Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

[macOS] Support policy changes; Xcode 14 and 16 will be removed from macOS 14 on November 4 #10703

Closed
6 of 14 tasks
erik-bershel opened this issue Sep 30, 2024 · 52 comments
Closed
6 of 14 tasks

Comments

@erik-bershel
Copy link
Contributor

erik-bershel commented Sep 30, 2024

Breaking changes

Current support policy:

- all OS compatible versions side-by-side
- for beta, GM versions - latest beta only
- old patch versions are deprecated in 3 months

New support policy:

- only one major version of Xcode will be supported per macOS version
- all minor versions of the supported major version will be available
- beta and RC versions will be provided "as-is" in the latest available macOS image only no matter of beta/GA status of the image
- when a new patch version is released, the previous patch version will be replaced
  • What does it means in general terms? Starting from the specified date, all minor versions of Xcode 14 and Xcode 16 will be removed from the macOS-14 image.
  • What about other images? These changes will not affect macOS-12 and macOS-13 images. The changes will affect macOS-14 and all subsequent images. As a result, macOS-14-based images will contain only Xcode 15.x versions, macOS-15 images will contain only Xcode 16.x versions, and so on.
  • What happens when a new major Xcode beta is released and there is no next revision of the macOS image? Such a beta will be shipped as part of the latest macOS image that supports this Xcode, until the next base macOS image is released, for example: Xcode 16 was shipped as part of macOS-14 until we released macOS-15.

Target date

November 4, 2024

The motivation for the changes

Recently, mainly due to the introduction of the new visionOS platform, macOS-based images have grown to such sizes that they are becoming more difficult to maintain, and users are experiencing difficulties with available disk space, which is critical for completing builds. Parent issue:

Possible impact

Workflows based on macOS-14 will stop running if they depend on Xcode 14 and/or Xcode 16

Platforms affected

  • Azure DevOps
  • GitHub Actions

Runner images affected

  • Ubuntu 20.04
  • Ubuntu 22.04
  • Ubuntu 24.04
  • macOS 12
  • macOS 13
  • macOS 13 Arm64
  • macOS 14
  • macOS 14 Arm64
  • macOS 15
  • macOS 15 Arm64
  • Windows Server 2019
  • Windows Server 2022

Mitigation ways

Users whose workflows depend on Xcode 14 and/or Xcode 16 will be forced to use the macOS-13 image for Xcode-14 and the macOS-15 image for Xcode-16, respectively. Be aware that macos-13 YAML label refer to Intel-based image.

@Cheesebaron
Copy link

This is a bit messed up since macos-15 is not available in Azure DevOps Pipelines. Will they be available in time for this change?

vszakats added a commit to vszakats/curl that referenced this issue Oct 1, 2024
vszakats added a commit to curl/curl that referenced this issue Oct 1, 2024
- Days of `macos-12` are numbered:
  actions/runner-images#10721
  Drop 5 affected jobs, replaced by `macos-15` ones added earlier today.

- Drop Xcode 14 and 16 from `macos-14` jobs.
  Following up upstream announcement:
  actions/runner-images#10703
  (No active jobs are affected by this.)

Follow-up to 4b4ff44 #15108
Closes #15113
@LotskiAndrej
Copy link

This is a bit messed up since macos-15 is not available in Azure DevOps Pipelines. Will they be available in time for this change?

Can we get a response on this?

@erik-bershel
Copy link
Contributor Author

Hey @Cheesebaron and @LotskiAndrej!

We are working on adding macOS-15 to ADO, but no ETA or promises are available now. I'll publish info in #10686 once available.

@mjosipovic-tgr
Copy link

Is there any way to use Xcode 16 currently using macOS-14 ? I run task for checking Xcode version on ADO and got this, but it says it cannot locate xcode 16
Xcode.app
Xcode_14.3.1.app
Xcode_14.3.app
Xcode_15.0.1.app
Xcode_15.0.app
Xcode_15.1.0.app
Xcode_15.1.app
Xcode_15.2.0.app
Xcode_15.2.app
Xcode_15.3.0.app
Xcode_15.3.app
Xcode_15.4.0.app
Xcode_15.4.app
Xcode_16.0.0.app
Xcode_16.0.app
Xcode_16.1.0.app
Xcode_16.1.app
Xcode_16.1_beta_2.app
Xcode_16.app

@erik-bershel
Copy link
Contributor Author

Is there any way to use Xcode 16 currently using macOS-14 ?

Yes, we have not removed Xcode 16 from macOS-14. It will be done on October 28.

