2016 presidential candidates on Syrian refugees

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search



Presidential Elections-2016-badge.png

2016 Presidential Election
Date: November 8, 2016

Candidates
Winner: Donald Trump (R)
Hillary Clinton (D) • Jill Stein (G) • Gary Johnson (L) • Vice presidential candidates

Election coverage
Important datesNominating processBallotpedia's 2016 Battleground PollPollsDebatesPresidential election by stateRatings and scorecards

Ballotpedia's presidential election coverage
2028202420202016

Have you subscribed yet?

Join the hundreds of thousands of readers trusting Ballotpedia to keep them up to date with the latest political news. Sign up for the Daily Brew.
Click here to learn more.



For information about refugee policy under the Trump administration, click here.

The overview of the issue below was current as of the 2016 election.
The 2016 presidential candidates quickly took to Twitter and their websites to release statements expressing their support for the people of France after members of the Islamic State (ISIS) killed at least 129 people and wounded more than 350 during a terrorist attack that occurred at six separate locations in Paris on November 13, 2015.[1]

After reports surfaced showing that one of the terrorists responsible for the attacks in Paris may have traveled to France posing as a Syrian refugee, Obama’s plan to allow 10,000 new Syrian refugees into the United States was criticized by most of the GOP candidates. More than half of the country's governors—including former Republican presidential candidates Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal and Ohio Gov. John Kasich and Donald Trump's 2016 running mate Indiana Gov. Mike Pence—announced that their states would not accept Syrian refugees.

Some governors said that they would reconsider the ban only after the Obama administration reviewed its procedures for allowing Syrian refugees into the country. According to American University law professor Stephen I. Vladeck, states cannot legally refuse to accept the refugees, but they can choose to not cooperate, which is what Kasich and Jindal said they would to do.[2][3]

See what the 2016 candidates and their respective party platforms said about Syrian refugees below.

OVERVIEW OF CANDIDATE POSITIONS
  • Hillary Clinton rejected calls to refuse Syrian refugees in the U.S.
  • Donald Trump expressed support for surveilling mosques in the U.S. for jihadist rhetoric, potentially closing mosques, and establishing a "total and complete shutdown” of Muslims entering the U.S.
  • Jill Stein supported accepting 100,000 Syrian refugees in the U.S.
  • Gary Johnson opposed military intervention in Syria and said the U.S. should take its "fair share" of Syrian refugees.
  • Democratic ticket

    Democratic Party Hillary Clinton

    caption
    • On November 23, 2015, Hillary Clinton said that it was “not smart” to summarily reject Muslim refugees because of its potential impact on law enforcement. She said, “If you're in law enforcement ... you want the people in the communities that you are looking to get information from to feel like they want to help you. And if the message from people who are running for president, for example, is that we don't want to take any Muslims whatsoever, that's not good for law enforcement."[4]
    • Clinton gave a speech at the Council on Foreign Relations on November 19, 2015, where she ejected calls to refuse Syrian refugees in the U.S. She said, “Turning away orphans, applying a religious test, discriminating against Muslims, slamming the door on every Syrian refugee—that is just not who we are. We are better than that. And remember, many of these refugees are fleeing the same terrorists who threaten us. It would be a cruel irony indeed if ISIS can force families from their homes, and then also prevent them from ever finding new ones. We should be doing more to ease this humanitarian crisis, not less. We should lead the international community in organizing a donor conference and supporting countries like Jordan, who are sheltering the majority of refugees fleeing Syria.”[5]
    • At a campaign event in Dallas on November 17, 2015, Clinton expressed her support for allowing Syrian refugees into the country. She said, "We have always welcomed immigrants and refugees. We have made people feel that if they did their part, they sent their kids to school, they worked hard, there would be a place for them in America."[6]
    • Read more of Hillary Clinton's public statements on 2016 campaign issues.

