9387,"name":"Travis CI","path":"/travis-ci","slug":"travis-ci","title":"A hosted continuous integration service for open source and private projects","votes":1749,"stacks":26379,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/460/Lu6cGu0z_400x400.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/travis-ci","followContext":null}],"viewCount":132585,"__typename":"StackDecision","htmlContent":"We were long time users of TravisCI, but switched to CircleCI because of the better user interface and pricing. Version 2.0 has had a couple of trips and hiccups; but overall we've been very happy with the continuous integration it provides. Continuous Integration is a must-have for building software, and CircleCI continues to surprise as they roll out ideas and features. It's leading the industry in terms of innovation and new ideas, and it's exciting to see what new things they keep rolling out. ","publishedAt":"2019-12-10T22:32:55Z","decisionType":"tool","subjectTools":[{"id":"101231773501041914","fans":9480,"name":"CircleCI","path":"/circleci","slug":"circleci","title":"Automate your development process quickly, safely, and at scale","votes":974,"stacks":12828,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/190/CvqrSSFs_400x400.jpg","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/circleci","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773636491087","fans":9387,"name":"Travis CI","path":"/travis-ci","slug":"travis-ci","title":"A hosted continuous integration service for open source and private projects","votes":1749,"stacks":26379,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/460/Lu6cGu0z_400x400.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/travis-ci","followContext":null}],"upvotesCount":2},"__typename":"StackDecisionEdge"},{"node":{"id":"103149602061782255","user":{"id":"101232123862380966","title":"","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/259296/default_0d803c5c8476c90ec49049f2e483e8bd930d3750.jpeg","thumbUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/259296/thumb_0d803c5c8476c90ec49049f2e483e8bd930d3750.jpeg","username":"tdurova","__typename":"User","companyName":"","displayName":"Tatiana Durova"},"stack":{"id":"101231819479698567","name":"My Stack","path":"/tdurova/my-stack","owner":{"id":"101232123862380966","imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/user/259296/default_0d803c5c8476c90ec49049f2e483e8bd930d3750.jpeg","username":"tdurova","__typename":"User"},"private":false,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/stack/331163/default_0d803c5c8476c90ec49049f2e483e8bd930d3750.jpeg","__typename":"Stack","identifier":"tdurova/my-stack"},"topics":[],"company":null,"private":false,"toTools":[{"id":"101231773703650742","fans":58553,"name":"Jenkins","path":"/jenkins","slug":"jenkins","title":"An extendable open source continuous integration server","votes":2219,"stacks":58368,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/670/jenkins.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/jenkins","followContext":null}],"publicId":"103149602061782255","services":[],"fromTools":[{"id":"101231773501041914","fans":9480,"name":"CircleCI","path":"/circleci","slug":"circleci","title":"Automate your development process quickly, safely, and at scale","votes":974,"stacks":12828,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/190/CvqrSSFs_400x400.jpg","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/circleci","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773636491087","fans":9387,"name":"Travis CI","path":"/travis-ci","slug":"travis-ci","title":"A hosted continuous integration service for open source and private projects","votes":1749,"stacks":26379,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/460/Lu6cGu0z_400x400.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/travis-ci","followContext":null}],"viewCount":709016,"__typename":"StackDecision","htmlContent":"
Jenkins is a pretty flexible, complete tool. Especially I love the possibility to configure jobs as a code with Jenkins pipelines.\n\n
CircleCI is well suited for small projects where the main task is to run continuous integration as quickly as possible.\nTravis CI is recommended primarily for open-source projects that need to be tested in different environments.\n\n