I run task for checking Xcode version on ADO and got this, but it says it cannot locate xcode 16

Recommended task: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/devops/pipelines/ecosystems/xcode?view=azure-devops

@mjosipovic-tgr
Copy link

mjosipovic-tgr commented Oct 4, 2024

Thanks for the response, but since I'm using MAUI, I cannot add xcWorkspacePath, and ADO crashes if I don't enter anything.
I tried like this also

- task: Bash@3
  displayName: 'Set Xcode Version to 16'
  inputs:
    targetType: 'inline'
    script: |
      sudo xcode-select -s /Applications/Xcode_16.0.app/Contents/Developer

But it cannot locate the file

@randyburden
Copy link

@mjosipovic-tgr, I am currently using the same command line command you are using with macOS-14 to set it to use Xcode 16 and it works fine.

sudo xcode-select -s /Applications/Xcode_16.app/Contents/Developer

I'm using the classic pipeline editor:

image

@mjosipovic-tgr
Copy link

I tried it few times, changed the order of the tasks in yaml, and managed to get it to work, tnx for the responses.

tgoyne added a commit to realm/realm-swift that referenced this issue Oct 9, 2024
Xcode 16 will be removed from macos-14 to cut down on the image size:
actions/runner-images#10703
tgoyne added a commit to realm/realm-swift that referenced this issue Oct 9, 2024
Xcode 16 will be removed from macos-14 to cut down on the image size:
actions/runner-images#10703
tgoyne added a commit to realm/realm-swift that referenced this issue Oct 9, 2024
Xcode 16 will be removed from macos-14 to cut down on the image size:
actions/runner-images#10703
tgoyne added a commit to realm/realm-swift that referenced this issue Oct 9, 2024
Xcode 16 will be removed from macos-14 to cut down on the image size:
actions/runner-images#10703
tgoyne added a commit to realm/realm-swift that referenced this issue Oct 9, 2024
Xcode 16 will be removed from macos-14 to cut down on the image size:
actions/runner-images#10703
tgoyne added a commit to realm/realm-swift that referenced this issue Oct 9, 2024
Xcode 16 will be removed from macos-14 to cut down on the image size:
actions/runner-images#10703
tgoyne added a commit to realm/realm-swift that referenced this issue Oct 9, 2024
Xcode 16 will be removed from macos-14 to cut down on the image size:
actions/runner-images#10703
tgoyne added a commit to realm/realm-swift that referenced this issue Oct 9, 2024
Xcode 16 will be removed from macos-14 to cut down on the image size:
actions/runner-images#10703
tgoyne added a commit to realm/realm-swift that referenced this issue Oct 10, 2024
Xcode 16 will be removed from macos-14 to cut down on the image size:
actions/runner-images#10703
@erik-bershel
Copy link
Contributor Author

erik-bershel commented Nov 15, 2024

Heads up! ⏰

To provide immediate mitigation, we have decided to roll back the current macos-14 images in production to the previous stable version from October 22. This should take about 24 hours, but may take up to 48 hours for some specific cases that can be worked around with a restart.

carsonRadtke added a commit to carsonRadtke/GSL that referenced this issue Nov 15, 2024
Looks like actions/runner-images#10703 took
away support for xcode 14. That is why the latest action failed. There
an active PR adding support for xcode 16 to the macos runner
(actions/runner-images#10967). This commit will
fail until that has been merged, but it is probably worth waiting for.
carsonRadtke added a commit to carsonRadtke/GSL that referenced this issue Nov 15, 2024
Looks like actions/runner-images#10703 took
away support for xcode 14. That is why the latest action failed. There
an active PR adding support for xcode 16 to the macos runner
(actions/runner-images#10967). This commit will
fail until that has been merged, but it is probably worth waiting for.
@yeftha
Copy link

yeftha commented Nov 16, 2024

@yeftha For this you can check th solution provided by mjosipovic-tgr in #10703 (comment)

@MerSpyro This fix is working fine . Thank you

@woutermeuwis
Copy link

woutermeuwis commented Nov 18, 2024

XCode 16 still does not seem available in the macOS-14 image?
When will this be available again?

ILLINK : warning MT0079: The recommended Xcode version for Microsoft.iOS 18.0.8314 is Xcode 16.0 or later. The current Xcode version (found in /Applications/Xcode_15.4.app/Contents/Developer) is 15.4. [/Users/runner/work/1/s/src/RmoniWeb.Maui/RmoniWeb.Maui.csproj::TargetFramework=net8.0-ios]

@erik-bershel
Copy link
Contributor Author

@woutermeuwis please switch to Xcode 16 before running your workflow. Issue states that the current Xcode version is set to 15.4, but it does not mean that there is no Xcode 16 at all.
Example action: https://github.com/maxim-lobanov/setup-xcode

akshayrdeodhar pushed a commit to akshayrdeodhar/llvm-project that referenced this issue Nov 18, 2024
…lvm#116216)

After a recent Github Actions runner policy change [1], the version of
Xcode included in the macos-14 image went from Xcode 16 to Xcode 15,
breaking our build bots.