    Democratic Party Tim Kaine

    caption
    • Tim Kaine called for establishing safe zones to protect civilian lives and supply lines for food, water, and medical supplies in Syria. In 2014, he led an effort in the Senate to pass the Syrian Humanitarian Resolution. It called for fully implementing UN Security Council Resolution 2139 to ease the delivery of humanitarian aid to Syrians. The resolution also pressed the Obama administration to submit to Congress a comprehensive strategy to address the Syrian humanitarian crisis.[9]
    • Kaine said that the U.S. had a moral responsibility to take in more Syrian refugees. On May 21, 2016, Kaine and a dozen senators wrote to President Barack Obama requesting that the U.S. accept “at least 50 percent of Syrian refugees whom UNHCR [United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees] is seeking to resettle.” They also wrote, "Indeed, we cannot expect countries hosting Syrian refugees to continue shouldering such a disproportionate burden if the United States and other industrialized countries do not begin resettling many more Syrian refugees."[10]
    • On May 18, 2016, Kaine and 25 U.S. Senate colleagues wrote to President Obama urging him to meet his administration's commitment to resettle at least 10,000 Syrian refugees in the United States. "We write to express our strong support for resettling Syrian refugees in the United States and to urge your Administration to make every effort to meet your commitment to accept at least 10,000 Syrian refugees in fiscal year 2016,” the senators wrote. “Nonetheless, we are deeply concerned about the slow pace of admissions for Syrian refugees in the first seven months of the fiscal year. During this timeframe only 1,736 Syrian refugees were admitted to the United States. By contrast, more than 6,000 refugees have been admitted from Burma, more than 5,000 refugees have been admitted from both the Democratic Republic of Congo and Somalia, and more than 4,000 refugees have been admitted from Iraq.” The senators also noted that “refugees are the most carefully vetted of all travelers to the United States” and “no refugees are admitted until after successful completion of [a] stringent security screening regime.”[11]
    • During hearings in both the Foreign Relations and Armed Services Committees on January 20, 2016, Kaine asked witnesses whether they believed ISIL or Syrian refugees were a bigger enemy to the United States. That day he also voted against the American Security Against Foreign Enemies Act. After casting his vote, he said in a statement, “Today I voted against consideration of a bill that would have labeled millions of innocent people fleeing the worst humanitarian crisis since World War II as enemies of the United States. Instead of allowing amendments that would actually keep Americans safer – including closing the terrorist gun loophole and increasing funding for anti-terror efforts by local law enforcement and airport security – Republicans would rather talk tough for political gain while doing nothing to strengthen our security." He also said, "If Congress was really serious about keeping America ‘secure against foreign enemies’ we would be voting to authorize the war against our real enemy – ISIL. A debate and vote in Congress would show both our allies and adversaries that we are unified in our resolve against ISIL and committed to defeating the terrorist threat, while also sending an important signal of support to the more than 3,500 U.S. servicemembers we’ve deployed into harm’s way over the past 18 months.”[12]

    Republican ticket

    Republican Party Donald Trump

    caption
    • Trump said that he would be comfortable personally telling Syrian refugee children that they were not permitted to come to the U.S., during a town hall meeting on February 8, 2016. "I can look at their faces and say, 'Look, you can't come here.’ … Their parents should always stay with them. But we don't know where their parents come from. We have no documentation whatsoever. There's absolutely no way of saying where these people come from,” Trump said, before recommending a “safe zone” be created in Syria for refugees.[13]
    • Trump criticized German Chancellor Angela Merkel for permitting Syrian refugees to settle in Germany after the Paris terrorist attacks. He said, "As far as Merkel's concerned, she ought to be ashamed of herself, what she's done. … She blew it, when she allowed this to happen, this migration."[14]
    • At a rally in Beaumont, Texas, Trump discussed allowing Syrian refugees into the U.S. after reports said that one of the terrorist who carried out the attacks in Paris posed as a Syrian refugee. Trump said, "We all have heart and we all want people taken care of, but with the problems our country has, to take in 250,000—some of whom are going to have problems, big problems—is just insane. We have to be insane. Terrible."[2]
    • Read more of Donald Trump's public statements on 2016 campaign issues.

    Republican Party Mike Pence

    caption
    • After the November 13, 2015, terror attacks in Paris, Indiana Gov. Mike Pence (R) issued a directive to state agencies to halt the resettlement of Syrian refugees in the state. In July 2016, Pence appeared on "60 Minutes" and said, “In Indiana, we suspended the Syrian refugee program" following the terrorist attack in Paris. According to The Washington Post, one family that was set to resettle in Indiana was redirected to Connecticut after Pence’s November 2015 announcement. On February 29, 2016, a federal judge blocked Pence's directive blocking state agencies from helping Syrian refugees resettle in Indiana. The judge said Pence's order "clearly discriminates" against Syrian refugees. Judge Tanya Walton Pratt found that Pence’s directive “clearly constitutes national origin discrimination” in a policy of “punishing Syrian refugees already in Indiana in the hopes that no more will come.”[16][17][18]
      • Also according to The Washington Post, as of late August 2016, 140 Syrian refugees have resettled in Indiana and more are expected.[19]
    • Refugee resettlement groups in Indianapolis ignored Pence’s November 2015 order. During a meeting in December 2015, Pence told Archbishop Joseph Tobin he was "concerned that Syrian refugees could pose a security risk and that the United States has not put proper screening procedures in place."[17]
    • Discussing Pence's November 2015 directive, Indiana Attorney General Greg Zoeller (R) wrote, “Governor Pence has merely suspended, in part, a discretionary federal grant program.” Zoeller continued, “This is meant as a deterrent, but if those agencies wish to resettle those refugees regardless, the Governor will not take further actions (besides denying their claims) to stop them.”[17]
    • Pence sought to withhold federal funding from groups in Indiana that help Syrian refugees obtain services and training.[20]

