($BE,Ev$J(B)$BO@J8>R2p(B

Charles R. Beitz, `Cosmopolitanism and Global Justice', in The Journal of Ethics (2005) 9:11-27.

17/Oct/2005 $BK?@/<#E/3X8&5f2q$K$F!";y6LAo(B

Abstract$B$NMWLs(B: $B%0%m!<%P%k%8%c%9%F%#%9$K$D$$$FE/3X

* Beitz$B$O%W%j%s%9%H%sBg3X$N@/<#3X2J$K$$$k!#(B $B$3$N%Z!<%Q!<$O(BAPA$B$NB@J?MNIt2q$,(B2004$BG/(B3$B7n$NG/

$B$O$8$a$K(B

$B@oAh$d?ML1$NM^05$P$+$j$7$F%@%a$J9q2H!"4D6-LdBj$K8+$i$l$k=89gE*9T0Y$NI,MW@-!"(B $B9q:]E*AH?%$d(BNGO$B$J$I$K$h$k%0%m!<%P%k$JLdBj$N2r7h$N2DG=@-$J$I$+$i!"(B $B%0%m!<%P%k%8%c%9%F%#%9$,LdBj$K$J$C$F$*$j!"E/3XE*CmL\$,=8$^$j$D$D$"$k$,!"(B $B@5@oO@0J30$O$^$@$^$@5DO@$,?<$^$C$F$$$J$$!#(B

$B@/<#M}O@$K$*$1$k%0%m!<%P%k%8%c%9%F%#%9(B

1960: Martin Write, `Why Is There No International Theory?' in International Relations 2 (1960)
$B9q2H$K$D$$$F$N@/<#M}O@$P$+$j$G!"9q:]E*@/<#M}O@$,$J$$$H;XE&!#(B $B$?$7$+$K(B1930$BG/Be0J9_!"@/<#E/3X

60$BG/BeEv;~$O!"9q2H4V$NG[J,E*@55A$O$[$H$s$ILdBj$K$J$i$:!"(B $B$I$&$d$C$?$iJ?OB$,C#@.$5$l$k$+$H$$$&OC$7$+$J$+$C$?!#(B 70$BG/Be$KF~$C$F!"9q:]4X78O@$G7P:QE*$J0MB84X78$d9q2H4V@/<#$J$I$b(B $Be$2$i$l$k$h$&$K$J$C$?!#(B $B8=

$B$D$$$G$K8@$&$H!"(B($B7P:QE*(B)$B%0%m!<%P%i%$%/$J$/$H$b(B19$B@$5*CfMU$+$i$9$G$K;O$^$C$F$$$k!#(B $B9q2H4V$NJ,6H$K$h$C$F?7$?$JNQM}E*LdBj$,@8$8$k$H$$$&OC$O!"(B $B$:$C$HA0$+$i$"$k!#(B $B$^$?!"$?$7$+$K@o8e$N1QJF@/<#E/3X$K$*$$$F$O5DO@$,$J$+$C$?$,!"(B $BEAE}E*$K$O%R%e!<%`!"%9%_%9!"%_%k!"%7%8%&%#%C%/$i$,(B $B;q8;$N=jM-8"!"309qKG0W!"O+F/

$B%3%9%b%]%j%?%K%:%`$N0UL#(B

$B%0%m!<%P%k$J@/<#M}O@$NH/E8$G!"%3%9%b%]%j%?%s$H$$$&9M$($,I|3h$7$?!#(B $B%3%9%b%]%j%?%K%:%`$O@$3&$r8+$k!V;kE@!W$@$1$G$O$J$/!"(B $B7$-$d$9$$(B($B0J2<$G8+$k$h$&$K!"(B $B%3%9%b%]%j%?%K%:%`$OFbMF$,$"$^$j$J$$(B)$B!#(B

$B$o$7$,:G=i$K%0%m!<%P%k%8%c%9%F%#%9$K$D$$$F9M$($?$H$-!"(B $B;0$D$N9M$(J}$KJ,$+$l$k$h$&$K;W$($?!#(B $B$=$l$O!"@/<#E*%j%"%j%:%`(B(political realism)$B!"(B $B=t9q2H$NF;FA(B(morality of states)$B!"(B $B%3%9%b%]%j%?%K%:%`$N;0$D$G$"$k!#(B $B@/<#E*%j%"%j%:%`$O2{5?O@$N0ll$H$7$F$O!"(B $B9q2Hl$G$"$k$o$1$G$O$J$$!#(B