This moves the bots to the macos 15 (public preview) image, which
contains Xcode 16.

Also, adjust an UNSUPPORTED annotation that was incorrectly targeting
macos 13.7 when it should have been targeting a version of AppleClang.

[1]: actions/runner-images#10703
ishwar-raut1 pushed a commit to ishwar-raut1/onnxruntime that referenced this issue Nov 19, 2024
- Work around Xcode 16 iOS test build issue: `error: Multiple commands produce '.../PlugIns'`.
- Fix link error in iOS static framework test.
- Update build.py to check for the right kind of build before running iOS tests on the simulator.
- Update Xcode 16 build images to 'macos-15' because that's the only image that will have Xcode 16 soon. See actions/runner-images#10703.
mfkrause added a commit to kuatsu/react-native-voicekit that referenced this issue Nov 20, 2024
@erik-bershel
Copy link
Contributor Author

👋

For those tracking these changes or encountering issues for the first time, here’s some context and clarification.

As you may know, we recently faced significant challenges where many users began running out of disk space during tests and builds on macOS-based runners. 😞 This issue was triggered by the inclusion of visionOS simulators in the latest Xcode builds. The root cause, however, lies in our policy of providing nearly all supported minor versions of Xcode on each macOS image, leading to steadily increasing disk usage as Apple’s ecosystem grows.

Here’s how we’ve approached resolving the issue so far:

  • Immediate action: We temporarily stopped pre-installing visionOS platform tools in Xcode on macOS-14 images.
  • Strategic adjustment: We introduced a policy to limit the number of major Xcode versions installed per macOS image, alongside reinstating visionOS tools for supported Xcode versions. This aimed to free up significant disk space. [doc] Update Xcode support policy #10876

However, we’ve discovered that some projects rely on multiple major versions of Xcode simultaneously, making these strict measures overly restrictive. This prompted us to refine our strategy, prioritising functionality alongside disk space optimisation.

Current Strategy 📏

Our updated approach balances reducing installed Xcode versions with maintaining runner usability:

  1. macOS-14 images:
  • Will include all minor releases of Xcode 15 with the full platform tools suite (as before).
  • Will now also include two minor releases of Xcode 16 (excluding visionOS tools). These will follow a “last two” principle, with the oldest replaced by the newest as updates are released. Beta versions will not be included. [macOS] Add Xcode16 back to macOS14 images #10962
  1. macOS-15 images:
  • Will include all minor releases of Xcode 16 with the full platform tools suite (as before).
  • Will also include the latest available release of Xcode 15 with the full platform tools suite. [macOS] Add Xcode 15.4 to macOS-15 #11023
  1. Disk Space and Future Adjustments:
  • Currently, macOS-14 images have approximately 60 GB of free space. However, this is not a guaranteed figure and may decrease over time.
  • When free space approaches 30 GB, we will reassess our policies and toolsets to ensure compliance with our promised minimum of 14 GB of free space.
  • macOS-15 images are not currently impacted by this issue. However, with future Xcode updates, policies may need to be revisited. 🤷‍♂️

Recommendations 🦮

  • If your workflows depend on visionOS, we recommend switching to macOS-15 images.
  • If your tasks require significant disk space, consider preparing the runner by removing unnecessary large components before starting your workflows.

@erik-bershel erik-bershel closed this as not planned Won't fix, can't repro, duplicate, stale Nov 27, 2024
rubiefawn pushed a commit to rubiefawn/lmms that referenced this issue Nov 28, 2024
* Use macOS 13

See: actions/runner-images#10721

* Upgrade to XCode 15.2

XCode 15.2 is the default on macOS 13

* Fix unqualified call to std::move warning

* Fix sprintf deprecated warnings

* Upgrade macOS 14 ARM64 builds to XCode 15.4

See: actions/runner-images#10703

* Fix unused lambda capture warnings in Fader.cpp

* Fix unused variable warnings

* Fix formatting warning

Cannot format `const void*` as a string

* Force lambda conversion to function pointer
Xmader added a commit to Distributive-Network/PythonMonkey that referenced this issue Nov 29, 2024
There's a recent change in GitHub hosted runners that only one major version of Xcode will be available per macOS version.

See actions/runner-images#10703
@mikeknack86
Copy link

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests