In this article
Home printers are as essential as they are polarizing. For hybrid work, due-tomorrow school assignments, or the occasional UPS return label, the printer can be your best friend one minute and give you an indecipherable error code or “low ink” notification the next. And while “all printers are designed to frustrate in some way,” says Dan Ackerman, former editor-in-chief of Gizmodo, home printers are still worth buying.
Beyond working when you need it most, the experts and printer owners I interviewed say that there are other important factors to consider when buying a printer for your home, including not only the initial cost, but ink and toner refill prices, whether you need monochrome or color printing, the size of the printer, and whether you prefer laser or inkjet printing. Most printers today come with built-in Wi-Fi and wireless printing, and depending on what you need it for, investing in extra features can make all the difference for day-to-day use. Below is our list of expert- and owner-recommended printers that are the best at aggravating users the least.
What we’re looking for
Cost per page
Before purchasing a printer, experts and owners I interviewed say to consider not only the initial cost, but ink and toner refill prices, and to consider subscriptions and third-party cartridges as a way to lower costs. All cost-per-page estimates are calculated by dividing the cost of a standard toner or ink refill by the yield (when available).
Type
Inkjet printers are better for photos and high-resolution images, though they tend to have slower printing speeds. They also can handle fewer pages and have smaller paper capacity, but are more compact in size overall. Chris Nadziejko, a printer and paper salesman at Adorama, noted the difference between dye- and pigment-based inkjets: “With pigment printers, you need to use it at least once a month or else the pigment in the nozzles may dry out and you’ll have streaks on your prints.” Laser printers are better for documents and labels. They print faster than inkjets, and the toner dries faster as well.
Resolution
Print resolution is measured in DPI, or “dots per inch.” In general, a higher DPI means a more detailed image. With most current printers, this isn’t a concern for document printing, but it is something to keep an eye on if you want to print photos.
Connectivity
Some printers may have wireless interfaces like Wi-Fi or Bluetooth or may connect via USB or Ethernet (and likely some combination of these).
Mobile printing
All printers listed have mobile printing, which allow you to print directly from devices without installing additional printer software. I’ve specified which apps are compatible below.
Size
A printer is no good if it doesn’t even fit in your apartment. The size of all printers are listed so you don’t end up with a product that doesn’t fit on your desk.
Extra features
Additionally, depending on what you need your printer for, investing in extras like double-sided printing, a scanner, faxing capabilities, a touchscreen, a rear tray feeder, and a manual feed slot for thicker types of media like envelopes or crafting paper could make all the difference.
Best overall monochrome printer
Cost per page: 3.7 cents | Type: B&W laser printing, print speed: 32 ppm | Resolution: 2400 x 600 DPI | Connectivity: wireless 802.11 b/g/n, USB 2.0, Wi-Fi Direct | Mobile printing: Apple AirPrint, Brother iPrint&Scan, Mopria, Cortado | Size: 14.0” x 14.2” x 7.2” | Extra features: double-sided printing, manual feed slot, works with Alexa
The overwhelming favorite black-and-white home printer is the Brother HL-L2350DW. The experts I spoke to love its simplicity, breezy setup, compact design, and affordability (it’s the least expensive monochrome printer on the list). The HL-L2350DW is a humble workhorse that offers double-sided printing, wireless printing from your phone or laptop, and a print speed of up to 32 pages per minute. “This is not for sleek, glossy documents,” says Dave Baker, founder and copy chief at Super Copy Editors, who uses his for proofreading. “Plus, you’ll save money on ink cartridges since it uses only black ink.” Jonathan Treble, CEO of PrintWithMe, says, “It offers everything you need for simple black-and-white printing.” And although this printer doesn’t have a scanner, Treble says the multitude of scanning apps available nowadays makes it a nonissue for most people. It also lasts. Strategist editor Maxine Builder, who purchased her HL-L2350DW five years ago, says the printer is still working just fine, and, despite the occasional connectivity issue, she still recommends it. It’s low-maintenance, she says, which is what a printer should be. “I really don’t think about my printer much at all, which is the best compliment I can give.”
Best color printer
Cost per page: not listed, standard refill $67 | Type: inkjet color printing with pigment-based (black) and dye-based (color) ink, 12 ppm (B&W), 5 ppm (color) | Resolution: 1200 x 1200 DPI (B&W), 4800 x 1200 DPI (color) | Connectivity: wireless 2.4GHz, Bluetooth Low Energy, USB 2.0 | Mobile printing: HP Smart app, Apple AirPrint, Mopria | Size: 17.11” x 14.23” x 6.19” | Extra features: flatbed copier and scanner, manual double-sided printing, borderless printing
Leah Fowler, owner of Nebraska-based Fowler Invitations, sells digital vellum-wrap designs for wedding invitations. She swears by HPs, and a favorite model of hers is the Smart Tank 5101, a durable inkjet machine good for everyday color printing but that can also handle card stock and thicker paper, making it ideal for home crafts and school projects. Fowler found it easy to set up and says it connected right to the Wi-Fi. Katherine Jacques, senior category merchant of Staples U.S. retail, agrees, telling me HP Smart Tanks are “great options” for those looking for high image quality without spending too much on ink. The cartridge-free high-capacity refillable ink tanks and the up to two years of ink included in the box make it a solid cost-saving purchase, explains Jacques. The Smart Tank 5101 can also copy and scan, and it has Wi-Fi and mobile printing. It does not have faxing capabilities, however; if you need a color printer that can do that, you should consider the Brother MFC-L3710CW below.