$B!V=t9q2H$NF;FA!W$H$$$&$N$G$o$7$,9M$($F$$$?$N$O!"(B $B%/%j%9%A%c%s!&%t%)%k%U$d(BE. de Vattel$B$H$$$C$?(B18C$B$N9q:]K!O@

  1. $B8"Mx$H5AL3$N
  2. $B9q2H$O<+A3>uBV$K$*$1$k=t8D?M$KE,MQ$5$l$k$N$H;w$?5,HOBN7O$K=>$&$3$H$,(B $B5AL3$E$1$i$l$k!#(B
  3. $BJ?Ey$H$$$&2ACM$O!"9q2H$,8_$$$rEy$7$$F;FAE*?M3J$H$7$F07$&$Y$7$H$$$&(B $B86B'$N$&$A$KI=L@$5$l$k!#(B

$B$7$+$7!"$3$N9M$(J}(B($B9q2HC10L$G9q:]@/<#$r9M$($kN)>l(B)$B$r@5Ev2=$7$h$&$H$9$k$H!"(B $B$$$m$$$m$JN)>l$KJ,$+$l$k!#(B $B$"$k8+2r$G$O!"9q:]Ca=x$N9MN8$3$=$,:,K\E*$@$H$5$l$k!#(B $BJL$N8+2r$G$O!"<+N'E*$J@/<#E*6&F1BN$H$7$F$N9q2H$N@-3J$3$=$,4pK\$@$H$5$l$k!#(B $B$5$i$KJL$N8+2r$G$O!"9q2H$O!"

$B%3%9%b%]%j%?%K%:%`$KOC$r0\$9!#(B $B!V%3%9%b%]%j%?%s!W$O!"(B $B@$3&$N@/<#Ca=x$N?^<0$K$D$$$F$b8@$o$l$k$7!"(B $B8D?M$NJ82=E*%"%$%G%s%F%#%F%#$N9M$(J}$K$D$$$F$b8@$o$l$k!#(B $B$3$3$G$O;0$D$a$N!"!VF;FAE*%3%9%b%]%j%?%K%:%`!W$K$D$$$FO@$8$k!#(B $B$=$N3K?4$O!"%H%^%9!&%]%C%2$r0zMQ$9$k$H!"(B $B!V$"$i$f$k?M4V$O!"F;FAE*G[N8$N5f6KE*C10L$H$7$F$N%0%m!<%P%k$J=EMW@-$r;}$D(B (every human being has a global stature as the ultimate unit of moral concern.)$B!W!#(B $B%]%C%2$N0zMQ$KB*$($i$l$F$$$k$h$&$K!"$3$N8+2r$O(B $B8D?M(B(prospects)$B$O0U;W7hDj$N$5$$$K(B $BEy$7$/9MN8$KF~$l$k$Y$-$@$H$$$&$N$+!"(B (2)$B@5Ev2=$NL>08?M(B(addressee of justification)$B$H$7$F(B $BEy$7$$CO0L$r;}$D$b$N$H$7$F3F?M$O07$o$l$k$Y$-$J$N$+!#(B $B$I$A$i$NE@$K$D$$$F$b(B(2)$B$,$o$7$O@5$7$$$H;W$&$,!"(B $B$3$3$G$OO@$8$i$l$J$$!#(B

$BF;FAE*%3%9%b%]%j%?%K%:%`$O!"(B $B$=$l$,2?$r5q@d$9$k$+$r9M$($?$H$-$O$o$+$j$d$9$$(B ($B$,!"]$rFCDj$N=8CD$K8BDj$9$k(B $B$$$+$J$k8+2r$K$bH?BP$9$k!#$^$?!"A*Br$N@5Ev2=$r!"(B $B9q2H$dl$O(B $BG'$a$J$$(B)$B!#(B $B$b$7=t9q2H$NF;FA$,!"9q6-$K$h$C$F@5Ev2=$NHO0O$,@)8B$5$l$k$H$$$&$N$G$"$l$P!"(B $B%3%9%b%]%j%?%K%:%`$H$OL@$i$+$KAjMF$l$J$$!#(B

