In this article
I used to be an air-fryer skeptic, believing them to be unnecessary, flashy appliances that were meant to make healthier versions of french fries, mozzarella sticks, and wings — and not useful for much else. But now, many interviews for this piece later, and after testing some out myself, I more wholeheartedly understand their appeal.
Yes, the classic snack-y, crunchy foods were what people talked about most when air fryers started rising in popularity several years ago (“It’s akin to deep frying without all the oil” is basically what I heard over and over again). But it turns out they also work magic on vegetables, proteins, baked goods, and, yes, toast. This is because they’re essentially small convection ovens, meaning they have a fan and exhaust system that blows hot air all around your food for more even cooking and browning. And with an air fryer, you’re taking ”that [convection oven] quality and putting it in a really small contraption, which magnifies it times ten,” explains Ben Mims, cook, writer, and author of a cookbook devoted to the appliance.
This powerful heating mechanism means that an air fryer conveniently cooks foods way faster than a regular oven with very minimal preheating time, if any at all, to boot. This is, of course, beneficial if you’re in a rush to eat, but also if you live in a small space and don’t want to make your kitchen unbearably warm — or just want to pull together a quick snack, or reheat leftovers without a fuss. “I use it as a kitchen helper,” Mims says. “I think of it as similar to the Instant Pot. You either take to it or you don’t (I have friends who love it, whereas I prefer to braise in a pot in the oven for four hours). It’s just about if it fits your cooking lifestyle.”
If you do in fact think an air fryer might fit yours, read on for recommendations tested by me, Mims, and 11 other experts. And if you’re in the market for another workhorse kitchen appliance that can cook full meals, check out my guide to toaster ovens.
Update on October 23, 2024: Updated prices and checked stock for all products.
What we’re looking for
Function
Perhaps the most important matter to decide on is whether you want an air fryer that is just an air fryer, or an air fryer that also does … a lot of other things. Some on this list are one trick ponies, while others have settings that allow you to broil, dehydrate, proof bread dough, and more.
Capacity
How you intend to use your air fryer should, of course, affect what size you buy. Are you planning to use it mostly for yourself, to bake off the occasional single cookie, or to reheat leftovers? Or is the idea to use it for regular family dinners? For this category, I’ve listed the capacity of each model. But it should be noted, basket-style air fryers (the majority here) are measured in terms of how many quarts they hold, while ones with rack inserts (meaning, they look more like toaster ovens) are measured in terms of their interior cubic inches.
Best air fryer overall
Function: Air fry, roast, bake, reheat, broil, dehydrate | Capacity: 6 quarts
When I tested the Instant Vortex, the first thing I noticed and appreciated was the smooth, integrated interface. The touchpad is fully flush with the surface of the machine and lights up when you plug it in; it’s actually quite sleek-looking for a big appliance. The functions are intuitive, so much so that I never once had to reference the instructions the first time I used it. You choose from roast, bake, broil, reheat, dehydrate, or air fry, then click time and temperature, adjusting each by turning a small stainless-steel knob. The machine preheats in only two minutes, automatically pauses when you pull the basket out midway to shake food around, and — perhaps my favorite feature of all — has that light inside and a clear window at the front so you can actually see what’s going on. It also cleans up perfectly with a light scrub.
But don’t just take it from me: The machine also comes recommended by three experts. Bruce Weinstein, co-author of multiple air frying cookbooks, explains that while some models are very tall, which accounts for their overall capacity and ability to fit, say, a big pile of French fries, that setup won’t allow air to flow around as easily and result in the crispy texture you’re after. The Vortex, however, has a large square footage on the bottom, meaning you can lay everything in a single layer and avoid overcrowding. “It just has the perfect ratio of height to width,” he says. Cookbook author Julia Turshen (who has the same model but without the see-through window) also appreciates the space. It’s basket-style (as opposed to a few models on this list that look like toaster ovens), which means she can “fit way more than a skillet” and “just shake things up” instead of tediously flipping them over on a sheet tray.
Jenny Tschiesche, founder of Lunchbox Doctor and author of an air-frying cookbook, has tried a few different air fryers — but the Instant Vortex is the one that has stood the test of time in her kitchen with daily use for several years. “With some of the others, after a few months, the lining starts to come away, or you see scratches. But this one has lasted without damage,” she says. “And that’s something considering how much it gets used by all family members — including two teenagers.” For Tschiesche, the fact that many of her Le Creuset dishes fit in there is also a huge plus.
Best less expensive air fryer
Function: Air fry | Capacity: 2.6 quarts
If you’re air-frying curious but don’t want to break the bank on one — and might store it away in a cabinet instead of out on the counter for daily use — you can’t get better than the Dash’s Tasti-Crisp model, which is about half the price and half the size of all the options above. In testing, I found it to be supremely simple to use. There are only two dials: One at the top for temperature and one on the front for time. This makes it a breeze to figure out upon first opening and efficient to operate going forward (I find I gravitate towards just setting these two controls on any air fryer as it is, as opposed to using presets).