According to Fowler, the HP Ink subscription service that you can link the 5101 with is “super affordable.” The printer also has sensors that let users know when it is running low on ink. They can opt to get refills sent automatically once ink levels drop below a certain point, and, if they’re printing more than usual, can also receive notifications so they won’t be hit with surprise charges.
Best all-in-one monochrome printer
Cost per page: 2.7 cents | Type: B&W laser printer, 36 ppm | Resolution: 2400 x 600 DPI | Connectivity: wireless 802.11 b/g/n, Ethernet, USB 2.0, Wi-Fi Direct | Mobile printing: Apple AirPrint, Brother iPrint&Scan, Mopria, Cortado | Size: 16.1” x 15.7” x 12.5” | Extra features: copier, color flatbed scanner, double-sided printing, LCD touchscreen, manual feed slot, works with Alexa
Sometimes your printer finds you, which is what happened to Jason Reif, a film and commercial producer based in Brooklyn. He inherited his Brother DCP-L2540DW, the older version of this printer, in 2017 after it was used as the set printer on season two of High Maintenance. As a set printer, it was too bulky, explains Reif, since “you have to lug them around everywhere you go,” but it worked perfectly for his home-office setup. If you’re looking for a black-and-white laser office printer, “it’s got all you need,” he says. Like Reif’s model, the DCP-L2550DW has wireless and automatic double-sided printing, color scanning, Wi-Fi, and mobile printing, Bluetooth and Ethernet connection options, and a low-toner mode to save on ink. Not that he needs to replenish often: “The last time I ordered toner for our printer was in 2021.” When Reif’s not using it to scan a stack of releases for work, “I use it almost exclusively for printing out USPS return labels because of all the eBay shopping I’m doing.”
Best all-in-one color printer
Cost per page: 18 cents (B&W), 19 cents (color) | Type: laser color printer, 19 ppm (B&W and color) | Resolution: 2400 x 600 DPI | Connectivity: wireless 802.11 b/g/n, USB 2.0, Wi-Fi Direct | Mobile printing: Apple AirPrint, Google Cloud Print, Brother iPrint&Scan, Mopria | Size: 16.1” x 18.7” x 16.3” | Extra features: flatbed copier and scanner, fax machine, color touch screen, manual feed slot, automatic document feeder, works with Alexa
Carl Prouty, a technologist at the national electronics and appliance retailer Abt, recommends the Brother MFC-L3710CW as a great all-in-one buy for most users. This laser color printer features specifications Prouty says one should look for when getting a printer: built-in Wi-Fi, wireless and mobile printing, and a display screen, which can make setup easier and is handy for knowing when your toner supply is low. Additionally, the MFC-L3710CW has a manual feed slot for card stock and envelopes as well as an automatic document feeder for scanning, copying, or faxing documents. It can take up to 50 sheets at a time, and the 250-sheet capacity paper tray reduces the need to constantly refill the paper. The MFC-L3710CW is bulkier than other home printers, but it’s worth it if you’re in regular need of the extra features. One drawback to keep in mind: This model does not have two-sided printing.
Best photo printer
Cost per page: not listed, $105.99 for refill | Type: inkjet color printer (dye based), print speed: 53 seconds per 8” x 10” bordered color photo | Resolution: 4800 x 2400 DPI | Connectivity: wireless 802.11a/b/g/n, 2.5/5.0GHz, Ethernet, USB | Mobile printing: Apple AirPrint, Mopria, Easy-PhotoPrint Editor, Cloud Link, Canon PRINT | Size: 25.2” x 15” x 7.9” | Extra features: LCD display, manual feed slot, auto paper width detection, paper feed skew correction
Professional photo printers can cost thousands, says Adorama’s Nadziejko, but for someone who wants a quality photo printer for their home, the Canon PIXMA PRO-200 is a more affordable option. With borderless printing and wireless printing capabilities, it’s also more forgiving for the occasional user, Nadziejko says. “It’s dye-based so you don’t have to print as often” as you would with a pigment-based printer. It’s an ideal printer for the photo hobbyist, someone who won’t be shooting all the time and doesn’t need business-grade prints, he says, adding that Canon photo paper also tends to be cheaper than that of some competitors.