And for something a bit larger I prefer to use Jenkins because it is possible to make serious system configuration thereby different plugins. In Jenkins, I can change almost anything. But if you want to start the CI chain as soon as possible, Jenkins may not be the right choice.","publishedAt":"2019-11-16T21:00:19Z","decisionType":"tool","subjectTools":[{"id":"101231773703650742","fans":58553,"name":"Jenkins","path":"/jenkins","slug":"jenkins","title":"An extendable open source continuous integration server","votes":2219,"stacks":58368,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/670/jenkins.png","verified":false,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/jenkins","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773501041914","fans":9480,"name":"CircleCI","path":"/circleci","slug":"circleci","title":"Automate your development process quickly, safely, and at scale","votes":974,"stacks":12828,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/190/CvqrSSFs_400x400.jpg","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/circleci","followContext":null},{"id":"101231773636491087","fans":9387,"name":"Travis CI","path":"/travis-ci","slug":"travis-ci","title":"A hosted continuous integration service for open source and private projects","votes":1749,"stacks":26379,"imageUrl":"https://img.stackshare.io/service/460/Lu6cGu0z_400x400.png","verified":true,"following":false,"__typename":"Tool","canonicalUrl":"/travis-ci","followContext":null}],"upvotesCount":3},"__typename":"StackDecisionEdge"}],"pageInfo":{"endCursor":"OA","__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false},"__typename":"StackDecisionConnection"}},"privateStackDecisions({\"first\":5})":{"type":"id","generated":true,"id":"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).privateStackDecisions({\"first\":5})","typename":"StackDecisionConnection"},"cachedFooterRelatedStackups":{"type":"json","json":[{"path":"/stackups/jenkins-vs-teamcity","title":"Jenkins vs TeamCity","__typename":"Stackup"},{"path":"/stackups/circleci-vs-jenkins-vs-travis-ci","title":"CircleCI vs Jenkins vs Travis CI","__typename":"Stackup"},{"path":"/stackups/buildbot-vs-jenkins","title":"Buildbot vs Jenkins","__typename":"Stackup"},{"path":"/stackups/gocd-vs-jenkins","title":"GoCD vs Jenkins","__typename":"Stackup"},{"path":"/stackups/appveyor-vs-jenkins-vs-travis-ci","title":"Appveyor vs Jenkins vs Travis CI","__typename":"Stackup"}]},"footerTopStackups":[{"type":"id","generated":true,"id":"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTopStackups.0","typename":"Stackup"},{"type":"id","generated":true,"id":"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTopStackups.1","typename":"Stackup"},{"type":"id","generated":true,"id":"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTopStackups.2","typename":"Stackup"},{"type":"id","generated":true,"id":"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTopStackups.3","typename":"Stackup"}],"footerTrendingStackups":[{"type":"id","generated":true,"id":"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTrendingStackups.0","typename":"Stackup"},{"type":"id","generated":true,"id":"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTrendingStackups.1","typename":"Stackup"},{"type":"id","generated":true,"id":"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTrendingStackups.2","typename":"Stackup"},{"type":"id","generated":true,"id":"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTrendingStackups.3","typename":"Stackup"},{"type":"id","generated":true,"id":"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTrendingStackups.4","typename":"Stackup"}],"__typename":"Stackup"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).jobs":{"count":1,"__typename":"JobConnection"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).featuredPosts":{"count":19,"__typename":"FeaturedPostConnection"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).privateStackDecisionsGetAdvice({\"first\":3})":{"count":0,"pageInfo":{"type":"id","generated":true,"id":"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).privateStackDecisionsGetAdvice({\"first\":3}).pageInfo","typename":"PageInfo"},"edges":[],"__typename":"StackDecisionConnection"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).privateStackDecisionsGetAdvice({\"first\":3}).pageInfo":{"endCursor":null,"hasNextPage":false,"__typename":"PageInfo"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).privateStackDecisions({\"first\":5})":{"count":0,"pageInfo":{"type":"id","generated":true,"id":"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).privateStackDecisions({\"first\":5}).pageInfo","typename":"PageInfo"},"edges":[],"__typename":"StackDecisionConnection"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).privateStackDecisions({\"first\":5}).pageInfo":{"hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"__typename":"PageInfo"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTopStackups.0":{"title":"Postman