$BF;FAE*%3%9%b%]%j%?%K%:%`$,2?$rMW5a$9$k$+$K$D$$$F$OHs>o$K[#Kf$G$"$k!#(B $B$?$H$($P!"%0%m!<%P%k$J@/<#E*@55A$NFbMF$K$D$$$F$O$+$i$C$]$G$"$k!#(B $B

$B0l$D$K$O!"ZE*$J8&5f$,B-$j$J$$$+$i!"(B $BK|?M$rF;FAE*G[N8$NHO0O$K4^$a$k$H$$$&Cj>]E*MW5a$+$i7kO@$,F3$-=P$;$J$$(B $B$H$$$&$3$H$,$"$k!#(B $B$7$+$7!"$h$j4pK\E*$J%]%$%s%H$O!"(B $B%3%9%b%]%j%?%K%:%`$O40A4$JF;FAE*9=A[(B(moral conception)$B$G$O$J$$$H$$$&$3$H$@!#(B $B$=$N>Z5r$K!"8yMxJ}$H$b%3%9%b%]%j%?%sM}O@$H9M$($i$l$F$$$k!#(B $B$=$l$@$1$G$J$/!"8D?M$NA1$K$D$$$F$I$&$$$&M}2r$r$9$Y$-$+!"(B $B0[$J$k8D?M$NE8K>(B(prospects)$B$r$I$&=87W$9$Y$-$+!"(B $B$^$?=87WE*$JH=CG$OHs5"7kl$H$$$&$N$O$J$$!#(B

$BM}O@E*$KIT3NDj$J$N$G!"$$$m$$$m$J5,HOE*N)>l$,%3%9%b%]%j%?%s$H8F$P$l$&$k!#(B $B$H$/$K!"$h$j?JJbE*$J%?%$%W$N!V=t9q2H$NF;FA!W$N

$B%3%9%b%]%j%?%K%:%`$rFsLL$9$k$o$1$@$,!"(B $B$=$NFbMF$K$D$$$F$b$C$H$h$/M}2r$7$J$$$H$$$1$J$$$7!"(B $B$=$l$i$NM}M3$rE}9g$9$k%W%m%;%9$K$D$$$F$bM}2r$7$J$$$H$$$1$J$$!#(B $B$*$=$i$/$=$N7k2L$H$7$F@8$8$k$N$O!V2:7r!W$"$k$$$O!V6KC

($B!V9T0Y$N0l8+<+L@$JM}M3!W$H$O!"CO0h$KBP$9$k0&Ce!"$5$^$6$^$J%l%Y%k$N(B $BWFM$9$kD>4Q(B)

$B%3%9%b%]%j%?%K%:%`$H@$3&$NIO:$(B

$B$b$&$A$g$C$H6qBNE*$K9M$($F$_$h$&!#(B $B$5$^$6$^$J!V9T0Y$NM}M3!W$,!"(B $B%0%m!<%P%k!&%8%c%9%F%#%9$NFs$D$NB&LL(B--$B7P:QE*$J$b$N$H!"@/<#E*$J$b$N(B--$B$K(B $B$D$$$F9M$($k$5$$$K$I$&$$$&1F6A$rM?$($k$N$+9M$($F$_$h$&!#(B

$B$^$:!"%0%m!<%P%k$JIO:$$r5_:Q$9$k@UG$$K$D$$$F9M$($F$_$h$&!#(B 1970$BG/Be$+$i!"E/3XE*$K$OFs$D$NBg$-$JLdBj$,$"$C$?!#(B

  1. $B0l$D$O%T!<%?!
  2. $B$b$&0l$D$O!"A19T$NM}M30J30$K!"(B $B:#F|$N@$3&$NIO:$5_:Q$N$?$a$K2?$+$r$9$kM}M3$,$"$k$N$+!"(B $B$^$?$"$k$H$7$?$i!"$I$&$$$&$3$H$r$7$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$$+!"$H$$$&LdBj!#(B

$B0l$DL\$NLdBj$OFq$7$/$F$^$@2r7h$7$F$$$J$$!#(B $BFs$DL\$K4X$7$F$O?JJb$,$"$C$?!#(B $B%m!<%k%:$N!X=t9qL1$NK!!Y$N5DO@$r8+$F$_$h$&!#(B $BH`$NM}O@$K$OFf$,$"$k!#(B $B%m!<%k%:$K$h$l$P!"87L)$K$O!"9q:]E*$JJ,G[E*@55A$J$s$F$J$$!#(B $BH`$O8D!9$N9q2H$r%0%m!<%P%k$J5,HOCa=x$K$*$1$k4pK\E*$J9T0Y$B$$$+$J$k(B$B%0%m!<%P%k$JJ,G[E*MW5a$r=

