When you buy through our links, Business Insider may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more
After testing 100 mattresses, interviewing countless industry insiders and experts, and sleeping on a new mattress every two to four weeks, I certainly know the value of a good night's sleep. That said, finding the best mattress for you is a highly personal endeavor: I've learned certain characteristics appeal more to specific sleepers, whether they're a side sleeper who seeks a plush mattress with top-tier pressure relief and motion isolation or a back sleeper who sleeps hot, looking for something cooling with a medium-firmness. This guide outlines my findings of the top beds that consider a variety of sleep preferences and budgets.
The Leesa Sapira Hybrid Mattress is the best mattress for most people. The heat dissipation keeps you cool, couples will love the motion isolation and edge support, and the average firmness will appeal to most sleepers. The Allswell Hybrid Mattress is our budget favorite with its sub-$300 price and great motion isolation and edge support, though it retains heat and might be too firm for side sleepers.
Black Friday is the perfect time to find a great mattress at a discount and most of our top picks are on sale. Check out our guide to the best Black Friday mattress deals for the latest sales taking place right now.
Learn more about how Business Insider Reviews tests and reviews home products.
Our picks of the top-rated mattresses
Best overall: Leesa Sapira Hybrid Mattress - See at Leesa
Best luxury: Saatva Classic Mattress - See at Saatva
Best budget: The Allswell Mattress - See at Walmart
Best for combination sleepers: Tempur-Pedic Cloud Mattress - See at Tempur-Pedic
Best for side sleepers: WinkBeds EcoCloud Mattress - See at WinkBeds
Best for back sleepers: Helix Dusk Luxe Mattress - See at Helix
Best for stomach sleepers: Awara Organic Luxury Hybrid Mattress - See at Awara
Best for back pain: Nectar Classic Memory Foam Mattress - See at Nectar
Best organic: Birch Natural Mattress by Helix - See at Birch
Best cooling: Nest Bedding Finch Latex Mattress - See at Nest Bedding
Best adjustable: Sleep Number i8 Smart Bed - See at Sleep Number
Best for heavy people: Big Fig Mattress - See at Big Fig
Best overall
The Leesa Sapira Hybrid Mattress provides great edge support and motion isolation. Its mix of memory foam and pocket springs produces an average firmness, making it an outstanding solution for back pain sufferers of any sleeping style. Save an extra $25 with our exclusive promo code INSIDER25.
- Foam and pocket springs offer breathability and support
- Ideal motion isolation and edge support for couples
- Medium firmness will benefit all sleeping styles
- Heavy and difficult to maneuver
Before I started testing a new mattress every two weeks, I slept on the Leesa Sapira Hybrid Mattress for a year and loved it. My wife is a back sleeper, while I sleep on my stomach and side, and we both found it offered an outstanding balance of comfort and support with excellent motion transfer.
In the four years since I tested this, I have only found two or three mattresses with comparable comfort, yet these fell short in other areas, whether they were too soft for some sleepers or lacked adequate edge support. The Leesa Sapira checks all the boxes. It's great for all sleeping positions, which is why it tops several of our mattress guides.
As the best hybrid mattress, it is constructed of foam and steel coils. From top to bottom, the five layers are cooling foam, contouring memory foam, and airflow-facilitating 14.5-gauge pocket springs nestled between two supportive foam layers. The cooling foam and airflow did a great job keeping my hot-sleeping body cool even on the muggiest summer nights when the AC struggled to keep up.
I have a history of back pain. Yet, while testing the Leesa Sapira Hybrid, I never awoke with back pain. It supplied the comfort and pressure relief I needed to recover when I wrenched my back while putting together a standing desk. I think it's the best mattress for back pain. However, this is based on my experience. Back pain sufferers should consult with a doctor before buying a new mattress. Also, consider getting someone else to help unbox the bed since it is heavy unless you opt for in-home set up and delivery, which is available for an extra cost.
The Leesa Sapira is also one of the best mattresses for couples because it has good edge support that keeps you comfortable right to the edge. The motion isolation keeps you from feeling jostled as your partner moves at night.
Customers on Reddit and Amazon have expressed their satisfaction with the Leesa Sapira Hybrid's pain relief and comfort, though there were concerns about its long-term durability and initial odor. Keep in mind that if the mattress shows significant indentation, Leesa will fix or replace it during the 10-year warranty.
Read our full Leesa Sapira Hybrid Mattress review.
Best luxury
The Saatva Classic Mattress is designed to suit a variety of sleeping styles and features a plush top for luxurious comfort.