vs Swagger UI","path":"/stackups/postman-vs-swagger-ui","__typename":"Stackup"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTopStackups.1":{"title":"HipChat vs Mattermost vs Slack","path":"/stackups/hipchat-vs-mattermost-vs-slack","__typename":"Stackup"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTopStackups.2":{"title":"Bitbucket vs GitHub vs GitLab","path":"/stackups/bitbucket-vs-github-vs-gitlab","__typename":"Stackup"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTopStackups.3":{"title":"Bootstrap vs Materialize","path":"/stackups/bootstrap-vs-materialize","__typename":"Stackup"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTrendingStackups.0":{"title":"Django vs Laravel vs Node.js","path":"/stackups/django-vs-laravel-vs-nodejs","__typename":"Stackup"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTrendingStackups.1":{"title":"Bootstrap vs Foundation vs Material-UI","path":"/stackups/bootstrap-vs-foundation-vs-material-ui","__typename":"Stackup"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTrendingStackups.2":{"title":"Node.js vs Spring Boot","path":"/stackups/nodejs-vs-spring-boot","__typename":"Stackup"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTrendingStackups.3":{"title":"Flyway vs Liquibase","path":"/stackups/flyway-vs-liquibase","__typename":"Stackup"},"$ROOT_QUERY.stackupBySlug({\"slug\":\"jenkins-vs-travis-ci\"}).footerTrendingStackups.4":{"title":"AWS CodeCommit vs Bitbucket vs GitHub","path":"/stackups/aws-codecommit-vs-bitbucket-vs-github","__typename":"Stackup"}}
Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community! Get Advice Jenkins vs Travis CI: What are the differences?
Introduction:
Jenkins and Travis CI are popular tools used for Continuous Integration and Continuous Deployment in software development projects.
1. **Integration flexibility**: Jenkins offers more flexibility in integrating with various tools, services, and frameworks due to its extensive plugin ecosystem, allowing for greater customization. On the other hand, Travis CI has a more opinionated approach with predefined configurations, making it easier to set up and use out of the box.
2. **Hosting**: Jenkins is typically self-hosted, requiring users to set up and maintain their own infrastructure, whereas Travis CI is a cloud-based service, allowing for easier setup and management without the need for maintaining servers.
3. **Pricing model**: Jenkins is open-source and free to use, but users have to bear the cost of infrastructure and maintenance. In contrast, Travis CI offers a free tier for open-source projects but charges for private repositories, providing a more straightforward pricing model for businesses.
4. **Community support**: Jenkins has a large and active community, providing extensive documentation, tutorials, and plugins for support and customization. Travis CI also has a helpful community but may not offer the same level of customization and plugin support as Jenkins.
5. **Ease of use**: Travis CI is known for its simplicity and ease of use, with a more streamlined interface and setup process compared to Jenkins, which can be more complex and require additional configuration for certain use cases.
6. **Scalability**: Jenkins can be easily scaled for large enterprises and complex projects by setting up distributed builds and leveraging its robust architecture, while Travis CI may have limitations in scaling for massive projects due to its cloud-based nature.
In Summary, Jenkins provides more integration flexibility and scalability options, while Travis CI offers simplicity in hosting, pricing, and ease of use.
Advice on Jenkins and Travis CI
We are currently using Azure Pipelines for continous integration. Our applications are developed witn .NET framework. But when we look at the online Jenkins is the most widely used tool for continous integration. Can you please give me the advice which one is best to use for my case Azure pipeline or jenkins.
See more I'm open to anything. just want something that break less and doesn't need me to pay for it, and can be hosted on Docker . our scripting language is powershell core. so it's better to support it. also we are building dotnet core in our pipeline, so if they have anything related that helps with the CI would be nice.
See more Replies (1)
Google cloud build can help you.
It is hosted on cloud and also provide reasonable free quota.
See more
I'm planning to setup complete CD-CD setup for spark and python application which we are going to deploy in aws lambda and EMR Cluster. Which tool would be best one to choose. Since my company is trying to adopt to concourse i would like to understand what are the lack of capabilities concourse have .
Thanks in advance !
See more Replies (1)
I would definetly recommend Concourse to you, as it is one of the most advanced modern methods of making CI/CD while Jenkins is an old monolithic dinosaur. Concourse itself is cloudnative and containerbased which helps you to build simple, high-performance and scalable CI/CD pipelines.
In my opinion, the only lack of skills you have with Concourse is your own knowledge of how to build pipelines and automate things. Technincally there is no lack, i would even say you can extend it way more easily. But as a Con it is more easy to interact with Jenkins if you are only used to UIs. Concourse needs someone which is capable of using CLIs.
See more
From a StackShare Community member: "Currently we use Travis CI and have optimized it as much as we can so our builds are fairly quick. Our boss is all about redundancy so we are looking for another solution to fall back on in case Travis goes down and/or jacks prices way up (they were recently acquired). Could someone recommend which CI we should go with and if they have time, an explanation of how they're different?"
See more Replies (6)
We use CircleCI because of the better value it provides in its plans. I'm sure we could have used Travis just as easily but we found CircleCI's pricing to be more reasonable. In the two years since we signed up, the service has improved. CircleCI is always innovating and iterating on their platform. We have been very satisfied.
See more As the maintainer of the Karate DSL open-source project - I found Travis CI very easy to integrate into the GitHub workflow and it has been steady sailing for more than 2 years now ! It works well for Java / Apache Maven projects and we were able to configure it to use the latest Oracle JDK as per our needs. Thanks to the Travis CI team for this service to the open-source community !
See more I use Google Cloud Build because it's my first foray into the CICD world(loving it so far), and I wanted to work with something GCP native to avoid giving permissions to other SaaS tools like CircleCI and Travis CI .
I really like it because it's free for the first 120 minutes, and it's one of the few CICD tools that enterprises are open to using since it's contained within GCP.
One of the unique things is that it has the Kaniko cache , which speeds up builds by creating intermediate layers within the docker image vs. pushing the full thing from the start. Helpful when you're installing just a few additional dependencies.
Feel free to checkout an example: Cloudbuild Example
See more I use Travis CI because of various reasons -
1. Cloud based system so no dedicated server required, and you do not need to administrate it.
2. Easy YAML configuration.
3. Supports Major Programming Languages.
4. Support of build matrix
6. Supports AWS, Azure, Docker, Heroku, Google Cloud, Github Pages, PyPi and lot more.
7. Slack Notifications.
See more You are probably looking at another hosted solution: Jenkins is a good tool but it way too work intensive to be used as just a backup solution.
I have good experience with Circle-CI, Codeship, Drone.io and Travis (as well as problematic experiences with all of them), but my go-to tool is Gitlab CI: simple, powerful and if you have problems with their limitations or pricing, you can always install runners somewhere and use Gitlab just for scheduling and management. Even if you don't host your git repository at Gitlab, you can have Gitlab pull changes automatically from wherever you repo lives.
See more If you are considering Jenkins I would recommend at least checking out Buildkite. The agents are self-hosted (like Jenkins) but the interface is hosted for you. It meshes up some of the things I like about hosted services (pipeline definitions in YAML, managed interface and authentication) with things I like about Jenkins (local customizable agent images, secrets only on own instances, custom agent level scripts, sizing instances to your needs).
See more
Decisions about Jenkins and Travis CI
Github Actions allowed us to drop previous CI/CD technologies like Jenkins or AWS CodeBuild. The main advantages for us are:
- The Infrastructure-as-Code approach of Github Actions enables us to keep CI/CD configurations next to the code.
- Github as a single platform for repositories and CI/CD simplifies our stack and effort to manage it on the daily basis.
TVcloud Team <3 Github Actions
See more We replaced Jenkins with Github Actions for all our repositories hosted on Github. GA has two significant benefits for us compared to an external build tool: it's simpler, and it sits at eye level.
Its simplicity and smooth user experience makes it easier for all developers to adopt, giving them more autonomy.
Sitting at eye level means it's completely run and configured right alongside the code, so that it's easier to observe and adjust our builds as we go.
These two benefits have made "the build" less of a system engineer responsibility and more of a developer tool, giving developers more ownership from code to release.
See more Jenkins is a friend of mine. 😀
There are not much space for Jenkins competitors for now from my point of view. With declarative pipelines now in place, its super easy to maintain them and create new ones(altho I prefer scripted still). Self-hosted, free, huge community makes it the top choice so honestly for me it was an easy pick.
See more When choosing a tool to help automate our CI/CD, the decision came down to GitHub Actions (GA) or TravisCI. Both are great, but the team has more experience with GA. Given GAs broad support of languages and workflows, it's hard to go wrong with this decision. We will also be using GitHub for version control and project management, so having everything in one place is convenient.
See more Stephen Badger | Vital Beats
Within our deployment pipeline, we have a need to deploy to multiple customer environments, and manage secrets specifically in a way that integrates well with AWS, Kubernetes Secrets, Terraform and our pipelines ourselves.
Jenkins offered us the ability to choose one of a number of credentials/secrets management approaches, and models secrets as a more dynamic concept that GitHub Actions provided.
Additionally, we are operating Jenkins within our development Kubernetes cluster as a kind of system-wide orchestrator, allowing us to use Kubernetes pods as build agents, avoiding the ongoing direct costs associated with GitHub Actions minutes / per-user pricing. Obviously as a consequence we take on the indirect costs of maintain Jenkins itself, patching it, upgrading etc. However our experience with managing Jenkins via Kubernetes and declarative Jenkins configuration has led us to believe that this cost is small, particularly as the majority of actual building and testing is handled inside docker containers and Kubernetes, alleviating the need for less supported plugins that may make Jenkins administration more difficult.
See more My website is brand new and one of the few requirements of testings I had to implement was code coverage. Never though it was so hard to implement using a #docker container.
Given my lack of experience, every attempt I tried on making a simple code coverage test using the 4 combinations of #TravisCI, #CircleCi with #Coveralls, #Codecov I failed. The main problem was I was generating the .coverage file within the docker container and couldn't access it with #TravisCi or #CircleCi , every attempt to solve this problem seems to be very hacky and this was not the kind of complexity I want to introduce to my newborn website.
This problem was solved using a specific action for #GitHubActions, it was a 3 line solution I had to put in my github workflow file and I was able to access the .coverage file from my docker container and get the coverage report with #Codecov .
See more We were long time users of TravisCI, but switched to CircleCI because of the better user interface and pricing. Version 2.0 has had a couple of trips and hiccups; but overall we've been very happy with the continuous integration it provides. Continuous Integration is a must-have for building software, and CircleCI continues to surprise as they roll out ideas and features. It's leading the industry in terms of innovation and new ideas, and it's exciting to see what new things they keep rolling out.
See more Jenkins is a pretty flexible, complete tool. Especially I love the possibility to configure jobs as a code with Jenkins pipelines.
CircleCI is well suited for small projects where the main task is to run continuous integration as quickly as possible.
Travis CI is recommended primarily for open-source projects that need to be tested in different environments.
And for something a bit larger I prefer to use Jenkins because it is possible to make serious system configuration thereby different plugins. In Jenkins, I can change almost anything. But if you want to start the CI chain as soon as possible, Jenkins may not be the right choice.
See more
Manage your open source components, licenses, and vulnerabilities
Learn More
Manage your open source components, licenses, and vulnerabilities
Learn More