[Rawls: The question to ask about it (a global egalitarian principle) is whether the principle has a target and cutoff point. The duty of assistance (=Rawls' position) has both: it seeks to raise the world's poor until they are either free and equal citizens of a reasonably liberal society or members of a decent hierarchical society. That is its target. It also has by design a cutoff point, since for each burdened society the principle ceases to apply once the target is reached. The Law of Peoples, ch. 16]

$B$,!"%m!<%k%:$Ol$r

  1. $BK-$+$J9q$O!"$=$&$G$J$$9q$r1g=u$9$k5AL3$,$"$k!#(B $B$^$?!">u67$K$h$C$F$O!"9q:]4V$NIY$N0\E>$,I,MW$G$"$k!#(B
  2. $B?M!9$O@8B88"$H$$$&4pK\E*?M8"$r;}$A!"$=$l$rD$r
  3. $B=t9qL1$NK!$OIT40A4$G$"$j!"8x@5$JKG0W$N4p=`$N$h$&$J!"(B $B9q:]E*6(NO$r5,@)$9$k86B'$K$h$C$FJdB-$5$l$kI,MW$,$"$k!#(B

$B$3$l$i$NN)>l$O!"(B $BK-$+$J9q!9$N;TL1$,IO$7$$

($B$3$N!"!V@55A!W$H!VA19T(B($B?MF;(B)$B!W$H$$$&6hJL$O6/NO$K:,$C$3$H$7$F$"$k$s$@$J(B)

$B$o$7$K$O$I$&9M$($?$i$$$$$N$+$h$/$o$+$i$s$N$@$,!"(B $B%m!<%k%:$N8@MU$G$O!"!V=t9qL1$N

$B>e$N$h$&$JN)>l$O!"!V@5Ev2=$NHO0O$O%0%m!<%P%k$J$b$N$G$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!W(B $B$H$$$&%3%9%b%]%j%?%sE*MW5a$r$B5,HOE*$J9MN8(B$B$O!"(B $B9qFb$N@/<#Ca=x$O!"9q2H4V$H0c$C$F6/@)$H$$$&MWAG$,$"$j!"(B $B$3$l$,F;FAE*$K=EMW$J0c$$$H$J$k$H$$$&9M$($G$"$k!#(B $B%^%$%1%k!&%V%l%$%/(B(Michael Blake)$B$H$+(BRonald Dworkin$B$,8@$C$F$$$k$3$H$@$,!"(B $B9q2H$O6/@)NO$rM?$($i$l$F$$$k$N$G!"r7o$,87$7$$!#(B $B$=$3$G!"r7o$,IU$/2DG=@-$,$"$k!#(B

$BNr;KE*$J9MN8(B$B$H$O!"(B $BK}@-E*$JIO:$>uBV$K4X$9$k0x2LE*$J@UG$$K$D$$$F(B $B$I$&9M$($k$+$G$"$k!#0lJ}$G$O!"%m!<%k%:$N$h$&$K!"(B $BIO:$$N860x$NBgItJ,$O9q2HFb$K$"$j!"(B $B$=$N2~A1$K$D$$$F$OB>9q$K$ODL>o2?$b$G$-$J$$$H$9$k?M!9$,$$$k!#(B $BB>J}$G$O!"%]%C%2$N$h$&$K!"(B $B%0%m!<%P%k$JCa=x$,8=B8$9$k%0%m!<%P%k$JIO:$$r1JB3$5$;!"(B $B$^$?0-2=$5$;$+$M$J$$$N$G!"K-$+$J9q$O%0%m!<%P%k$JCa=x$r2~3W$7!"(B $B$3$l$^$G$NB;32$KBP$7$FJd=~$9$kI,MW$,$"$k$H8@$&?M!9$b$$$k!#(B