    Green ticket

    Green Party Jill Stein

    Jill-Stein-circle.png
    • In an interview with teleSUR on November 3, 2015, Jill Stein discussed the approach she would take with refugees. She said, "We need to pitch-in proportional to our ability to do so. We need to do our part for emergency relief and we need to accept our portion of the refugees." Stein continued, "There are refugee associations calling on the U.S. to accept, I believe, 100,000 (Syrians) and that’s the figure we need to be talking about. And we need to put out the welcome mat and, I would say, this is with regard to the refugees who are already in the country as well -- the refugees from Latin America that we are holding in detention centers. Women and children who are being held in family detention. This is an absolute human rights outrage that people who we have forced into becoming refugees are being criminalized. It’s very clear to see how in the way we’re treating children fleeing from Honduras and Guatemala how they’ve been criminalized. And I think we’re treating Syrian refugees not quite that bad, but almost that bad, and we need to recognize the human rights of refugees and do so on an emergency basis."[21]
    • Read more of Jill Stein's public statements on 2016 campaign issues.

    Green Party Ajamu Baraka

    captin
    • In an October 3, 2016, interview with The Real News Network, Sharmini Peries said that a ceasefire in Syria "really is dependent on the United States and Russia being able to bring and convince all of its proxies participating in Syria to some order." She asked Baraka, "How does the Green Party plan to deal with this problem if you were in power?" Baraka replied, "I think it’s clear that every force involved in this conflict has to be part of any solution including the current Syrian government. This notion that the US and Russia will determine the fate of Syrian people to me is a unworkable position. It is a position that denies the voice of the Syrian people and it is a position that has a colonial character that I reject. So if there’s going to be a real resolution then those forces have to be at the table. But at the centerpiece of that has to be the legitimate government of Syria."[23]
    • Baraka briefly discussed Syrian refugees and political leaders in the U.S. in his December 16, 2015, article posted on his Black Agenda Report blog. After describing the hypocrisy of U.S. political leaders as "galling," Baraka wrote, "That is why the hypocrisy of political leaders in the U.S. is so galling. The de-valuation of Arab and Muslim lives has been an operative principle of U.S. policies in the Middle-East since it became the hegemonic power in the region. There is not much space between Hillary Clinton’s joke about the murder of Muammar Gaddafy—“We came, we saw, he died”—which of course took place during a murderous NATO assault on Libya that by conservative estimates killed tens of thousands, and the positions of various governors on the issue of Syrian refugees and even with Donald Trump’s latest proposal to temporarily ban Muslim immigration."[24]
    • In an article largely about bombings in Yemen and their impact on the Yemeni people, Baraka wrote, "And while U.S. propagandists are preparing the people for an even more direct intervention into Syria, using the absurd pretext that somehow the imposition of a “no fly zone” is an appropriate response to the humanitarian concerns of refugee flows from Syria to Europe, the humanitarian emergency created by the war in Yemen is largely uncovered and outside the bounds of polite conversation in the U.S."[25]
    • In an essay published online on June 4, 2014, by CounterPunch, Baraka said the West and the corporate media had "carefully cultivated" a narrative on Syria which described the conflict as "a courageous fight on the part of the majority of the Syrian people against the brutal dictatorship of Bashar al-Assad. As the story goes, the al-Assad “regime,” (it is never referred to as a government), can only maintain its power through the use of force. By attacking “its own citizens,” the regime, representing the minority Alawite community, can only maintain its dominance over the rest of the country through sheer terror." Baraka said that this narrative was undermined when "Western corporate news outlets, especially in the U.S., were unable to explain the huge turnout of Syrian refugees voting in Lebanon preceding the election on Tuesday, so they just decided not to cover it. Images of Syrians displaced by war yet backing al Assad for president did not support the carefully crafted story that the only people fleeting war were those who had been terrorized to do so by the government."[26]
    • Read more about Ajamu Baraka.

    Libertarian ticket

    Libertarian Party Gary Johnson

    Gary-Johnson-(New Mexico)-circle.png
    • In an interview with Reason in November 2015, Johnson criticized drone strikes. He said, "When it comes to drones, I think it makes a bad situation even worse. We end up killing innocents and fueling hatred as opposed to containing it. It just hasn't worked." He also briefly discussed the Syrian refugee crisis, saying, "We need to take our share, and I'm not sure what that share should be. I'd like to come up with a formula based on our coalition partners. I wouldn't say zero, but I don't know if 65,000 puts us in the category of 'our fair share.'"[27]

    Libertarian Party Bill Weld

    William-Weld-circle.png
    • Speaking to students at Emerson College on September 8, 2016, Weld said that the Libertarian Party focuses on "soft power and cultural diplomacy, rather than military intervention" in its approach to foreign policy. He also said that it can be difficult to tell the difference between a civil war and genocide in a country like Syria. For Libertarians, he said, any military intervention should be linked to "an attack on the United States as opposed to something terrible that's happening in another country."[29]
    • Read more about Bill Weld.



    Withdrawn candidates

    Recent news

    The link below is to the most recent stories in a Google news search for the terms 2016 Presidential candidates on Syrian refugees. These results are automatically generated from Google. Ballotpedia does not curate or endorse these articles.

    See also

    External links

    Footnotes

    1. CNN, "Paris victims: From all over the world and all walks of life," accessed November 17, 2015
    2. 2.0 2.1 CNN, "More than half the nation's governors say Syrian refugees not welcome," accessed November 17, 2015
    3. CNN, "Federal court blasts Pence on Syrian refugees," October 3, 2016
    4. U.S. News & World Report, "Clinton says hard-line stances against admitting refugees could hurt law enforcement," November 23, 2015
    5. Council on Foreign Relations, "A Conversation With Hillary Clinton," November 19, 2015
    6. CBS News, "Hillary Clinton weighs in on Syrian refugee crisis," November 17, 2015
    7. 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 Note: This text is quoted verbatim from the original source. Any inconsistencies are attributable to the original source.
    8. Democratic Party, "The 2016 Democratic Party Platform," accessed August 24, 2016
    9. Tim Kaine United States Senator for Virginia, "Foreign Relations Committee," accessed July 25, 2016
    10. USA Today, "Fact check: Trump blasts Kaine for Syrian refugee plan," July 27, 2016
    11. Tim Kaine United States Senator for Virginia, "KAINE CALLS ON PRESIDENT OBAMA TO FULFILL COMMITMENT TO RESETTLE 10,000 SYRIAN REFUGEES IN AMERICA," May 18, 2016
    12. Blue Virginia, "Sen. Tim Kaine: 'The enemy is not refugees from Syria. The enemy is ISIL.'” January 20, 2016
    13. CNN Politics, "Donald Trump: I can tell refugees 'you can't come here,'" February 8, 2016
    14. CNN, "Donald Trump: Syrian refugees a 'Trojan horse'," accessed November 17, 2015
    15. Republican Party, "The 2016 Republican Party Platform," accessed August 24, 2016
    16. NBC News, "Federal Judge Rules Indiana Gov. Mike Pence Can't Block Syrian Refugees," March 1, 2016
    17. 17.0 17.1 17.2 The Washington Post, "Mike Pence wants to keep Syrian refugees out of Indiana. They’re coming anyway." August 28, 2016
    18. The New York Times, "Mike Pence's Illegal Treatment of Syrian Refugees," September 15, 2016
    19. The Washington Post, "Mike Pence wants to keep Syrian refugees out of Indiana. They’re coming anyway." August 28, 2016
    20. Chicago Tribune, "Lawyers grilled over Indiana Gov. Mike Pence's Syrian refugees order," September 14, 2016
    21. teleSUR, "US Presidential Candidate Jill Stein: I Want to Be President to Save the World," November 3, 2015
    22. Green Party, "The 2016 Green Party Platform on Democracy," accessed August 10, 2016
    23. The Real News Network, "Green Party VP Ajamu Baraka on the Middle East," October 3, 2016
    24. Black Agenda Report, "Why African Americans Should Stand with Muslims and Arabs," December 16, 2015
    25. CounterPunch, "The Yemen Tragedy and the Ongoing Crisis of the Left in the United States," September 16, 2015
    26. CounterPunch, "The Syrian Elections," June 4, 2014
    27. Reason.com, "Gary Johnson Talks ISIS, Refugees, Black Lives Matter and Marijuana Leglization," November 19, 2015
    28. Libertarian Party, "The 2016 Libertarian Party Platform," accessed August 24, 2016
    29. MassLive.com, "Bill Weld says Gary Johnson's Aleppo gaffe was 'not so bad,'" September 8, 2016