- Free in-home setup and old mattress removal
- Zoned support
- Great heat dissipation
- Good bounce
- Outstanding edge support
- Long home trial and warranty
- Average motion isolation
- $99 fee deducted from your refund if you return the bed
The Saatva Classic gives luxury without a high-end price. All Saatva mattresses include free in-home setup and old mattress removal, which is virtually unheard of at this price point. The bed features zoned support and a dual-coil design that helps relieve pressure points and align my spine.
The bed's 3-inch Euro pillow top is constructed of cool-feeling organic cotton. Below that is memory foam with a firmer middle third to offer back support. Next, the individually wrapped pocket coils contour to your body. Then, an additional base coil layer adds airflow and durability. The Classic gets unparalleled edge support from a high-density foam that borders the springs.
I tend to overheat in bed and appreciated how well the Saatva Classic dissipated heat. I tested the Luxury Firm as a side sleeper, and my hips and shoulders couldn't sink in enough to keep my spine neutral. Consequently, I had to flip to my back or wake up sore. If given the chance, I'd choose the Plush Soft version, a better option for my side sleeping. Senior home editor Jaclyn Turner slept on the Saatva Classic for nearly two years as a predominant back sleeper and appreciated the gentle support combined with the plush pillow-top design. However, she experienced a break-in period.
I didn't feel pets or people moving when lying on the bed. Yet, the Classic failed the bowling ball test and had higher than usual vibrometer readings, suggesting so-so motion isolation. However, with the impressive edge support, I'd still recommend this mattress for couples.
Mattress reviews on the Saatva site echo Turner's break-in period experience: The Saatva Classic takes a little getting used to, but once they do, it's supportive and comfortable. The biggest customer complaint is delivery delays, so you may want to hold onto your old mattress until the Classic arrives. Free removal of your old mattress is included in your purchase.
Read our full Saatva Classic Mattress review.
Best budget
The Allswell Mattress is the best hybrid we’ve tested for under $500. It's firm enough to support stomach and back sleepers and ideal for couples with its impressive edge support and motion isolation.
- Good motion dampening
- Great firmness for stomach and back sleepers
- Cold sleepers will appreciate the heat retention
- Impressive edge support
- Our tester had excellent sleep quality
- May run too hot for most hot sleepers
- Might be too firm for side sleepers
- No showroom availability or in-home setup delivery
For our guide to the best cheap mattresses, we tested 13 sub-$500 mattresses. Of those, the Allswell was the winner. It's a hybrid, a rarity in this price range. CertiPUR-US-certified foam comprises the top three layers: a high-density memory foam top support layer, cooling gel memory foam offering pressure relief below that, and body-contouring comfort foam. Below these foam layers are individually wrapped coils supplying airflow, durability, and support. On the bottom is a durable high-density foam layer.
According to my Garmin Forerunner 945 watch readings and my subjective experience, I slept better on the $320 Allswell than on any other cheap mattress I tested. While I prefer to sleep on my side, the firm feel forced me onto my back and stomach.
Couples will like the outstanding edge support and good motion isolation. However, hot sleepers may want to look elsewhere, as the mattress did not dissipate heat well.
A Walmart reviewer called the Allswell the "best mattress that I have ever bought and slept on" because it helped alleviate back pain so they could get a good night's sleep. While the mattress reviews are mainly positive, a consistent complaint is it sometimes fails to expand fully. I see this when a bed has been in the box for too long. Unbox your mattress within a week or two of it arriving. If it doesn't fully expand, contact Walmart for a replacement.
Side sleepers on a budget might consider the Siena Memory Foam Mattress due to its softer feel. It stays cool, dissipates heat well, and offers good edge support and motion isolation.
Read our full Allswell Mattress review.
Best for combination sleepers
The Tempur-Pedic Cloud Mattress features contouring foam that cradles sleepers of all body types and sleeping styles while offering outstanding pressure relief and heat dissipation.
- Layers of conforming comfortable and supportive Tempur foam adjust to all sleeping styles
- Impressive motion isolation
- Excellent heat dissipation
- Unimpressive edge support
- Shipping fee deducted from refund
While I mostly sleep on my side, I adjust to my back and stomach throughout the night. My favorite mattress for combination sleeping is the Sleep Number Climate360 adjustable bed, but its luxury price is out of most people's budgets. Instead, the Tempur-Pedic Cloud Mattress is the best bet for most sleepers and budgets, and it's also one of the best memory foam mattresses you can buy.
The Tempur-Cloud stands out because it features three layers of Tempur-Pedic's proprietary foam: a soft and responsive comfort top layer, a firmer support layer, and a supportive base. Combined, they do an outstanding job of adjusting to your body's contours regardless of position. For instance, the foam contoured to my body and offered impressive pressure relief. I was comfortable on my stomach and side, and my wife, a back sleeper, enjoyed the feel. I suffer from lower back pain that flares up when I sleep on an unsupportive mattress, but the Cloud offered superb support, and my back remained pain-free.
Its versatility makes it an excellent option for couples with different sleeping styles. Couples will also appreciate the outstanding motion isolation, so you aren't jostled as your partner shifts at night, or when a rambunctious child or dog hops in bed, you'll barely notice.
I also liked the excellent heat dissipation, a rarity for an all-foam mattress. I stayed cool all night despite my tendency to overheat on other mattresses. The polyester-blend stretch cover is moisture-wicking and breathes well.
The main negative is that the Cloud exhibited poor edge support. When I was close to the bed's edges, I sank significantly. Couples may want a king for more space without feeling uncomfortable on the edges.
In Reddit's mattress community, the customer reviews for the Tempur-Cloud are mostly positive. The general vibe is it's a great value from one of the best mattress brands. Users like how the material conforms to their body soon after lying down. The most common customer complaint on Tempur-Pedic's site is that the bed is too firm.
Read our full Tempur-Pedic Cloud Mattress review and guide to the best memory foam mattresses.
Best for side sleepers
The EcoCloud Mattress by WinkBeds features responsive latex foam and zoned support for a luxurious plush feel ideal for side sleepers.
- Good balance of support and pressure relief for side sleepers
- Great motion isolation and edge support
- Good bounce
- Lifetime warranty
- Zoned support
- Made of eco-friendly materials
- May not be supportive enough for heavier back or stomach sleepers
- Doesn’t dissipate heat well
The EcoCloud by WinkBeds is a little softer than average, making it ideal for side sleepers, yet it's firm enough that petite to average stomach and back sleepers may still find it supportive.
The cover is made of organic cotton and wool. Below that is a responsive layer of OEKO-TEX-certified sustainable latex that gives the mattress good bounce. Next, individually wrapped innerspring coils with zoned support offer targeted support in the heavier areas of your body. Firmer springs surround the bed's periphery to lend extra edge support. In my tests, these springs did the job, as the sides sagged minimally.
While waiting for more mattresses to test, I turned to the EcoCloud for optimal side-sleeping comfort. I didn't sink into the mattress much, yet it relieved pressure as I recovered from long runs. I appreciated that I fell asleep quickly while testing this bed. However, on hotter nights, I wish it cooled faster. In our tests, it dissipated heat poorly.
The WinkBeds EcoCloud performed well in our motion isolation tests. Combined with its great edge support, this is an excellent option for couples.
When browsing the reviews on the WinkBeds site and Reddit, I found a mixed bag of complaints about the firmness. Several customers found it too firm, and others too soft. This tells me that it's somewhere in the middle. Fortunately, the brand offers a 120-night trial period with free returns.
For more recommendations, check out our best mattress for side sleepers guide.
Best for back sleepers
The medium-firm Helix Dusk Luxe is tailor-made for back and stomach sleepers. The hybrid sleeps exceptionally cool and provides excellent support, but edge support was lacking. Use our exclusive promo code INSIDER27 to save 27% off and get two free pillows.
- Excellent comfort and support for back sleepers
- Sleeps cool
- Ergo-Align layer (add-on) provides extra support for those with a history of back pain
- Likely too firm for strict side sleepers
- Poor edge support
- Minimal showroom availability
The Helix Dusk Luxe Hybrid Mattress is a great medium-firm option for back sleepers that balances comfort and support with cooling features to leave you waking refreshed and pain-free.
I found the Dusk Luxe immensely supportive; the medium-firm feel slightly contours to my body, keeps my spine aligned, and offers relief for the densest part of my body. Back and stomach sleepers will most benefit from this level of support and firmness. It keeps the lower half of my body from sinking too far into the mattress, but I do admire a tinge of plush. It is likely too firm for lighter-weight side sleepers, as I noticed pressure build up if I spent prolonged periods just on my side. It was fine for short stints, however, like when I scroll my phone in bed.
It also sleeps incredibly cool (I tested with the optional GlacioTex cover), and I never dealt with hot spots. Within 2 minutes of getting up, the heat dissipated pretty close back to the ambient temperature of my bedroom. The mattress passed our motion transfer test and also offers some slight bounce, making it easy to change positions in bed without disturbing your partner. I took the most issue with the bed's edge support, which sunk about 3.5 inches, but not enough that you'd feel like you might roll off the bed.
The Helix Dusk Luxe is a hybrid mattress with a pillowtop comprised of six different layers. For the cover, you can choose between a quilted Tencel cover or upgrade to its cooling GlacioTex cover made with fibers to draw heat away from the body. Below that are three layers of foam, followed by individually wrapped pocket coils. A final foam base layer offers durability. Those with a history of back pain or seeking extra pressure relief may want to add on the optional ErgoAlign layer, which provides zoned support in the top layer of foam.
Helix offers more than 25 mattresses across three collections, a base, Luxe, and Elite, which can be confusing to sift through. Fortunately, a mattress quiz makes it easier to identify the best mattress for your needs, with various firmness options for side and back and stomach sleepers. The mattresses all follow a similar construction, but their foam densities will vary according to your desired feel. In my case, the Dusk Luxe was the recommendation, and an accurate one at that for my sleep needs. If the mattress is too firm or soft for your liking, Helix will send a free mattress topper. Helix offers a 100-night sleep trial with free returns, though requires a typical 30-day adjustment period from delivery date. — Jaclyn Turner, senior home editor
Read our full Helix Dusk Luxe Hybrid Mattress review and our guide to the best mattresses for back sleepers.
Best for stomach sleepers
Made with natural foam and New Zealand wool, Awara's mattress includes latex-wrapped coil springs for bounce and support.
- Good heat dissipation
- Made of eco-friendly materials
- All four sides have two handles
- Not ideal for side sleepers
- Sinks significantly when sitting on the side
A firmer mattress supports stomach sleepers by keeping their spine aligned, protecting them from back pain. The Awara Organic Luxury Hybrid Mattress provides slightly firm, comfortable support. The firm feel is balanced by a plush Euro-top made of organic wool. Next is a Rainforest Alliance-certified Dunlop latex layer, and the support core contains individually wrapped coils. As a combination side and stomach sleeper, I preferred stomach sleeping on the Awara. During the testing period, I didn't experience any soreness.
Both the edge support and motion isolation were middle of the road. The Awara failed our motion transfer tests, but the mattress is quite bouncy, which some people may like. The mattress cover has two handles sewn into all four sides for easy moving, an important feature since it is one of the heaviest mattresses in our guide. Despite the heft, it's still one of the best mattresses in a box. I set it up without help in about five minutes.
Best for back pain
The gel memory foam of the Nectar makes it a versatile mattress that conforms to the contours of your body to relieve pressure. It's a premium sleep experience, but its price tag is way under a grand.
- Year-long home trial and lifetime warranty
- Impressive spinal alignment
- Outstanding motion isolation and edge support
- The medium firmness is ideal for most sleep positions
- Lacks the dynamic feel of more expensive mattresses
- Subpar heat dissipation
The Leesa Sapira Hybrid is the top pick in our best mattress for back pain guide and the top overall pick in this guide. We want to provide another, more affordable option, so we're highlighting the Nectar Classic Memory Foam Mattress, which is ideal for those who enjoy memory foam's conforming support.
With its medium firmness, the Nectar mattress is the best bet for side sleepers with back pain, but it may also work well for stomach and back sleepers. My back remained pain-free during my testing as I slept on my side.
A Tencel-poly blend cover helps keep the Nectar Classic mattress cool. Three CertiPUR-US-certified foam layers comprise the mattress: a gel memory foam top layer, a pressure point-relieving, adaptive response transition layer, and a supportive foam base layer.
The motion isolation and edge support are excellent, making it great for couples. I didn't feel like I was "stuck" in the mattress when lying on it, which can be an issue with memory foam. Instead, mobility wasn't an issue, a plus when back pain makes any extra effort painful. However, I found the mattress didn't dissipate heat well as previous versions of the mattress. I often felt like I was overheating.
At about $700 and frequently on promotion, the Nectar Classic Memory Foam Mattress is the best mattress for back pain — or any need — at this price point.
Read our full Nectar Classic Mattress review.
| Features | Rating | Results |
| Firmness | 6/10 | The medium-firm feel is great for all sleeping styles |
| Cooling | 3/10 | Didn't get too hot, but failed to dissipate heat well. |
| Edge Support | 8/10 | I felt supported while sitting and lying on the edge |
| Motion Isolation | 8/10 | It passed the bowling ball test |
Best organic
Environmentally-conscious folks can choose the Birch Mattress without guilt thanks to its all-natural materials. Use our exclusive promo code INSIDER27 to save 27% off and get two free pillows.
- Firmer than average
- Soft topper available for an extra cost
- Made of natural materials
- Greenguard Gold certified
- Outstanding edge support
- Not ideal for side sleepers without the pillow top
- Subpar motion isolation
If you want to make an eco-friendly choice in the bedroom, an organic mattress utilizes natural materials like cotton, wool, and latex and has third-party certifications to back its organic status. The Birch Natural Mattress by Helix is one of the best organic mattresses thanks to its sustainable materials, excellent pressure relief, and mid-range cost. The latex hybrid design typically provides a cooler and more responsive alternative to memory foam mattresses.
Underneath the organic cotton cover, the top layers of the mattress are made of wool fibers with rayon, followed by a wool layer for temperature regulation and comfort. The middle layers are made of latex and individually wrapped coils for support and limited motion transfer. The base consists of wool batting for durability and stability. The mattress is also Greenguard Gold-certified to be free of harsh chemicals.
It's a firm mattress, but you can add a plush organic mattress topper for an extra cost. The Birch has outstanding edge support, though the motion isolation was subpar. If you share a bed with someone, consider a larger size so their movement doesn't disturb you.
After testing, I gave the Birch to my 6-foot-5 teenager, who deals with joint pain. They said the bed helped soothe their aches. We both sleep hot, and the Birch did an adequate job of dissipating heat. However, on hotter nights, they said the mattress was uncomfortably hot.
Read our full Birch Mattress review and guide to the best organic mattresses.
Best cooling
In our testing, the Nest Bedding Finch Latex Mattress stayed cool and dissipated heat quickly, and its medium firmness will appeal to most sleepers.
- Materials are certified by many independent standards organizations
- Excellent edge support
- Medium feel will appeal to most sleepers
- Dissipated heat well and stayed cool in our tests
- Subpar motion isolation
One night, when sleeping with the Nest Bedding Finch Latex Mattress, I felt too cool and had to add an extra blanket. It had some of the lowest temperature readings in my tests. The mattress is available in medium and firm feels. I tested the medium, which felt accurate and should appeal to most sleeping styles.
The Finch's top layer has good bounce and airflow thanks to organic wool, cotton, and CertiPUR-US-certified foam. Next are two OEKO-TEX-certified latex layers. The firmness comes from the top latex layer, and the bottom layer adds durability, structure, and support to the bed. While the edge support will appeal to couples, the motion isolation leaves much to be desired.
Read our guide to the best cooling mattresses.
Best adjustable
If you and your partner just can't agree on mattress firmness, the Sleep Number i8 Smart Bed allows you to customize each side to your perfect firmness. The bed automatically adjusts based on your body's position.
- Built-in sleep tracker
- Adjustable firmness to cater to your specific sleeping style
- Automatically adjusts as you shift in the night
- Free in-home setup
- Good edge support
- Poor motion isolation
- Subpar heat dissipation
While pricey, the $3,000 Sleep Number i8 Smart Bed is worth every penny because it customizes to your comfort preferences. This adjustable air bed has 20 firmness options, so you'll find a feel that's right for you. Both sides adjust individually so you and your partner can have your custom firmness.
If you switch between multiple sleep positions, you just activate the automatic air adjustment feature in the Sleep Number app (iOS and Android), and the bed will quietly adjust the firmness when it senses your movements.
Another luxury feature is the sleep tracker, which assigns a sleep score based on how well you slept and gives recommendations for better sleep. During the testing period, Sleep Number made several improvements to its measuring software that aligned with the data from my smartwatch.
Setup was a breeze since the Sleep Number i8 has in-home delivery. The delivery people had it installed and paired with my phone in 45 minutes.
The main negatives with the bed are motion isolation and heat dissipation. My wife found the motion transfer was so extreme that it felt like she was on a water bed. While the mattress didn't get very hot, it didn't cool down quickly when I got up.
Read our full Sleep Number i8 Smart Bed review.
Best for heavy people
The Big Fig Mattress is constructed for heavier individuals with firm support and a high weight capacity.
- Firmer than average
- 1,100-pound weight capacity
- Good motion isolation
- Impressive heat dissipation
- Exceptional edge support
- May not be comfortable for side sleepers or petite individuals
The Big Fig Mattress is designed to support two sleepers with a combined weight of 1,100 pounds. Factor in the firmer-than-average support, and you have the ideal mattress for heavier individuals. The cover is made of a cooling material to prevent overheating, followed by three CertiPUR-US-certified foam layers that promote airflow, edge support, and durability. The individually wrapped coils located at the base of the mattress add more support and durability.
I usually sleep on my side, but with the firm feel of the Big Fig, I slept better on my stomach and back. Heavier side sleepers will likely be comfortable since they will sink into the mattress more, keeping their spine aligned.
The Big Fig's edge support is among the best I've experienced. I felt just as comfortable on the edge as in the middle. I rarely find good motion isolation and bounce on the same mattress. The Big Fig came close. It failed our bowling ball test, but in my subjective experience, the mattress's motion dampening was pretty good. The impressive bounce could facilitate intimate activities.
The Big Fig weighs more than most mattresses, so setting it up took more effort. The initial odor took a day to dissipate, so air out the bed before you sleep on it.
What to look for when choosing a mattress
When considering what is the best mattress to buy, there are many factors to look for. The key attributes to zero in on are mattress type, preferred sleep position, medical conditions you and your bed partner may have, and individual preferences. We outline specifics about how to choose a mattress below:
Mattress type
The most popular types of mattresses are memory foam (contours to your body), latex foam (eco-friendly), hybrid (durable), innerspring (supportive), pillow-top (soft), and adjustable air beds (versatile). Here are more pros and cons of each type.
- Memory foam: These are mattresses with multiple layers of high-density foam that support and contour to your body and offer pressure relief. Due to their construction, all-foam mattresses tend to trap heat, but advances in materials have made them much more breathable. Many are sold as a mattress-in-a-box because they can easily be condensed for shipping.
- Latex foam: People looking for an eco-friendly and more responsive alternative to traditional memory foam tend to prefer latex foam, though it is heavier and more expensive. Latex is often described as bouncy.
- Hybrid: These beds combine one of the above foams with individually wrapped coils. The coils help with motion transfer and edge support, making them an excellent option for couples. The pocket springs also help with airflow for cooler sleep.
- Innerspring: Also called coil mattresses, these are your traditional mattresses and are generally pretty affordable. The responsive coils offer good overall support, edge support, cooling, and durability, but you can expect some motion transfer.
- Pillow-top: Pillow-tops, or euro-tops, can be found on any mattress type but are usually associated with innerspring mattresses. They are typically filled with foam or fiber and are an excellent choice for those who like a soft, cushy feel.
- Adjustable or air beds: These beds use an air pump to adjust the firmness of your mattress to suit your needs. They are among the most expensive options but may be an ideal long-term solution since firmness needs can change with time. Couples with different firmness needs would also benefit from an adjustable air bed.
Sleep position
Though preferences differ, certain sleeping styles seem to prefer certain mattresses, according to Dr. Luis Javier Peña-Hernández, a lung and sleep health specialist at the Pulmonary, Critical Care & Sleep Disorders Institute of South Florida.
Side sleepers: "Vast research exists to support side sleepers benefit from medium-firm mattresses to support pressure point relief," said Peña-Hernández. An unsupportive bed will give side sleepers shoulder and lower back pain.
Back sleepers: Peña-Hernández recommends medium firmness for back sleepers. "Back sleepers should strive to maintain the natural S-curvature of the spine," he said. "A medium-firm mattress will help achieve this."
Stomach sleepers: Firmer mattresses tend to benefit stomach sleepers.
Body size and preferences
"Overweight individuals should consider a thicker mattress of at least 12 inches thick or more," said Peña-Hernández. "Thinner mattresses won't provide the support you need. Coil mattresses (including hybrids) provide a more durable construction." Heavier people also tend to prefer firmer beds.
Softer mattresses are better for petite individuals (under 130 pounds) since they don't sink into beds as much. Michael Breus, Ph.D., a board-certified psychologist in clinical sleep disorders known as "The Sleep Doctor," noted that older people benefit from softer mattresses. "As we age, our skin gets thinner, which means less cushion," he said.
"Hot sleepers should consider sheets and materials made of natural fibers for their breathability," said Peña-Hernández. "Bamboo, cotton, linen, and hemp are good options as well as cooling sheets, especially sheets designed to wick moisture." Check out our guide to the best bed sheets for recommendations.
Medical conditions
Peña-Hernández suggests consulting with your doctor and considering your medical history, like respiratory diseases, allergies, scoliosis, or sleep apnea, when purchasing a mattress. "For example, patients with COPD may benefit from adjustable beds because elevating the head of the bed can sometimes facilitate easier breathing," Peña-Hernández said.
How we test mattresses
I've reviewed mattresses for six years and developed a methodology for how Business Insider tests mattresses to determine the best. I've also toured a mattress factory, which gave me deep insights into how mattresses are made. All of our best mattresses have been tested by myself or members of the Business Insider Reviews team.
I sleep on each mattress for at least two weeks and conduct many objective tests on each model. The most important factors are comfort, edge support, and motion isolation.
Here are some of the test results for the main attributes we tested:
| Attribute | Leesa Sapira Hybrid | Saatva Classic (Luxury Firm) | The Allswell | Tempur-Cloud | WinkBed EcoCloud | Helix Dusk Luxe | Awara LuxuryHybrid | Nectar Classic | Birch by Helix | Nest Bedding Finch | Sleep Number i8 | Big Fig |
| Firmness (1 softest to 10 firmest) | 5 | 7 | 7 | 6 | 5 | 6 | 6 | 6 | 7 | 5.5 | 20 levels | 7 |
| Motion Isolation (1 awful to 10 best) | 7 | 5 | 7 | 7 | 6 | 7 | 5 | 8 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 6 |
| Edge Support (1 awful to 10 best) | 8 | 10 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 5 | 5 | 9 | 9 | 6 | 10 | |
| Heat Dissipation (1 traps heat to 10 stays cool) | 6 | 7 | 4 | 9 | 3 | 7 | 6 | 3 | 4 | 10 | 3 | 6 |
| Trial Period (nights) | 100 | 365 | 90 | 90 | 120 | 100 | 365 | 365 | 100 | 365 | 100 | 120 |
| Warranty (years) | 10 | Lifetime | 10 | 10 | Lifetime | 15 | Lifetime | Lifetime | 25 | Lifetime | 15 | 20 |
Here are the main attributes we look for and how we test them:
Comfort: This is a reasonably subjective characteristic based on the firmness of a mattress, how hot it sleeps, and how supportive it feels. I measure firmness by testing dozens of beds and developing a feel for soft, medium, and firm mattresses. I also consider heat dissipation, which I gauge using a laser thermometer to measure the temperature before I lay in bed for at least one hour, immediately after I get up, and two minutes after I get up.
Motion isolation: If you've ever spent the night with someone who moves around a lot, you know how vital motion isolation is. Without it, your sleeping partner's movements will jostle you awake throughout the night. To test motion isolation, I place a 12-ounce can in the middle of the mattress. Then I drop a 15-pound bowling ball four feet above the bed so it lands 12 inches from the can. If the can falls over time and time again, the motion isolation is not very good. If the can stays upright, the bed does an excellent job of dampening motion transfer. I also place a vibrometer across the bed from where the bowling ball lands and compare the intensity of the vibrations.
Edge support: To test edge support, I lay on the very edge of the bed and slowly roll off — literally. The bed has good edge support if I can roll a fair amount before falling. If I fall easily, then the edge support is not very good. I also sit on the side to put on my socks and shoes to assess how much the edge sinks.
Maneuverability: You probably won't need to move your mattress often, so this category doesn't weigh heavily in our assessment. Still, it's nice if you can easily rotate your mattress, a task that's important for your bed's longevity. Depending on your bed's position, you may need to move the mattress to put on fitted sheets. I move each mattress several times to see how heavy it feels and if it flops around, making it harder to move.
Trial and warranty: The only way to know if a bed is right for you is to sleep on it for several nights, so I looked for loopholes in the fine print of the return policy and let you know about them. I also report any questionable language in the warranty.
Setup: I time how long it takes me to unbox and set up each mattress and note any peculiarities to the process. My nose tracks any new bed odor and if it's still around when I go to bed 10+ hours later. Lastly, I examine whether an in-home setup is offered and how much it costs.
Mattress FAQs
How long should a mattress last?
A good way to gauge how long a mattress will last is to look at its warranty. All mattresses in our guide have warranties of at least 10 years. However, several factors can affect a mattress's lifespan, including its type, body weight, and how often it is slept on. See our "How long does a mattress last?" article for more details.
When is the best time to buy a mattress?
Mattress makers have sales throughout the year, but you can usually find the best deals during holiday weekends, like Presidents Day, Memorial Day, Independence Day, Labor Day, and Black Friday/Cyber Monday.
Manufacturers tend to mark down prices in the spring as they prepare to launch a new line in June. You'll usually find the most comprehensive selection in March with the smallest discounts. As you get into May, the discounts increase while the inventory becomes sparse.
What is the best size mattress to get?
The mattress sizes you should get depend on whether you are sleeping alone or with a partner, as well as whether your bedroom can comfortably fit the size of your bed. Twin, twin XL and full beds are generally better for smaller, taller, and larger individuals, respectively. Queen, king, and California king are better for smaller, larger, and taller couples, respectively. Here are the dimensions of each.