$BNr;KE*LdBj$H8@$C$?$,!"(B $B%0%m!<%P%k$NCa=x$K$h$C$FIO:$$,1JB3$7$F$$$k$H8@$C$?$5$$$K!"(B $B!V4m32!W$N35G0$,@5$7$/E,MQ$5$l$k$N$+$H$+!"(B $B9qFb$H9q2H4V$N%l%Y%k$G$I$N$h$&$KF;FAE*@UG$$rJ,$1$k$N$+$H$+!"(B $BE/3XE*$JLdBj$,$J$$$o$1$G$O$J$$!#(B $B$7$+$7!"$3$3$G=EMW$J$N$O!"(B $BF;FAE*%3%9%b%]%j%?%K%:%`$r7k$7$J$$$3$H$G$"$k!#(B $B$`$7$m!"$=$N2r7h$N$?$a$K$O!"(B $B9q:]7P:Q$K;22C$9$k$3$H$H!"9qFb$NIO:$$H=jF@$NITJ?Ey$N4X78$r$I$&M}2r$9$k$+(B $B$,=EMW$G$"$j!"$=$3$i$X$s$N$3$H$OE/3X

$B$^$?!"%0%m!<%P%k$JJ,G[E*@55A$N%3%9%b%]%j%?%sM}O@$N>\:Y$O!"(B $BNr;KE*9M;!$K4p$E$/I,MW$,$"$k!#(B $B0lNc$r5s$2$h$&!#(B $B:G6a$^$G!"(B $B%0%m!<%P%k$JJ,G[E*@55A$N5DO@$O!"(B $B:G$b=EMW$J$3$H$O!"(B $BIO$7$$9q$K$h$j$?$/$5$s$N6b$rCm$.$3$`$3$H$@$H8@$o$s$P$+$j$ND4;R$GOC$7$F$-$?!#(B $B$?$H$($P!"(BODA$B$NM=;;$rA}$d$9$H$+(B($B%Y%$%D(B)$B!"%R%[email protected]$rIO$7$$9q$N@/I\$K(B $BM?$($k$H$+(B($B%V%i%$%"%s!&%P%j!<(B)$B!#(B $B$7$+$7!"$3$l$OL@$i$+$J4V0c$$$G$"$C$?!#(B $B$=$l$O9qFb$N%"%J%m%8!<$G9M$($F$_$l$P$o$+$k$O$:$G$"$C$?!#(B $B%m!<%k%:<+?H$,!"@\$N=jF@$N0\E>$O!"E,@Z$JZ$9$k$?$a$KMQ$$$i$l$k(B $B$b$N$G$"$k$,!"$=$l$O;T>l$,<:GT$7$?>u67$N$?$a$KMQ0U$5$l$?$b$N!#(B $BF1$8$h$&$K!"(B $B%0%m!<%P%k$JJ,G[E*@55A$NM}O@$b!"(BODA$B$H$+$h$j$b!"(B $B$h$jBg$-$J%$%s%Q%/%H$r;}$D9q:]

$B%0%m!<%P%k$J@/<#E*@55A(B

$B@/<#E*@55A$NOC$O!"J,G[E*@55A$NOC$h$j$b8EE5E*$JLdBj!#(B $B$J$N$K%0%m!<%P%k!&%8%c%9%F%#%9$NJ8L.$G$OJ,G[E*@55A$N5DO@$NJ}$,(B $B@h$K5DO@$5$l$F$$$k$H$$$&$N$O$*$b$7$m$$!#(B

$B$3$l$O!"%0%m!<%P%k$J@/<#E*@55A$K$*$$$F$O!"2?$rLdBj$H$9$Y$-$+$,(B $B$o$+$j$K$/$$$+$i$@$m$&!#9qFb$@$H!"6/@)NO$rH<$&@/I\$,$"$k$N$G!"(B $B0U;W7hDj$N8"NO$r$I$N$h$&$KG[J,$9$Y$-$+$H$$$&LdBj$H!"(B $B9q2H8"NO$K$I$N$h$&$K@)Ls$r2]$9$Y$-$+$H$$$&LdBj$,!"(B $B@/<#E*@55A$N86B'$NBP>]$H$J$k!#(B

$B%0%m!<%P%k$J%l%Y%k$G$O!"$=$l$HN`Hf$9$Y$-$b$N$,$J$$!#(B $B$^$7$$$H$+$$$&(B $B0U8+$N0lCW$b$J$$!#MW$9$k$K!"%0%m!<%P%k$J@/<#E*@55A$N5DO@$NBP>]$K$J$k(B $B$b$N$,$J$$$7!"$"$C$?$H$7$F$b$I$&$d$C$FOC$r?J$a$?$i$$$$$+$o$+$i$J$$!#(B

$B$H$$$C$F$b!"$9$G$K%0%m!<%P%k$"$k$$$OCO0hE*$J8xE*0U;W7hDj$N%W%m%;%9(B $B$H$$$&$N$O7k9=H/E8$7$F$*$j!"@/I\9b41$K$h$k%H%i%s%9%J%7%g%J%k$J%M%C%H%o!<%/(B ($B$C$F2?(B?)$B$,%0%m!<%P%k!&%,%P%J%s%9$NLr3d$r2L$?$7$F$b$$$k!#(B $B$?$H$($P(BTRIPS($BCNE*=jM-8"$K$D$$$F$N6(Dj(B)$B$H$+G@;:J*$K4X$9$k6(Dj$H$+!#(B $B$,!"(B $B$3$&$7$?OHAH$K$O!"$=$l$K$h$C$F1F6A$r

$B$3$3$G%3%9%b%]%j%?%sE*$JLd$$$,=EMW$K$J$k!#(B $B9q:]E*!&%H%i%s%9%J%7%g%J%k$J@)EY$O!"(B $B9q2H$N@)EY$KE,MQ$5$l$k$b$N$HN`HfE*$J@/<#E*@)EY$N4p=`$rK~$?$9$Y$-$+!#(B $B$?$H$($P!"%0%m!<%P%k$J@)EY$OL1$^$7$$M}M3$r8+=P$7!"(B $B$=$l$i$NM}M3$,!"9q2H$rD6$($?%,%P%J%s%9$KOC$,JQ$o$C$F$bE,MQ$G$-$k$+(B $B$r9M$($k$3$H!#(B $B@)EYE*$JB&LL$O!"(B $B%0%m!<%P%k$J%l%Y%k$G8=/$J$/$H$b0J2<$N;0$D$NE@$,$"$k!#(B

  1. $B$=$l$,;TL1$NJ?Ey$J8xE*CO0L$rG'$a$k$b$N$G$"$k$3$H!#(B
  2. $B$=$l$,;TL1$N=EMW$JMx1W$,9q2H$K$h$k?/32$rl9g$K!"(B $B8D?M$,$=$l$rJ]8n$9$k
  3. $B$=$l$,@/<#E*A*Br$K4X$9$k;TL1$K$h$kM-8z$J=ON8$KLrN)$D@/<#E*4D6-$r(B $B:n$j=P$9$b$N$G$"$k$3$H!#(B

$B$3$l$i$NE@$,%0%m!<%P%k$J%l%Y%k$G$bEv$F$O$^$k$+$I$&$+$OD>$A$KL@$i$+$G$J$$$7!"(B $B$^$?!"$?$H$(Ev$F$O$^$k$K$7$F$b!"@)EY@_7W$KBP$9$k4^0U$,F1$8$+$I$&$+$o$+$i$s!#(B $BEv$F$O$^$i$J$1$l$P!"%0%m!<%P%k$J@/<#E*@55A$NE,@Z$J%b%G%k$O!"(B $B$o$7$i$,CN$kL1

$B$$$/$D$+$NNc30$r=|$$$F(B(note 30)$B!"(B $BE/3X

$B7kO@(B

$B:G=i$K$3$NH/I=$rMj$^$l$?$H$-!"(B $B!V%0%m!<%P%k!&%8%c%9%F%#%9$N5DO@$N8=>u!W$K$D$$$FOC$7$F$/$l$H8@$o$l$?$,!"(B $B%0%m!<%P%k!&%8%c%9%F%#%9$K$O9-$$0UL#$H69$$0UL#$,$"$k$N$G:$$C$?!#(B $B9-$$0UL#$G$O!"(B $B9q2H$r1[$($?@/<#E*3hF0$K$*$$$F@8$8$k5,HOE*=tLdBj$KBP$9$kJq3gE*$J%i%Y%k(B $B$H$7$F;H$($k!#(B $B69$$0UL#$G$O!"(B $B@55A(B$B$N%0%m!<%P%k$JMW5a$H$7$F!"(B $B$D$^$j

$B$3$l$i$O@5@oO@$r=|$1$PE/3XE*$K$b5DO@$NEAE}$,$J$/$F5DO@$9$k$N$,$?$$$X$s!#(B $B$7$+$7!"E/3X

KODAMA Satoshi
Last modified: Mon Oct 17 23:36:10 JST 2005