Best (less-expensive) photo printer
Cost per page: not listed, $38 for standard paper and ink refill set | Type: photo printer (dye-based), approx. 47 seconds for a 4” x 6” photo | Resolution: 256 Levels Per Color | Connectivity: wireless 802.11 b/g/n, 2.4GHz, USB | Mobile printing: Apple AirPrint, Canon PRINT app, Mopria | Size: 7.1” x 5.4” x 2.5” | Extra features: borderless printing, LCD printing, reprinting, power save mode, red-eye correction, memory card slot
The Canon SELPHY CP1300 prints postcard-size photos directly from your phone, and is a lifesaver for Daily Show writer Devin Delliquanti, who uses it for last-minute school assignments for his kids, saving him an evening trip to CVS or Kinko’s. “It’s the night before and, oh my God, I need a picture of my son and his family and his grandparents, but I can just print out a picture” at home, Delliquanti says. “It’s a relief.” He got his CP1300 as a Christmas gift circa 2018 and loves that its compact design means “it’s not as clunky” as other printers. The dye-sublimation technology the CP1300 uses to print means photos dry quickly, are smudge free, and are water-resistant.
Best for high-volume printing
Cost per page: 22 cents | Type: inkjet color printer (pigment based), 29 ppm (B&W), 25 ppm (color) | Resolution: black: 1200 x 1200 DPI, color: Up to 4800 x 1200 | Connectivity: wireless 802.11a/b/g/n, Ethernet, USB 2.0, Wi-Fi Direct | Mobile printing: Chrome OS, HP Smart, Apple AirPrint, Mopria | Size: 18.11” x 13.43” x 9.21” | Extra features: double-sided printing, touchscreen display
When curriculum specialists Catherine Coyle and Aimee Jensen look to print out worksheets and lesson plans, they both agree the inkjet HP OfficeJet Pro 8025e is the one to use. For Coyle, who is a former grade-school teacher and the creator of Classroom Creations, the 8025e’s automatic double-sided printing is a must-have feature, and the HP Instant Ink plan keeps refills affordable. She uses her printer four to five times a week, and often features it in her TikTok videos previewing her teacher resources. “I get comments all the time on my social media asking what printer I use. People say that the colors are really vibrant,” Coyle says. Jensen, a third-grade teacher and creator of Aimee’s Edventures, agrees. She’s had her OfficeJet Pro 8025e for three years and loves how vivid the colors are, and says the wireless printing ensures she can quickly print the classroom resources she makes for children and teachers from her devices. Jacques also likes the OfficeJet Pro 8025e, and says it “keeps up with my business needs, but also supports my home-printing needs like photos and color documents.”
Best printer for ease of use
Cost per page: 3.7 cents | Type: laser B&W printer, 36 ppm | Resolution: 2400 x 600 DPI| Connectivity: wireless 802.11 b/g/n, Ethernet, USB 2.0, Wi-Fi Direct | Mobile printing: Apple AirPrint, Brother iPrint&Scan, Mopria, Cortado, NFC | Size: 16.1” x 15.7” x 10.7” | Extra features: copier, flatbed scanner, color touch screen, double-sided printing, toner save mode
Ackerman says the Brother HL-L2395DW was the one printer he found that not only worked for him, but for his mother as well. As someone who used to review printers at CNET, Ackerman says of all the models he tested, this printer was “the one that made me not want to throw it out the window.” With black-and-white laser printing, an LCD touchscreen display, and automatic double-sided printing, the printer also has a 250-sheet paper capacity and print speed of 36 pages per minute, the fastest among the printers on this list. Refill toner cartridges start at around $45, but Ackerman says he finds third-party toner on Amazon for much cheaper that works just as well. He has had this printer for three or four years, and the reliability and ease of it led him to gift one to his mother, who uses it for crafting. “She has not come to me and asked me to come troubleshoot her printer,” Ackerman says of the HL-L2395DW. “The ultimate endorsement I can give is that she never asks about it.”
Some more office staples we’ve written about
Our experts
• Dave Baker, founder and copy chief at Super Copy Editors
• Jonathan Treble, CEO of PrintWithMe
• Maxine Builder, Strategist editor
• Leah Fowler, owner of Fowler Invitations
• Katherine Jacques, senior category merchant of Staples U.S. Retail
• Carl Prouty, technologist at Abt
• Jason Reif, film and commercial producer
• Chris Nadziejko, a printer and paper salesman at Adorama
• Catherine Coyle, curriculum specialist and creator of Classroom Creations
• Aimee Jensen, elementary curriculum specialist and creator of Aimee’s Edventures
• Devin Delliquanti, writer for The Daily Show
• Dan Ackerman, editor-in-chief of Gizmodo
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.