- Twin: 38 inches wide by 75 inches long
- Twin XL: 38 inches wide by 80 inches long
- Full: 54 inches wide by 75 inches long
- Queen: 60 inches wide by 80 inches long
- King: 76 inches wide by 80 inches long
- California king: 72 inches wide by 84 inches long
My wife and I are slightly taller and heavier than average. Queen mattresses are too small and uncomfortable for us, though as the most popular size, it's what we test. We've found king is ideal for our needs. However, since our "sleep divorce," we rarely share a bed.
Check out my mattress size chart for more detailed recommendations.
What is the best mattress for back pain?
The orthopedic surgeons we talked to said that medium-firm mattresses are best for people with back pain.
Amit Jain, MD, chief of minimally invasive spinal surgery at Johns Hopkins Hospital and an associate professor of orthopedic surgery and neurosurgery at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, said a medium-firm mattress is best for those with or without back pain, based on a 2015 study.
Tamara Huff, MD, a Georgia-based board-certified orthopedic surgeon and health disparities advocate, pointed out that it's hard to pinpoint what a "medium firm" is. She recommends avoiding the firmest mattress if you suffer from back pain. Instead, choose one that feels medium-firm to you.
I recommend looking for a mattress with zoned support. These offer more pressure relief around the hips, lower back, and shoulders and can better keep your spine aligned.
Take advantage of the home trial. After all, the only way to know if a mattress is right for your back is to sleep on it.
We rate the Leesa Sapira Hybrid as the best mattress for back pain, but for more options, read our comprehensive guide to the best mattresses for back pain.
What is the best mattress for hot sleepers?
We have a whole guide dedicated to the best mattresses for hot sleepers. Beds that keep you cool allow for airflow through the mattress. Hybrid mattresses with pocket coils that reach the mattress's edge breathe better. The same is true for beds with perforated foam. In my experience, beds with wool, cotton, or Celliant in their top layers or cover also tend to sleep cooler.
Emiel DenHartog, a professor in the textile engineering, chemistry, and science department at North Carolina State University, recommended mattresses with phase-change materials. As these materials change physical states, they absorb, store, and release heat.
Based on my objective tests using a laser thermometer, the Nest Bedding Finch is the best cooling mattress for hot sleepers.
What mattress should you buy for your weight?
The general rule of thumb is that heavier individuals should choose firmer mattresses, and petite folks are better served by softer ones. Heavy people will sink in more, and a firm, supportive mattress will help keep their spine aligned. Lighter sleepers need to be able to sink in for optimal spinal alignment.
According to Peña-Hernández, heavier individuals should pick an innerspring or hybrid mattress at least 12 inches thick for durability and support. We recommend the Big Fig Mattress, specifically designed for bigger people. The Titan Plus Luxe is another solid option.
Lighter individuals might like the super soft Puffy Royal.
How much should you spend on a mattress?
We outlined picks at various price points, but experts repeatedly tell us to consider a mattress an investment in your well-being. You spend about a third of your life on your bed, and you should expect to spend over $1,000 on a quality mattress.
While the upfront cost may seem high, a good mattress should last about 10 years. The chart below breaks down the average price for different types of mattresses. See our "How much does a mattress cost?" article for more in-depth information.
| Type of mattress | Budget | Mid-priced | Luxury |
| Foam mattress | $450 or less | From $1,000 | From $1,300 |
| Innerspring mattress | $700 or less | From $1,500 | From $2,000 |
| Hybrid mattress | $600 or less | From $1,500 | From $2,200 |
| Latex mattress | $1,200 or less | From $1,800 | From $2,500 |
If you can't afford a new mattress right now, a good short-term solution is a mattress topper. It can extend the life of your bed and give you a new feel. Check out our guide to the best mattress toppers.
What's the best way to clean a mattress?
Clean your mattress with baking soda and a vacuum every three to six months. Treat stains immediately with a disinfectant wipe. Tackle harder stains with a mixture of dishwashing liquid and hydrogen peroxide.
Some mattresses have removable covers. Check with the manufacturer before removing the cover and attempting to clean it, as it could void the warranty. Some brands may state that their covers are machine washable. If that is the case with your mattress, we recommend that option only as a last resort since it's incredibly difficult to take the cover off and put it back on.
For more tips, check out our article on how to clean a mattress.
Do I need a mattress protector?
When purchasing a new mattress, you should also buy a mattress protector to protect your investment. Our guide to the best mattress protectors offers our top recommendations.
You can purchase logo and accolade licensing to this story here.
Disclosure: Written and researched by the Insider Reviews team. We highlight products and services you might find interesting. If you buy them, we may get a small share of the revenue from the sale from our partners. We may receive products free of charge from manufacturers to test. This does not drive our decision as to whether or not a product is featured or recommended. We operate independently from our advertising team. We welcome your feedback. Email us at [email protected].