The machine is small, but that gives it a sleeker profile on the countertop than some others I’ve tested. And it perfectly fits one-person portions. For this reason, I especially like it for vegetables, like the broccoli below, though it does fit proteins like a filet of fish, or a handful of meatballs. Recipe developer and blogger Madeline Park of Cafe Maddy loves it for this reason, too. “I live alone and only cook one portion at a time,” says Park, who doesn’t even like to have leftovers because her video creation requires her to make new meal after new meal. “I can cook a dish in 20 minutes, and it’s really intuitive to use.”
Best air fryer with presets
Function: Air fry, toast, bake, steak, chicken, seafood, shrimp, bacon, frozen foods, french fries, vegetables, preheat, shake, keep warm | Capacity: 5.8 quarts
The Cosori air fryer has more particular presets than any of the other basket-style models on this list. While many of the others have additional functions like “bake” or “roast,” this one’s selections are more particular, allowing you to choose from food options like fries, vegetables, and bacon. They’re nice shortcuts — and ones that Jennifer West and Rebecca Abbott, the writers and recipe developers behind Air Frying Foodie, say work well. “Also, the directions are very clear and easy,” says West, who uses the machine to cook for four to six people regularly. “Some air fryers stress me out. You’re trying to set time and temperatures and there are too many buttons — and I’m someone who air-fries every day.” Hale appreciates that it’s affordable — “especially for the quality,” she says.
Best durable air fryer
Function: Air fry | Capacity: 7 quarts
The Philips has a couple standout features that prompted me to give it the title of most durable. First, the food tray is stainless-steel mesh, “almost like chicken wire,” Weinstein says. It’s a material that is bound to last much longer than the usual slatted nonstick trays you’ll find at the bottom of other basket-style air fryers. (Weinstein notes that you can put it in the dishwasher, but if you don’t have one, just soak it right after use so no hard bits stick, and then wash when you’re ready.) The second reason is an additional built-in layer underneath that mesh tray: a catcher where released fat drips down and collects. “It keeps splatter and smoke down,” he says, “especially with fatty foods like steak and hamburgers.” The less grease buildup over time, the better your air fryer will function, and the longer it will last. Recipe developer and food blogger Nicole Modic also calls the air fryer high-quality as well as heavy-duty. Though she has a couple of models on hand, she uses this one when making fattier foods, too, like chicken wings. As for getting the accumulated grease out of the bottom, she says that cleanup is super easy because the drip tray comes out fully.
Best toaster oven air fryer
Function: Air fry, toast, bagel, bake, roast, broil, pizza, cookies, proof, dehydrate, reheat, warm, and slow cook | Capacity: 1 cubic foot
The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro boasts 13 preset functions. You can toast nine pieces of bread at a time, roast a 14-pound turkey, and fit a five-quart Dutch oven inside. In other words, it’s really not fooling around. Food writer and editor Alyse Whitney has been using hers for the last several years, and used Breville’s previous similar model for eight years before that. “This is like my ride-or-die appliance,” she says. “It is what will be buried with me.” Obviously it’s big, and not everyone has the counter space for that. But if you do, Whitney can’t recommend it enough. “I use this as my oven six out of seven days of the week,” she says. “And I use it as my second oven when I’m hosting a party. Two quarter sheet pans fit nicely in there because it has two levels. The basket ones seem simple, but also limiting. I love how many things this one does. Also, it has a clear window, so I can see what’s happening, which I like.” As for the difficult cleanup that Mims mentioned? Whitney has a solution: “I put a piece of aluminum foil underneath.”
Best less expensive toaster oven air fryer
Function: Air fry, convection bake, convection broil, bake, broil, warm, and toast) | Capacity: 0.6 cubic feet
The Cuisinart is a slightly smaller (12 x 16 x 14 inches instead of 21 x 17 x 12 inches) machine with seven preset functions to its name. Mims says that if you want an air fryer that can do more than just air fry, this one does a great job. Like the Breville, it comes with a tray and a basket insert, though it will only hold one level at a time.
For a similar price as the Cuisinart, Modic recommends this Oster Air Fryer Oven, which she keeps on her counter and uses several times a week like a toaster oven to bake, roast, boil, toast, and keep food warm in addition to air fry. She says the buttons are super clear, a plus for her 6- and 8-year-old boys who use it often to make snacks, too. And she says she likes that you can move the trays to different levels so you can fit different-size foods and get the most even level of cooking depending on what you’re making.
Best basket-style multifunctional air fryer
Function: Air fry, roast, broil, bake, reheat, and dehydrate | Capacity: 5.5 quarts
Unlike the Breville and the Cuisinart, this Ninja is a basket-style multifunctional air fryer (as opposed to tray-style). Erin Clarke, the recipe developer behind Well Plated, purchased hers a few years ago, uses it several times a week, and says it has held up great. Beyond its durability, “it has a lot of surface area, which allows you to put food in a single layer so it cooks and crisps evenly,” Clarke says. She appreciates that it only takes three minutes to preheat (though oftentimes she won’t even wait and it still works perfectly, she says). The basket slides out smoothly, too, so she can pull it out and shake food up part way through cooking. And “there’s never any residual grease or stains” after cleaning with a sponge and dish soap, she says, even when working with fatty foods like chicken wings and bacon.
Best air fryer with dual baskets
Function: Air fry, air broil, roast, reheat, dehydrate, bake | Capacity: 8 quarts
This air fryer has something none of the others on this list do: two baskets. Of course, this allows you to cook separate foods separately but at the same time with each side set to a distinct temperature for a particular amount of time. In my own testing, I found this feature quite useful; I was able to start a salmon filet in one compartment, which takes slightly longer than the broccoli florets I made in the other. Dinner was ready without any waiting, and without one component getting cold. The settings are intuitive to use, too.
I will note, the individual baskets have a narrow surface area, so on occasions where I was making food for more than just myself, I had to fill both with the same thing (like the wings you can see pictured below). It works just as well, but to accommodate two baskets, even at their smaller size, the appliance is overall very big and a bit cumbersome. If you see yourself doubling up on the same foods across the board more often than not, it might be smarter to go with a different pick.
Best Instant Pot air fryer
Function: Air fry, pressure cook, saute, slow cook, steam, sous vide, roast, bake, broil, dehydrate, keep warm | Capacity: 8 quarts
In fact, the Instant Pot Duo has 11 preset functions — but it’s the only one on this list that pressure cooks in addition to air frying. “For a long time, I was one of the most outspoken and vehement critics of air fryers,” says Courtney Kassel, recipe developer at Allrecipes. “But after moving in with an air fryer-owning friend, I’m well on my way to converted. In our apartment, as is the case with many, using the oven takes more effort than a simple switch, and can often be unreliable both in preheating time and temperature. Our trusty air fryer, however, preheats in minutes and I’d argue outperforms the oven for various tasks; evenly roasted vegetables, cooking proteins quickly, or just generally existing on TikTok in 2022. Additionally, ours happens to be a combination air-fryer-Instant Pot, meaning I can further justify the space it eats up in our limited kitchen storage and it’s a lifesaver on nights when the ‘What’s for dinner?’ conversation doesn’t even kick off until 7 p.m.”
Best air fryer with rotisserie basket
Function: Air fry, roast, boil, bake, reheat, dehydrate, rotate) | Capacity: 10 quarts
This Instant air fryer is the largest on the list and as such, accommodates several insertable accessories for cooking that wouldn’t fit in any other model. The first is a metal spit specifically designed for making rotisserie-style chicken that Hale says “has the crispiest skin on all sides.” You secure the bird on the spit, insert it into the air fryer, set your temperature and time, select the “rotate” button, and let it go. (While Instant says you can fit a bird up to four pounds, Hale prefers hers to be around three to prevent it from rubbing against the sides.) The machine also comes with a perforated cylindrical basket suspended in the center of the main chamber that rotates so the food inside tumbles around and receives maximum air flow. Hale says this makes the outside of french fries, tater tots, and chunks of vegetables even more uniformly crisp than other air fryers. It also accommodates two trays at a time that you can air fry on, as well as use with the machine’s toast and bake settings. While Hale admits the appliance isn’t quite as easy to clean as her Cosori XL based on sheer size, she says the inside still wipes down nicely and the front door comes completely off so it can be washed more thoroughly by hand.
Some more kitchen appliances we’ve written about
Our experts
• Rebecca Abbott, co-founder of Air Frying Foodie
• Erin Clarke, recipe developer behind Well Plated
• Katie Hale, cookbook author
• Courtney Kassel, recipe developer at Allrecipes
• Ben Mims, Los Angeles Times cooking columnist and cookbook author
• Nicole Modic, recipe developer and food blogger
• Madeline Park, Cafe Maddy cook and blogger
• Jenny Tschiesche, founder of Lunchbox Doctor
• Julia Turshen, cookbook author
• Bruce Weinstein, cookbook author
• Jennifer West, co-founder of Air Frying Foodie
• Alyse Whitney, food writer and editor
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best dining-room décor items, coffee-makers, knife sets, Japanese coffee brewer, charcoal water filter, and drinking glasses for water and more. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.
Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.