$B@iMUBg;qNA=8MQO@J8(B / $B;29MJ88%0lMw(B

$B@iMUBg;qNA=8MQO@J8(B

$BM-8z$J$9$Y$j:dO@K!$H$O2?$+(B?

$B;y6L(B $BAo(B

$B%-!<%o!<%I(B

  1. $B$9$Y$j:dO@K!(B the slippery slope argument
  2. $BM-32$JA0Nc$X$NAJ$((B the appeal to a pernicious precedent
  3. $BBO@Q$N8mI5(B ($BO":?<0(B) the sophism of the heap (sorites)

$B$9$Y$j:dO@K!(B$B$H$O!"$"$k9T0Y$,K!E*$^$?$OF;FAE*$K5v$5(B $B$l$J$$$3$H$r<($9$?$a$K;H$o$l$kO@K!$N0l$D$G$"$j!"0lHL$K<!$N7A<0$r;}$D!#(B $B!V$b$7$"$J$?$,$O$8$a$N0lJb(BA$B$r$U$_$@$9$J$i$P!"$"$J$?$+!"=EMW$JE@$K$*$$(B $B$F$"$J$?$H;w$F$$$kJL$N9T0Yo$K9b$$2DG=@-$G$J$5$l$k$@(B $B$m$&!#(BB$B$OF;FAE*$K5vMF$G$-$J$$!#$7$?$,$C$F!"$"$J$?$OBh0lJb(BA$B$r$U$_$@$7$F(B $B$O$J$i$J$$!#!W(B(1) $B$3$NO@K!$NBeI=E*$JNc$O!"0B3Z;`(B $B$K4X$9$k$b$N$G$"$k!#!V$*$=$i$/6KC<$JNc$K$*$$$F$O<+H/E*$J0B3Z;`$,F;FAE*(B $B$K@5Ev2=$5$l$k>l9g$b$"$k$+$b$7$l$J$$!#$7$+$7!"<+H/E*0B3Z;`$OHs?M4VE*$J(B $Bc32$r;}$C$?(B $B?7@8;y$,;&$5$l$k$3$H$K$J$j!"$=$N<!$K$O@:?@E*>c32$r;}$C$??M!9$,;&$5$l$k(B $B$3$H$K$J$j!"$D$$$K$OLr$KN)$?$J$$O7?M$,$=$N0U;V$KH?$7$F;&$5$l$k$3$H$K$J(B $B$k!#!W(B(2)

$B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O!"$H$-$K$=$NL>$rJQ$($F!"!V%i%/%@$NI!$r%F%s%H$KF~$l$k(B (letting the camel's nose in the tent)$B!W!"!V$/$5$S$N@hC<(B(the thin end [edge] of the wedge)$B!W!"!V%I%_%NM}O@(B(the domino theory)$B!W$J$I$NL>A0$G(B $BI=8=$5$l!"=P@8A0?GCG$d0dEA;R<#NE$H$$$C$?@8L?NQM}3X$G$"$D$+$o$l$kOCBj$K(B $B8B$i$:!"I=8=$N<+M3$+$i%^%j%U%!%J$N5,@)$^$G!"1~MQNQM}3X$GO@$8$i$l$k$[$H(B $B$s$I$NOCBj$K$*$$$F=EMW$JO@E@$N0l$D$rDs6!$7$F$$$k(B(3)$B!#$b$C$H$b!"$3$N8l$,$D$M$KF10l$N0UL#$GMQ$$$i$l$F(B $B$$$k$H$O8@$($:!"$7$P$7$P$=$N0UL#FbMF$O$"$$$^$$$G$"$k!#$?$H$($P!"!V2c$r(B $B;&$9$?$a$K$3$N;&Cn:^$r;H$&$Y$-$G$O$J$$!#B>$NM-MQ$J:+Cn$b;&$7$F$7$^$&$3(B $B$H$K$J$k$+$i!W$H$$$&$h$&$J5DO@$,$9$Y$j:dO@K!$H$7$F8l$i$l$k$3$H$,$"$k$,!"(B $B$3$N5DO@$O$"$k9T0Y$N(B$BJ@32$J$$$7I{:nMQ(B$B$r;XE&$9$k$b$N$G(B $B$"$j!"$"$k9T0Y$,O":?E*$K$=$l$H;w$?(B$BJL$N9T0Y(B$B$r@8$_$@$9(B $B$HO@$8$k$9$Y$j:dO@K!$H$O0[$J$k(B(4)$B!#$7$?$,$C$F!"B>(B $B$NO@K!$H$N:.F1$rHr$1$k$?$a$K!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$rDj<02=$9$kI,MW$,$"$k!#(B

$B$^$?!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$,O@M}3X$N652J=q$K$*$$$F@bL@$5$l$k$3$H$O$a$C$?$K(B $B$J$$$,!"O@M}3X$K$*$$$F$O$3$NO@K!$O8mI5$H$7$F\:Y$KO@$8$F$$$k$h$&$K!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O$=$N7A<0$K$h$C(B $B$F$O!"$?$H$($"$^$jM-8z$J5DO@$G$O$J$$(B($B(5)$B!#$9$k$H!"l9g$H$=$&$G$J$$>l9g$KJ,$1!"$=$7$F8mI5(B $B$G$J$$$9$Y$j:dO@K!$,$I$N$F$$$IM-8z$J5DO@$H$7$F5!G=$7$&$k$N$+$r9M;!$9$k(B $BI,MW$,$"$k$h$&$K;W$o$l$k!#(B

$B$=$3$GK\9F$G$O!"(B1998$BG/$K=PHG$5$l$?(BA Companion to Bioethics$B$K<}O?$5$l$F$$$k(BGovert den Hartogh$B$N(B`The slippery slope argument'(6)$B$H$$$&O@J8$N>R2p$rDL$8$F!"1~MQ(B $BNQM}3X$K$*$$$F$7$P$7$PEP>l$9$k$9$Y$j:dO@K!$NDj<02=$HJ,N`!"$*$h$S$=$NM-(B $B8z@-$r8!F$$9$k!#(B

Hartogh$B$N5DO@(B

$B$O$8$a$K(BHartogh$B$N$3$NO@J8$N$*$*$^$+$J8+$B>JN,(B)$B!"BhFs@a$G$O!"(B $B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$NE57?E*7A<0$,Ds<($5$l$k!#Bh;0@a$G$O!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$NE57?E*(B $B7A<0$H$O$$$/$i$+0[$J$k!VM-32$JA0Nc$X$NAJ$(!W$H$$$&O@K!$,>R2p$5$l!"$3$N(B $BO@K!$OBEEv$G$"$k$HO@$8$i$l$k!#$7$+$7$J$,$i!"B3$/Bh;M@a$HBh8^@a$G$O!"$9(B $B$Y$j:dO@K!$OBEEv$G$O$J$/!"9gM}@-$KAJ$($kO@>Z$H$7$F$O<:GT$7$F$*$j!"$^$?(B $B$?$H$(?M4V$NIT9gM}$JB&LL$KAJ$($k$K$7$F$b!"$3$NO@K!$,$$$/$i$+$G$bM-8z$K(B $BE,MQ$5$l$&$k$N$OF;FAE*??M}$N5DO@$G$O$J$/47=,$d@)EY$K4X$9$k5DO@$N$_$G$"(B $B$k$H=R$Y$i$l$k!#BhO;@a$G$O!"%*%i%s%@$N0B3Z;`@/:v$rNc$K$H$j!"$9$Y$j:dO@(B $BK!$rM-8z$J5DO@$K$9$k$N$OFq$7$$$3$H$,;XE&$5$l!":G8e$NBh<7@a$G$O!"u$N2~3W$X$NH?BP$r7`E*$KI=8=$9$k$?$a$K(B $BMQ$$$i$l$F$$$k$K$9$.$J$$$N$G!"$3$N$h$&$J>l9g!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$K@5LL$+$iH?(B $BO@$9$k$h$j$O$`$7$m8=>u$KBP$9$kL5HcH=$J9NDj$rLdBj$K$9$Y$-$G$"$k$HO@$8$i(B $B$l$k!#(B

$B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$NE57?E*7A<0(B ($BBhFs@a(B)

$BBh0l@a$G$9$Y$j:dO@K!$NE57?$J;vNc$r>R2p$7$?$"$H!"(BHartogh$B$O<!$K!"$9$Y(B $B$j:dO@K!$NE57?E*7A<0(B(paradigmatic form)$B$rDs<($9$k!#H`$K$h$l$P!"$9$Y$j(B $B:dO@K!$,Dj<02=$5$l$M$P$J$i$J$$M}M3$N0l$D$O!"!V$9$Y$j:dO@K!!W$H$$$&8@MU(B $B$NE,MQHO0O$,$"$$$^$$$G!"$H$-$K!VM-32$JA0Nc$X$NAJ$(!W(B($BBh;0@a;2>H(B)$B$dDs0F(B $B$5$l$?9T0Y$N0-$$7k2L$r;XE&$9$k5DO@(B(7)$B$r;X$9$N$K$b(B $BMQ$$$i$l$k$+$i$G$"$k!#(B $B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$NE57?E*7A<0$O0J2<$NFCD'$r;}$D$H$5(B $B$l$k!#(B

  1. $B$3$NO@K!$,;HMQ$5$l$k5DO@$K$*$$$F$O!"(B $B!V$"$k$B$3$N5DO@$K$*$$$F$O!"?M!9$,8=>u$N0LCV(B(status quo position)$B$G$O!"(B $B9T0Y(BA$B$r6X$8$k9T0Y5,HO$KF;FAE*$K=>$C$F$$$k$+!"(B $B$"$k$$$OK!E*8"NO$K$h$C$F=>$o$5$l$F$$$k$3$H$,A0Ds$5$l$F$$$k!#(B
  2. $B$3$N8=>u$N0LCV$+$i!"(B $B9T0Y(BA$B$,:#8e$O5vMF$"$k$$$O5v2D$5$l$&$k$H$_$J$5$l$k$h$&$J?7$7$$0LCV(B ($B:d$N0lHV>e(B)$B$X$H0\F0$9$k$3$H$,Ds0F$5$l$k!#(B
    ($BDs0F$,$3$l$^$G5vMF$5$l$F$-$?9T0Y$r6X$8$k$b$N$G$"$C$F$O$J$i$J$$(B $BO@M}E*M}M3$O$J$$$,!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$,$3$N7A$r$B$3$NDs0F$KH?BP$9$ke$N0LCV$,@\$KDj$7$?$j!"(B $B9T0Y(BA$B$O0-$$7k2L$r$b$?$i$9$N$G9T$J$o$l$k$Y$-$G$J$$$H$O ($B$b$C$H$b!"$B$=$N$+$o$j!"H?BP ($B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$NE57?E*7A<0$K$*$$$F$O!"(B $B0-$$7k2L$r;}$D$N$O9T0Y(BA$B$=$l<+BN$G$O$J$/!"(B $B9T0Y(BA$B$r5vMF$G$-$k$b$N$H$_$J$9(B$B7hDj(B$B$G$"$k$3$H$KCm0U(B)
  3. $B>e$G8@5Z$7$?0x2LE*:nMQ$OO":?H?1~$r$9$k$H$$$&FC@-$r;}$D!#(B $B$9$J$o$A!"9T0Y(BA$B$r5vMF$9$k$J$i$P$*$=$i$/9T0Y(BB$B$r$b5vMF$9$k$3$H$K$J$j!"(B $B$=$&$9$k$H<!$K$O9T0Y(BC$B$r5vMF$9$k$3$H$K$J$j!"(B $B:G8e$K$O9T0Y(BN$B$r5vMF$9$k$3$H$K$J$k!#(B

$B$3$NO":?$r@8$_=P$9$N$O2?$J$N$+$H$$$&Ld$$$KBP$7$F!"(BHartogh$B$O(B$B9gM}@-(B$B$r0l$D$NMW0x$H$7$F5s$2$F$$$k!#$3$l$ODL>o!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$N(B$BO@M}E*7A<0(B(logical form)$B$H8F$P$l$k$b$N$G(B(8)$B!"$=$l$K$h$k$H!"$o$l$o$l$,9T0Y(BA$B$r5v$9$N$J$i$P!"$o$l$o$l$O9gM}E*$K$O9T0Y(BB$B!"9T0Y(BC$B!"$=$7$F7k6I$O9T0Y(BN$B$r$b5v$5$6$k$r$($J$$$3$H$K$J$k!"$HO@$8$i$l$k!#(B

$B$@$,o$K>-Mh$N(B$BM=A[(B (prediction)$B$KAH$_9~$^$l$k!"$H(BHartogh$B$O=R$Y$k!#$9$J$o$A!"9T0Y(B A$B$NH?BPe$KIQHK$K$J$5$l$k$h$&$K$J$k$@$m$&!#$=$l$f(B $B$(!"9T0Y(BA$B$O5v$5$l$k$Y$-$G$J$$!W$HO@$8$k!#$^$?!"H?BP$B9T0Y(BN$B$,5vMF$5$l$k$K$;$h$=$&$G$J$$$K$;$h(B$B!"(B $B9T0Y(BN$B$O$$$:$l$K$7$F$b$3$l$^$G0J>e$KIQHK$K$J$5$l$k$h$&$K$J$k$@$m$&!#$@(B $B$+$i!"9T0Y(BA$B$O5v$5$l$k$Y$-$G$J$$!W$HO@$8$k$3$H$b$"$k!#(B

$BM-32$JA0Nc$X$NAJ$((B ($BBh;0@a(B)

Hartogh$B$O!"A0@a$GDs<($5$l$?$9$Y$j:dO@K!$NE57?E*7A<0$N8!F$$KF~$kA0$K!"(B $B$3$NE57?E*7A<0$H$OFs$D$NE@$G0[$J$kO@K!$r>R2p$7$F$$$k!#$3$NO@K!$O(B $BM-32$JA0Nc$X$NAJ$((B$B$H8F$P$l$k$b$N$G!"0J2<$N$h$&$J9=B$(B $B$r;}$D!#!V9T0Y(BA$B$O0l8+$7$?$H$3$m!"F;FAE*$K$OLdBj$J$$!#$7$+$7!"9T0Y(BA$B$r5v(B $B$9$J$i$P!"$9$Y$F$N=EMW$JE@$K$*$$$F9T0Y(BA$B$H;w$F$$$k9T0Y(BB $B$r5v$5$J$$M}M3(B $B$O$J$$!#$@$,!"9T0Y(BB$B$OL@$i$+$K5v$7$,$?$$$b$N$G$"$k!#!W$3$NO@K!$,$9$Y$j(B $B:dO@K!$NE57?E*7A<0$H0[$J$kE@$O!"(B(1)$B!V$b$79T0Y(BA$B$r5v$9$N$J$i!"(B$B9g(B $BM}E*$K$O(B$B9T0Y(BB$B$r$b5v$5$6$k$r$($J$$!W$HO@$8$F$$$k$@$1$G!"!V$o$l(B $B$o$l$,9T0Y(BA$B$r5v$9$N$J$i(B$B$B9T0Y(BB$B$b$BM=A[$r$7$F$$$J$$(B$BE@$H!"(B(2)$BLdBj$K$J$k$N$O9T0Y(BA$B$H(B $B9T0Y(BB $B$@$1$G!"$=$l$i$NCf4VE*$J9T0Y$d!"9T0Y(BC$B!"9T0Y(BD $B$J$I$N$5$i$J$kO":?(B $B$OLdBj$K$5$l$F$$$J$$E@$G$"$k(B($BFs$DL\$NE@$O<!@a$G8!F$$5$l$k(B)$B!#(B

$B$"$k9T0Y$,IT@5$G$"$k$3$H$r<($9$?$a$K!"$9$G$KIT@5$G$"$k$HG'$a$i$l$?(B $B9T0Y$H$=$N9T0Y$H$NN`;w@-$r;XE&$9$k$H$$$&$N$O!"H=NcK!$KE57?E*$K8+$i$l$k(B $B;W9MK!$G$"$k$,!"(BHartogh$B$N9M$($G$O!"$3$NO@K!$OBEEv$G$"$k(B($BO@M}E*$K@5$7$$(B)$B!#(B $BH`$O$3$NO@K!$NBEEv@-$r!"5,HOE*=R8l$N$h$/CN$i$l$?FCD'$G$"$k(B$B0MB8(B $B@-(B (supervenience)$B$rMQ$$$F@bL@$7$F$$$k!#$9$J$o$A!"$"$k9T0Y$,(B $BF;FAE*$K5vMF$5$l$&$k$+$I$&$+$O!"$=$N9T0Y$r5vMF$5$l$&$k$b$N$K$9$k$$$/$D(B $B$+$NB>$NFCD'$,$=$N9T0Y$KHw$o$C$F$$$k$+$I$&$+$K0MB8$9$k(B(9)$B!#$=$l$f$(!"9T0Y(BA$B$,5vMF$5$l$F$*$j!"9T0Y(BB$B$,=EMW$J(B $BE@$K$*$$$F9T0Y(BA$B$HF1$8FCD'$r;}$D$N$G$"$l$P!"9gM}E*$K$O9T0Y(BB$B$b5vMF$5$l$J(B $B$/$F$O$J$i$J$$!#$b$C$H$b!"9T0Y(BB$B$O!"$?$H$(9T0Y(BA$B$r5vMF$5$l$k$b$N$K$9$kFC(B $BD'$r$9$Y$F6&M-$7$F$$$?$H$7$F$b!"I,$:$7$b5vMF$5$l$k$H$O8B$i$J$$!#$H$$$&(B $B$N$O!"9T0Y(BB$B$O!"$=$N9T0Y$r5v$5$l$J$$$b$N$K$9$k$h$&$JB>$NFCD'$b;}$C$F$$(B $B$k$+$b$7$l$J$$$+$i$G$"$k!#$=$l$f$(!"(BHartogh$B$K$h$l$P!"F;FAE*5DO@$bK!E*(B $B5DO@$bO@G}2DG=(B(defeasible)$B$J$b$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B$^$?!"$3$N$3$H$K$h$C$F!"!VM-32$JA0Nc$X$NAJ$(!W$rO@G}$9$kJ}K!$b$o$+(B $B$k$HH`$O8@$&!#$9$J$o$A!"9T0Y(BA$B$r@5$7$$$b$N$K$9$kFCD'$N$&$A!"9T0Y(BB$B$,6&M-(B $B$7$F$$$J$$$b$N$r;XE&$9$k$+!"9T0Y(BB$B$rIT@5$J$b$N$K$9$kFCD'$N$&$A!"9T0Y(BA$B$,(B $B6&M-$7$F$$$J$$$b$N$r;XE&$7!"9T0Y(BA$B$H9T0Y(BB$B$,=EMW$JE@$K$*$$$F0[$J$k$3$H$r(B $B<($7$F$d$l$P$h$$$N$G$"$k!#$b$C$H$bH`$N9M$($G$O!"$3$NO@K!$N??2A$O!"9T0Y(B A$B$NH?BPZ@UG$$rIi$o$;$k(B)$B$H$$$&E@$K$"$k!#(B

$B9gM}@-$N:d(B ($BBh;M@a(B)

$B<!$K(BHartogh$B$O!">-Mh$NM=A[$r4^$^$J$$=c?h$KO@M}E*$J$9$Y$j:dO@K!(B($BBhFs(B $B@a;2>H(B)$B$NBEEv@-$r8!F$$9$k!#H`$K$h$l$P$3$NO@K!$O<!$N$h$&$J?M9)G%?1Cf@d(B $B$N5DO@$K$*$$$FMQ$$$i$l$k$3$H$GM-L>$G$"$k!#(B
$B@\9gBN(B(zygote)$B$r;&$7$F$h(B $B$$$N$G$"$l$P!"G%?1(B14 $BF|8e$Nfu(B(embryo)$B$r;&$9$3$H$r6X$8$kM}M3$O$J$$!#$@(B $B$H$9$l$P!"G%?1(B3$B%v7n$NB[;y$r;&$9$3$H$r6X$8$kM}M3$b$J$$(B--$BEy!9!#@\9gBN$+(B $B$i;R$I$b$^[email protected]$K$OFMA3$NJQ2=$H$$$&$b$N$,$J$$$+$i!"@\9gBN$r;&$9$3$H(B $B$r5v$5$l$k$J$i$P!"!V$3$3$+$i$O;&$7$F$O$$$1$J$$!W$H$$$&E@$r9gM}E*$K7h$a(B $B$k$3$H$O$G$-$J$$!#@8B8G=NO$NM-L5$O0eHartogh$B$N8@$&$h$&$K!"$3$NO@K!$O!VM-32$JA0Nc$X$NAJ$(!W$H$h$/;w$F$$$k!#(B $B$3$NO@K!$O!"!V(BA$B$r5v$9$J$i(BB$B$b5v$5$l$k!#(BB$B$b5v$5$l$k$J$i(BC$B$b5v$5$l$k!W$H$$(B $B$&7A$GA0Nc$X$NAJ$($r7+$jJV$7!":G8e$K!V$9$k$H!"(BA$B$,5v$5$l$k$J$i(BN$B$b5v$5$l(B $B$k$3$H$K$J$k!W$H$$$&Iw$K!"L@$i$+$KM-32$JA0Nc$X$H$?$I$j$D$/!#!VM-32$JA0(B $BNc$X$NAJ$(!W$,BEEv$JO@K!$@$H$9$k$H!"O@M}E*$J$9$Y$j:dO@K!$bBEEv$@$H;W$o(B $B$l$k!#(B

$B$7$+$7!"(BHartogh$B$K$h$k$H!"$BBO@Q$N8mI5(B ($BO":?<0(B)$B$H$7$FCN$i$l$F$$$k8mI5$J$N$G$"$k!#BO@Q$N8mI5$NBeI=Nc(B $B$O<!$N$b$N$G$"$k!#IaDL$KH1$,@8$($F$$$k=w@-$+$iH1$r0lK\$@$1H4$$$F$bH`=w(B $B$OFE$2$H$O8F$P$l$J$$!#$b$&0lK\H4$$$F$b$d$O$jFE$2$H$O8F$P$l$J$$!#$b$&0l(B $BK\!#$b$&0lK\!#!D!#$D$$$K:G8e$N0lK\$^$GH1$NLS$rH4$$$F$b!"$d$O$jH`=w$rFE(B $B$2$H8F$V$3$H$O$G$-$J$$!#$J$<$J$i!"H`=w$,FE$2$H8F$P$l$k?M!9$NCg4VF~$j$r(B $B$9$k@53N$JE@$r;XE&$G$-$J$+$C$?$+$i$G$"$k!#(B($BH1$NLS$,0lK\$b$J$$>l9g$N$_(B $BFE$2$H8F$V$N$@$HH?O@$5$l$k$+$b$7$l$J$$$,!"DL>o$O!VFE$2!W$H$$$&8l$O$=$N(B $B$h$&$K8BDjE*$KMQ$$$i$l$k$3$H$O$J$$!#(B)

Hartogh$B$K$h$k$H!"$3$NO@K!$,$I$&$7$F8mI5$J$N$+$r@bL@$9$k$3$H$OO@M}3X(B $BZ$KMQ$$$i$l$kA0Ds$b?dO@$N;EJ}$K$bLdBj$O$J$$$?(B $B$a!"$*$=$i$/$3$NO@K!$O$9$Y$F$N;vNc$KEv$F$O$^$k$o$1$G$O$J$$$H9M$($6$k$r(B $B$($J$$!"$HH`$O=R$Y$F$$$k!#$H$/$K!VFE$2!W$J$I$N[#Kf$J8@MU(B($B$9$J$o$A!"$"(B $B$kO"B3BN(B(continuum)$B$NITL@3N$J0lItJ,$r;X$98@MU(B)$B$N>l9g$K$O$=$&$G$"$k(B(10)$B!#(B

$BO":?<0$,$J$<8mI5$+$r@bL@$9$k$N$OFq$7$$$,!"$7$+$7$=$l$,8mI5$G$"$k$3(B $B$H$O$^$A$,$$$J$$$H(BHartogh$B$O=R$Y$k!#$H$$$&$N$O!"9u$HGr$NCf4V$K3%?'$NNN(B $B0h(B (grey area)$B$,$"$j!"$=$N6-3&@~<+BN$bITL@3N$@$+$i$H$$$C$F!"3%?'$NNN0h(B $B$h$j$bL@$i$+$K9uB&$^$?$OGrB&$K$"$kE@$r;XE&$G$-$J$$$o$1$G$O$J$$$+$i$G$"(B $B$k!#$7$?$,$C$F!"O@M}E*$J$9$Y$j:dO@K!$ON)>Z@UG$$rAj$B$H$O$$$(!"(BHartogh$B$N9M$($G$O!"$=$N$h$&$J=EMW$J0c$$$,H/@8$9$kE@$r47=,(B $BE*!&K!E*$J5,HO$K$h$C$FDj$a$kI,MW$,$"$k!#$?$H$($P!"G%?1(B3$B%v7n$^$G$OB[;y(B $B$K$h$k$B$^$?(BHartogh$B$K$h$l$P!"Cf@d$N5DO@$N>l9g!"O@M}E*$9$Y$j:dO@K!$OJL$N0UL#(B $B$G$bCWL?E*$J7gE@$r;}$D!#Cf@d$KH?BP$9$k$?$a$K$9$Y$j:dO@K!$r;}$A=P$9?M$O!"(B $B!V?M4V$N@8L?$NJ]8n$OG%?1$7$?;~E@$+$i;O$^$k!W$H$$$&8=>u$N0LCV$,40A4$KL@(B $B3N$G$"$k$3$H$rA0Ds$7$F$$$k!#$@$,!"$B0J>e$N$h$&$K!"(BHartogh$B$K$h$l$P!"O@M}E*$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O8mI5?dO@$G$"$j!"$3$N$h$&$J5DO@$KH?O@$9$k$K$O!":d$N>e$H2<$N=EMW$J0c$$$r;XE&$9$k$@$1$G$h$$!#$@$,!"H`$K$h$l$P!"Cf@d$N9gK!2=$K;?@.$9$k<+M3LL$9$kLdBj$O$^$5$K$3$N;XE&$,$G$-$J$$E@$K$"$k!#$9$J$o$A!"H`$i$O?M4V$r?M$rG'$a0U;WEAC#$9$kG=NO$,MW5a$5$l$k!#$=$3$G$3$N>l9g$K$O!"O@M}E*$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O(B--$B$=$N4pK\E*$J9M$(J}$O8m$C$F$$$k$b$N$N!"7k2LE*$K@\9gBN$H@V;R$N=EMW$J0c$$$N;XE&$rO@AhAjZ@UG$$NE>[email protected]$7$F$$$k$H8@$($k!#H`$N9M$($G$O!"Cf@d$K;?@.$9$k<+M3

$BHs9gM}@-$N:d(B ($BBh8^@a(B)

$BA0@a$G(BHartogh$B$O!"?M4V$N9gM}@-$KAJ$($k$9$Y$j:dO@K!$NBEEv@-$rO@$8$?$,!"(B $BK\@a$G$O!"9gM}@-$X$NAJ$($r4^$^$J$$$9$Y$j:dO@K!$,$I$NDxEY$N@bF@NO$r;}$D(B $B$+$r9M;!$7$F$$$k!#(B

$BA0@a$G8+$?$h$&$K!"0l8+$9$k$H9gM}E*$K8+$($kO@M}E*$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O$B$^$?!"(BHartogh$B$K$h$l$P!"@h$NCf@d$NNc$+$iL@$i$+$J$h$&$K!"$o$l$o$l$OL@(B $B3N$JE@(B($B$?$H$($PG%?1$7$?$H$-(B)$B$r<($9$@$1$G$OIT==J,$G!"$=$l$,$^$?Ws0UE*$J(B $BE@$G$J$$$3$H$b<($9I,MW$,$"$k$N$@$,!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$rMQ$$$k?M!9$O!"$7$P$7(B $B$P8=>u$N0LCV$,$^$C$?$/Ws0UE*$G$J$/!"M#0lF;FAE*$KMJ8n2DG=$J$b$N$@$H9M$((B $B$k798~$K$"$k!#$b$C$H$b!"$3$N$h$&$J9M$($r;}$D?M$,$9$Y$j:dO@K!$r;H$C$F$b!"(B $B8=>u$N0LCV$KK~B-$7$J$$?M$r@bF@$9$k$3$H$O$G$-$=$&$K$J$$!#(B

Hartogh$B$N9M$($G$O$5$i$KLdBj$,$"$k!#$=$l$O!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$GLdBj$K$5$l(B $B$F$$$k$N$,!"F;FAE*??M}$J$N$+!"47=,$J$N$+!"$"$k$$$OK!N'$J$N$+!"$H$$$&Ld(B $BBj$G$"$k!#H`$K$h$l$P!"$o$l$o$l$ODL>o!"F;FAH=CG$r?.G0$NLdBj$@$H9M$($F$$(B $B$k!#$9$J$o$A!"(BA$B$,5v$5$l$k$H$_$J$9$3$H$O!"!V(BA$B$,5v$5$l$k!W$H$$$&L?Bj$,??(B $B$@$H?.$8$k$3$H$G$"$k!#$9$k$H$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O7k6I!"$$$C$?$s!V(BA$B$,5v$5$l$k!W(B $B$,??$@$H?.$8$?$i!"7k6I!V(BN$B$,5v$5$l$k!W$,??$@$H$$$&$3$H$b?.$8$k$3$H$K$J(B $B$k$H8@$C$F$$$k$3$H$K$J$k$,!"$3$l$OL@$i$+$K@5$7$/$J$$!#$@$,!"$?$H$($3$l(B $B$,@5$7$$$H$7$F$b!"!V(BA$B$,5v$5$l$k!W$,??$G$"$k$3$H$r?.$8$J$$M}M3$K$O$J$i(B $B$J$$!#$J$<$J$i!"$"$k??$J$kL?Bj$r?.$8$k$J$i0-$$7k2L$,@8$8$k$+$i$H$$$C$F!"(B $B$=$NL?Bj$,56$K$J$k$3$H$O$J$$$+$i$G$"$k!#(B

$B$=$3$G!"(BHartogh$B$N9M$($G$O!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$rM}2r$9$k$?$a$K$H$j$&$kJ}8~(B $B$OFs$D$"$k!#0l$D$O!"5DO@$5$l$F$$$k$N$O4pK\E*$J(B$BF;FAE*??M}(B $B$NLdBj$G$O$J$/!"?M4V$N(B$B47=,(B(conventions)$B$NLd(B $BBj$@$H9M$($k$3$H$G$"$k!#$3$N>l9g!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$,O@G}$7$h$&$H$7$F$$$kDs(B $B0F$O!V$o$l$o$l$N47=,$r8=>u$N0LCV$+$i?7$7$$0LCV$X$HJQ$($k$b$C$H$b$JM}M3(B $B$,$"$k!W$H$$$&$b$N$G$"$k!#$@$,!"H`$K$h$l$P!"$3$N$h$&$K2r$=$&$H$7$J$$$N$@$m$&$+!"$HH`$O=R$Y$F$$$k!#(B

$BH`$K$h$l$P!"$b$&0l$D$NJ}8~$O!"??$NF;FA$O%(%j!<%H$N$b$N$@$+$i!"72=0(B $B$K$O65$($J$$J}$,$h$$$H$$$&$b$N$G$"$k!#$9$J$o$A!"9T0Y(BA$B$O%(%j!<%H$K$H$C(B $B$F$O40A4$K5vMF$G$-$k$b$N$G$"$k$,!"72=0$K65$($k$H$9$Y$j:d$,5/$-$k$H9M$((B $B$k$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B$H$3$m$G!"Ds0F$5$l$F$$$k?7$7$$0LCV$,(B$BF;FA(B$B$G$O$J$/(B $BK!N'(B$B$K4X$9$k$b$N$G$"$k$J$i!"$3$N@a$G$N5DO@$N$$$/$D$+(B $B$OEv$F$O$^$i$J$$$H(BHartogh$B$O8@$&!#$J$<$J$i!"$?$H$(K!N'$NBgItJ,$OF;FAE*(B $B?.G0$K$h$C$F@5Ev2=$5$l$k$Y$-$G$"$k$K$;$h!"K!N'$OF;FAE*?.G0$NI=L@$G$O$J(B $B$$$+$i$G$"$k!#$7$?$,$C$FK!N'$K4X$9$k>l9g$O!"(BA$B$,5v$5$l$k$H!"(BN$B$bF10l$"$k(B $B$$$O0[$J$k8"0R$K$h$C$FG'$a$i$l$k$3$H$K$J$k$+$i!"(BA$B$O5v$5$l$k$Y$-$G$O$J(B $B$$$HO@$8$k$N$OITE,@Z$H$O8@$($J$$!#$"$k$$$O!"(BA$B$,5v$5$l$k$H!">/$J$/$H$b!"(B $BK!$N2<$K$$$k?M!9$K$h$C$F(BN$B$,$h$jB?$/$J$5$l$k$h$&$K$J$k$HO@$8$i$l$k$+$b(B $B$7$l$J$$!#(B

$B$5$i$K!"6-3&@~$,L@3N$G$"$k$3$H$OK!$K$*$$$F$O$H$j$o$12ACM$,$"$k$H(B Hartogh $B$O=R$Y$k!#$H$$$&$N$b!"K!$K$*$$$F$O!"5v$5$l$k$3$H$H$=$&$G$J$$$3(B $B$H$H$N6-3&@~$O!"7Y;!41$dH=;v$P$+$j$G$J$/;TL1$K$h$C$F$b$O$C$-$jM}2r$5$l(B $B$kI,MW$,$"$k$+$i$G$"$k!#$b$A$m$sK!N'$N>l9g$G$b!"Ws0UE*$J6-3&@~$O$O$C$-(B $B$j3%?'$NNN0h$NFbIt$HJ,$+$k$H$3$m$K0z$+$l$F$$$k$K$3$7$?$3$H$O$J$$!#C1$K(B $BL@3N$G$"$k$H$$$&M}M3$@$1$+$iWs0UE*$J6-3&@~$,A*$P$l$k$J$i!"$3$N6-3&@~$,(B $Bl9g$K$*$$$F$b!"$9$Y$j:d(B $BO@K!$,8z2LE*$KMQ$$$i$l$k>l9g$O!"8=>u$N0LCV$,L@3N$5$@$1$G$J$/F;FAE*?.MQ(B $B$r$b;}$D$3$H$,A0Ds$5$l$F$$$k!#$7$?$,$C$FK!$NNN0h$K$*$$$F$O(B--$B$H$/$K?7$7(B $B$$0LCV$h$j$b8=>u$N0LCV$NJ}$,F;FAE*$KM%$l$F$$$k$3$H$r<($9$?$a$K$9$Y$j:d(B $BO@K!$,MQ$$$i$l$k$H$-$K$O(B--$B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$,FH<+$N@bF@NO$r;}$C$F$$$k$H9M$((B $B$?J}$,$h$5$=$&$G$"$k!"$H(BHartogh$B$O7kO@$9$k!#(B

$B;v

Hartogh$B$O!"(B $BA0@a$^$G$GO@$8$i$l$?$9$Y$j:dO@K!$NLdBjE@$r0J2<$NFs$D$K$^$H$a$F$$$k!#(B

  1. $B9gM}@-$N:d$K8@5Z$9$k$9$Y$j:dO@K!$N$&$A!"M#0lBEEv$J$N$O!"(B $BCf4VE*$J;vNc$,O"B3BN$r9=@.$9$k$H$$$&O@E@$K0M5r$7$J$$$b$N$@$1$G$"$k(B ($B$=$l$,$9$Y$j:dO@K!$H8F$P$l$k$Y$-$+$I$&$+$OCV$$$F$*$/(B)$B!#(B
  2. $BF;FAE*5DO@$NNN0h$K$*$$$F$O!"(B $B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O4pK\E*F;FAE*??M}$K$OE,MQ$5$l$($:!"(B $B$;$$$<$$47=,E*$J;vJA$KE,MQ$5$l$k$@$1$G$"$k!#(B

$BM-8z$J$9$Y$j:dO@K!$r:n$k$?$a$K$O!"B>$K$I$s$J0lHLE*>r7o$,I,MW$@$m$&(B $B$+!#(B Hartogh$B$N9M$($G$O!"$=$N0l$D$K!"(B$B --$B!V:d$r$9$Y$k$@$m$&!W$H$$$&u(B $B$K$H$I$^$k$3$H$K$bF;FAE*%3%9%H$,$+$+$k$+$i$G$"$k!#$3$&$7$?%3%9%H$,!"6%(B $B9g$9$k$9$Y$j:dO@K!$N7A<0$GDs<($5$l$k$3$H$b$"$k!#$?$H$($P(BJohn Griffiths $B$O!"0B3Z;`$d<+;&Vs=u$O;j$k$H$3$m$G9T$J$o$l$F$$$k$?$a!"$=$l$r8=:_$N$h$&(B $B$K%?%V!<;k$9$k$h$j$b!"K!N'$K$h$C$F873J$J>r7o$N2<$G5vMF$7$?J}$,NI$$$HO@(B $B$8$F$$$k(B(11)$B!#(B

$B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$GMQ$$$i$l$k0x2LE*:nMQ$r$b$C$H$b$i$7$/@bL@$9$k$3$H$,$7(B $B$P$7$P:$Fq$J$3$H$rNc>Z$9$k$?$a$K!"(BHartogh$B$O6aG/%*%i%s%@$NK?IB1!$G5/$-(B $B$?<!$N$h$&$J;v7o$rNc$K5s$2$F$$$k!#(B
$B$"$k4G8nIX$,%"%k%D%O%$%^!j$KEjM?$9$k$3$H(B $B$K$h$C$F>/$J$/$H$b(B5$B?M$r;&$7$?!#4G8nIX$OA10U$+$i$d$C$?$H8@$C$F$$$k$,!"(B $BH`=w$O@:?@E*$KIT0BDj$G$"$k$3$H$,@:?@4UDj$K$h$C$F$o$+$C$?!#(B

$B0B3Z;`$K4X$9$k%*%i%s%@$N@/:v$rHcH=$9$k$B$7$+$7B>J}$G!"H`$N9M$($G$O!"%*%i%s%@$N0B3Z;`@/:v$K4X$9$kM=A[$,$3$&(B $B$7$?;vNc$K$h$C$FN"IU$1$i$l$?$H9M$($k?M$O!"F;FAE*%3%9%H$r8xJ?$K9MN8$7$F(B $B$$$J$$$3$H$,B?$$!#$H$$$&$N$O!"0B3Z;`$rG'$a$J$1$l$P!";`$LA0$KD9$$$"$$$@(B $B6lDK$rBQ$($J$/$F$O$J$i$J$$?M$,$G$F$/$k$H$$$&%^%$%J%9LL$rH`$i$OL5;k$7$F(B $B$$$k$+$i$G$"$k!#$3$NE@$G$b!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$rMQ$$$k?M$,DL>o!"8=>u$N0LCV$r(B $BF;FAE*$K40A4$K5vMF$G$-$k$b$N$H9M$($F$$$k$3$H$,M}2r$5$l$k$H(BHartogh$B$O=R(B $B$Y$F$$$k!#(B

$B$3$N$h$&$K!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$rFHN)$7$?5DO@$H$7$F9M$($k$J$i$P!"$?$H$($=(B $B$NM=A[$K$$$/$i$+@bF@NO$,$"$C$?$H$7$F$b!"7hDjE*$J5DO@$K$O$J$j$($J$$$3$H(B $B$,$[$H$s$I$G$"$k$H(BHartogh$B$O8@$&!#$@$,H`$K$h$l$P!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$N=EMW$J(B $B7gE@$OJL$N$H$3$m$K$"$j!"$3$l$b0B3Z;`$NO@Ah$rMQ$$$F@bL@$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#(B $B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$K$*$$$FM=A[$5$l$k0-$$7k2L$O!"%*%i%s%@$N4G8nIX$NNc$N$h$&$K(B $B?M!9$,8m$C$??dO@$r$9$k$3$H$+$i@8$8$k$H9M$($i$l$F$$$k!#$9$k$H!"(B $B0B3Z;`$,47=,E*$^$?$OK!E*$KG'$a$i$l$J$$M}M3$O!"0B3Z;`$rMW5a$7$F$$$k?M$N(B $B4jK>$,0-$$$+$i$G$O$J$/!"0B3Z;`$r@)EY$H$7$FG'$a$k$HB>$N?M$,IT@5$J$3$H$r(B $B$9$k$+$i$@$H$$$&$3$H$K$J$k(B$B!#$7$+$7!"0B3Z;`$rI,MW$H$7$F$$$k?M(B $B$K!"B>$N?M$,:a$rHH$9$N$rKI$0$?$a$K<+8J$NMx1W$r5>@7$K$7$F$/$l$HMW5a$9$k(B $B$N$OIT8xJ?$@$H(BHartogh$B$O@\E*@U(B $BG$$H4V@\E*@UG$$r6hJL$7$J$$7A<0$N5"7k$N?M$,$o$?$7$N9T0Y$KM=A[$5$l$?;EJ}$GH?1~$7$?(B $B$3$H$K$h$C$F@8$8$?;vBV$KBP$9$k!"$o$?$7$N@UG$$N$3$H$@$H$5$l$k!#(B

$B8+$+$1$Hu(B ($BBh<7@a(B)

$B$3$3$^$G$9$Y$j:dO@K!$NO@>Z$H$7$F$NM-8z@-$r8+$F$-$?$,!"(BHartogh$B$N9M$((B $B$G$O!"$3$NO@K!$O8BDj$5$l$?NN0h$K$*$$$F$N$_!"7hDjE*$G$O$J$$$,$$$/$i$+$N(B $B@bF@NO$r;}$D!#$7$+$7!"H`$K$h$l$P!"$3$NO@K!$,8=u$N0LCV$r@5Ev2=$9$k$?$a(B $B$K@dBPE*$K3NHartogh$B$K$h$l$P!"DL>o!"$=$N$h$&$J5DO@$K$^$H$b$Ku$N0LCV$,F;FAE*$KM%$l$F$$$k$H$$$&0U8+$rI=L@$7$F$$(B $B$k$K2a$.$J$$$+$i$G$"$k!#$=$N$h$&$J5DO@$K$*$$$F$O7k6I!"(B$BF;FAE*$K(B $B=EMW$J6-3&@~$O!":d$N>e$H:d$N2<$H$N4V$K$"$k6-3&@~$G$O$J$/!"8=>u$N0LCV$H(B $B?7$7$$0LCV$H$N4V$N6-3&@~$J$N$G$"$k(B$B!#$=$l$f$(!":d$N2<$K9T$-$D(B $B$/$H$$$&M=A[$O:d$N>e$N0LCV$,5vMF$G$-$J$$$H$$$&$BM-32$JA0Nc$X$NAJ$($HF1$8$3$H$K$J$k(B

$B$HH`$O7kO@$7$F$$$k!#$=$&9M$($k$J$i$P!"L$Mh$NM=A[$bCf4VE*$J;v(B $BNc$b=EMW$G$J$/!"$^$?!"$O$8$a$N0lJb$NF;FA@-$OLd$o$J$$$H$$$&7$/$b$N$G$7$+$J$$!#(B

$B$=$3$G!"$3$N$h$&$J>l9g!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$rMQ$$$ku$N0LCV$KBP$9$kCi@??4$+$i$OFHN)$G$"$k$+$I$&$+$r$=$N(B $Bu$N0LCV$H?7$7$$0LCV$NF;FAE*2ACM$K$D$$$FO@$8$l$P(B $B$h$$!#Ez$,!V$O$$!W$G$"$l$P!"$[$H$s$I$N>l9g!"Ajl9g$K8B$j!"Ev$N$9$Y$j:dO@K!$N$b$C$H$b(B $B$i$7$5$H@bF@NO$r6cL#$9$k0UL#$,$"$k$H8@$($k!"$HH`$O=R$Y$F$$$k!#(B

$B$*$o$j$K(B

$B0J>e$,(BHartogh$B$N5DO@$G$"$k!#(B $BH`$N5DO@$N=EMW$J7kO@$r;M$D$K$^$H$a$F0J2<$K<($7$F$*$/!#(B

  1. $BM-32$JA0Nc$X$NAJ$((B$B$OBEEv$J5DO@$G$"$k!#(B
  2. $B=c?h$KO@M}E*$J$9$Y$j:dO@K!(B$B$O8mI5$G$"$j!"(B $B9T0Y(BA$B$H9T0Y(BN$B$H$N=EMW$J0c$$$r<($9$3$H$,$G$-$k$J$i$P!"(B $B$=$N0c$$$,H/@8$7$?E@$r<($9I,MW$O$J$$!#(B $B$?$@$7!"M-32$JA0Nc$X$NAJ$($HF1MM$K!"(B $B9T0Y(BA$B$H9T0Y(BN$B$H$N0c$$$r;XE&$9$k@UG$$rAj[email protected]$7$F$$$k!#(B
  3. $B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O!V9T0Y(BA$B$r$9$k$J$i$P!":d$r$9$Y$C$F!"(B $B9T0Y(BN$B$r$b$9$k$h$&$K$J$k$@$m$&!W$H$$$&M=A[$r9T$J$&$,!"(B $B$=$NM=A[$,$b$C$H$b$i$7$$$3$H$r<($9$N$O$7$P$7$P:$Fq$G$"$k!#(B
  4. $B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O!"(B $B9T0Y(BA$B$H9T0Y(BN$B$N4V$K$OWs0UE*$J@~$7$+0z$1$J$$$+$i!"(B $B9T0Y(BA$B$r5v$9$Y$-$G$O$J$$$HO@$8$k$,!"(B $B$=$N:]!"8=>u$N0LCV$OWs0UE*$G$J$$$HA0Ds$7$F$$$k>l9g$,B?$$!#(B $B$^$?!"8=>u$N0LCV$,F;FAE*$K$bM%$l$F$$$k$H$7$P$7$P2>Dj$5$l$F$$$k!#(B $B$7$?$,$C$F!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$rMQ$$$?5DO@$rLdBj$K$9$k>l9g$K$O!"(B $B$^$:$3$l$i$NE@$,LdBj$K$5$l$k$Y$-$G$"$k!#(B

$B:G8e$K!"(BHartogh$B$N5DO@$GLdBj$K;W$($kE@$r0l$D$@$1;XE&$9$k!#H`$OBhO;@a(B $B$K$*$$$F!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$K$*$$$F$O9T0Y@\E*@UG$$H4V@\E*@UG$$,6hJL$5(B $B$l$F$$$J$$E@$r$3$NO@K!$NBg$-$J7gE@$H$7$F5s$2$F$$$k!#$=$7$F$9$Y$j:dO@K!(B $B$O$3$N6hJL$r$7$J$$$?$a!"!VB>$N?M$K$h$C$FIT@5$J9T0Y(BN$B$,$J$5$l$k$+$b$7$l(B $B$J$$$+$i!"$o$?$7$O9T0Y(BA$B$r9T$J$&$Y$-$G$J$$!W$H$$$&5DO@$rG'$a$k$3$H$K$J(B $B$k$HO@$8$F$$$k!#$7$+$7!"$?$H$($P0B3Z;`$K$D$$$F8@$&$H!"0B3Z;`$N@'Hs$,5D(B $BO@$5$l$k$N$O/$J$/$H$b$3$NJ8L.$K(B $B$*$$$F$O!V0B3Z;`$,47=,E*$^$?$OK!E*$KG'$a$i$l$J$$M}M3$O!"0B3Z;`$rMW5a$7(B $B$F$$$k?M$N4jK>$,0-$$$+$i$G$O$J$/!"0B3Z;`$r@)EY$H$7$FG'$a$k$HB>$N?M$,IT(B $B@5$J$3$H$r$9$k$+$i$@!W$HO@$8$k$3$H$O$^$C$?$/LdBj$,$J$$$H;W$o$l$k!#$J$<(B $B$J$i$3$3$GO@E@$K$J$k$N$O!"0B3Z;`$r9T$J$C$??M$,B>?M$NIT@59T0Y$KBP$7$F@U(B $BG$$r;}$D$+$I$&$+$H$$$&$3$H$G$O$J$/!"0B3Z;`$r5vMF$9$k$3$H$,@\E*@UG$$H(B $B4V@\E*@UG$$H$N6hJL$O$3$3$G$OL54X78$@$H;W$o$l$k!#(B

$BCm(B

  1. Wibren van der Burg, `The Slippery Slope Arguments', in Encyclopedia of Bioethics Revised Edition (W. T. Reich ed., Macmillan, 1995), p. 132.
  2. ibid., p. 130.
  3. $B$3$l$i$d$=$NB>$NNc$K$D$$$F$O!"<!$NK\$r8+$h!#(B Douglas Walton, Slippery slope arguments, Oxford Clarendon Press, 1992.
  4. van der Burg, 1995, pp. 131-2.
  5. Walton, 1992.
  6. Govert den Hartogh, `The slippery slope argument', in A Companion to Bioethics, (ed. by Helga Kuhse & Peter Singer), Blackwell, 1998, pp. 280-90.
  7. $B$3$l$O$?$H$($P<!$N$h$&$J5DO@$G$"$k!#(B $B!V@/I\$O@=B$6H.@n$KGS=P$9$k$N$r5v$7$F$O$J$i$J$$!#(B $B$J$<$J$i(BPCB$B$,2$B$?$H$($P(Bvan der Burg, 1995$B$r8+$h!#(B
  8. $B$h$j>\$7$/$O!"%X%"$N!XF;FA$N8@8l!Y$J$I$r;2>H$;$h!#(B $B!V$^$:!"!XA1$$!Y$NFCD'$N$&$A!"(B $B0MB8@-$H8F$P$l$F$$$kFCD'$re$2$h$&!#(B $B!V@;%U%i%s%A%'%9%3$OA1$$?M$@$C$?!W$H$o$l$o$l$,8@$&$H$7$h$&!#(B $B$3$&=R$Y$F!"$7$+$bF1;~$K!"(B $B!T@;%U%i%s%A%'%9%3$H$^$C$?$/F1$8>u67$KCV$+$l!"(B $B$^$C$?$/F1$8$h$&$K9T0Y$7$?$K$b$+$+$o$i$:!"(B $BA1$$?M$G$O$J$+$C$?$H$$$&E@$K$*$$$F$N$_@;%U%i%s%A%'%9%3$H(B $B0[$J$k?M$,$$$?$+$b$7$l$J$$!U(B $B$HThe Language of Morals, Oxford UP, 1964, p. 145. cf. pp. 79ff.)
  9. $BBO@Q$N8mI5$K$D$$$F$N$5$i$K>\$7$$5DO@$O!"(BWalton, 1992$B$r;2>H$;$h!#(B
  10. John Griffiths, `Assisted Suicide in the Netherlands: The Chabot Case', in The Modern Law Review, Vol. 58 (1995), pp. 232-49.

$B;29MJ88%(B

($BCm$G0zMQ$7$?$b$N$O>JN,$9$k(B)

  • Frederick Schauer, `Slippery Slopes', in Harvard Law Review, Vol. 99 (1985), pp. 361-83.
  • Wibren van der Burg, `The Slippery Slope Argument', in Ethics, Vol. 102 (1991), pp. 42-65.
  • Bernard Williams, `Which Slopes Are Slippery?', in Moral Dillemmas in Modern Medicine, ed. Michael Lockwood (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985), pp. 126-37.
    ($BK.Lu(B: $B%P!<%J!<%I!&%&%#%j%"%`%:!"(B $B!V$I$N:dF;$,3j$j$d$9$$$+!W(B($BLx_7M-8cLu(B)$B!"(B $B%^%$%1%k!&%m%C%/%&%C%IJTCx!&2CLPD>$B9>8}Ao!"!V(B$B0B3Z;`LdBj(B$B!W!"!X$B9u:j9d!"!V%K%k%9!&%[%k%?%C%0(B $B!V%R%H0dEA;R<#NE(B: $B3j$j:d$r2<$k$+(B?$B!W!W!"(B $B!X@8L?!&4D6-!&2J3X5;=QNQM}8&5f;qNA=8(BII$B!Y!"(B $B@iMUBg3XIaJW2JL\!V2J3X5;=Q$NH/C#$H8=Be$B9u:j9d!"(B $B!V(B$B!V0dEA;R<#NE3j$j:dO@!W$O8m$C$?HcH=$+(B? --$B%K%k%9!&%[%k%?%C%0!V%R%H0dEA;R<#NE(B: $B3j$j:d$r2<$k$+(B?$B!W(B $B$N8!F$(B--$B!W!"(B $B!X%R%H%2%N%`2r@O8&5f$H$B9u:j9d!"!V@8L?!&0dEA;RA`:n$KE,MQ$5$l$?!V3j$j:dO@!W(B $B$N0UL#$rB*$($k$?$a$K(B --W$B!&%t%!%s!&%G%"!&%P!<%0!&!V3j$j:dO@!W(B $B$N>R2p$r7s$M$F!W!"(B $B!X%R%H%2%N%`2r@O8&5f$H$B>>2&@/9@!"(B $B!V(B$B%R%H%2%N%`2r@O7W2h$=$N$b$N$rLd$&$3$H(B --$B2r@O8e$N=tLdBj$r8!F$$9$kA0$K(B--$B!W!"(B $B!X%R%H%2%N%`2r@O8&5f$H
  • $BLx_7M-8c(B$B!"!V@8L?NQM}$H8=BeNQM}3X2qJT!X8=BeNQM}$N2]Bj!Y!"98MN=qK<!"(B1990$BG/(B

($B$3$@$^(B $B$5$H$7(B $B5~ETBg3XBg3X1!J83X8&5f2J(B $BF|K\3X=Q?66=2qFCJL8&5f0w(B)
[email protected]

($BJdB-(B) $B0J2<$O>e$NO@J8>R2p$G$O%Z!<%8?t$NET9g$G>JN,$7$?(BHartogh$B$NBh0l@a$NItJ,!#(B

$B6qBNNc(B ($BBh0l@a(B)

Hartogh$B$O:G=i$K!"$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O$5$^$6$^$J5DO@$K$*$$$F$h$/;HMQ$5$l!"(B $B$^$?$3$NO@K!$O$?$$$F$$$N>l9g!"Ds0F$5$l$?2~3W$KBP$7$FH?O@$9$k$?$a$KMQ$$(B $B$i$l$k$H=R$Y$F$$$k!#0J2<$NNc$G$O!"=P@8A0?GCG$N $B$b$70dEA;R>e$N7g4Y$,8+$D$+$C$?$H$-$KI$N5?$$$,Cf@d$r9T$J$&$?$a$N$b$C$H$b$JM}M3$H9M$($i$l$k$@$m$&!#<!$K(B $B$OE|G"IB$,!"3y>u@V7l5eIO7l$,!"%@%&%s>I8u72$,!"$=$N<!$K$OOQ6JB-$,!"8}?0(B $BNv$,!"6a;k$,!"?'LU$,!"M>J,$J(BY$B@w?'BN$,!":8$-$-$,!"$=$7$F$D$$$K$OH)$N?'(B $B$,!"Cf@d$r$9$k$?$a$N$b$C$H$b$JM}M3$K$J$k$@$m$&!#Cf@d$r$9$k$3$H$OL$Mh$N(B $B;R6!<+?H$NMx1W$K$J$k$HO@$8$i$l$k$+$b$7$l$J$$!#$7$+$7!"$"$k?M$N@8$,@8$-(B $B$k$K$"$?$$$7$J$$$H$o$l$o$l$,7h$a$k$3$H$O$G$-$J$$!#$"$k>c32$r;}$C$??M$N(B $B@8$,2ACM$rM-$7$J$$$H7h$a$k8"Mx$O$o$l$o$l$K$O$J$$!#$=$&$9$k$3$H$OJ?Ey$H(B $B$$$&4pK\86B'$N?/32$G$"$k!#$b$7$3$N86B'$K0l$D$G$bNc30$rG'$a$k$J$i$P!">c(B $B32$r;}$C$??M!9$O?F$N2a<:$N;:J*$H$_$J$5$l$k$h$&$K$J$k$@$m$&!#?M!9$OH`$i(B $B$K$3$&8@$&$G$"$m$&!#!V$J$<$*$^$($O$3$3$K$$$k$s$@(B? $B$*$^$($OCf@d$5$l$k(B $B$Y$-$@$C$?$N$K!W!#$=$7$F?M!9$O!"$b$70l4S@-$r;}$D$N$G$"$l$P!"$D$$$K$O!"(B $B>c32$r;}$C$??M!9$N@8$O:#$+$i$G$b(B--$BH`$i<+?H$NMx1W$N$?$a$K(B--$B=*;_Id$rBG$?(B $B$l$k$Y$-$@$H?.$8$k$h$&$K$J$k$@$m$&!#(B

Hartogh$B$N5DO@$N9|;R(B ($B@8L?NQM}3XJY6/2qMQ%l%8%a(B)

$BBhFs@a(B $B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$NE57?E*7A<0(B (=$BO@M}E*$9$Y$j:dO@K!(B+$B>-Mh$NM=A[(B)

  • $BO@M}E*$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O!"(B $B!V(B$B9gM}E*$K$O(B$B!"9T0Y(BA$B$r5v$9$J$i$P!"(B $B9T0Y(BB$B!"9T0Y(BC$B!"!D!"9T0Y(BN$B$b5v$5$6$k$r$($J$$$O$:$@!W$H=R$Y$k!#(B
  • $B>-Mh$NM=A[$O!"(B $B!V9T0Y(BA$B$r5v$9$J$i$P!"$=$N7k2L!"(B $B$B9T0Y(BN$B$b5v$5$l$k$h$&$K$J$k$@$m$&(B ($B$"$k$$$O$h$jIQHK$K$J$5$l$k$@$m$&(B)$B!W$H=R$Y$k!#(B

$BBh;0@a(B $BM-32$JA0Nc$X$NAJ$((B

  • $BF;FAE*H=CG$N0MB8@-(Bsupervenience$B$K$h$C$F@5Ev2=$5$l$k(B
  • $B$3$NO@K!$KBP$9$kM-8z$JH?O@$O!"A0Nc$H$N0c$$$r;XE&$9$k$3$H(B
  • $B$3$NO@K!$N%a%j%C%H$O!"AjZ@UG$$rIi$o$;$i$l$k$3$H(B

$BBh;M@a(B $B9gM}@-$N:d(B ($BO@M}E*$9$Y$j:dO@K!$NLdBjE@(B)

  • $B!V9T0Y(BA$B$H9T0Y(BB$B$O6hJL$G$-$J$$!"9T0Y(BB$B$H9T0Y(BC$B$O6hJL$G$-$J$$!"!D!"(B $B$=$l$f$(!"9T0Y(BA$B$H9T0Y(BN$B$O6hJL$G$-$J$$!W(B $B$H$B$3$NO@K!$KBP$7$F$O!"9T0Y(BA$B$H9T0Y(BN$B$H$N=EMW$J0c$$$,;XE&$G$-$l$P$h$$!#(B
  • $B$3$N;XE&$rGw$kE@$G$O!"AjZ@UG$$rIi$o$;[email protected]$7$F$$$k!#(B

$BBh8^@a(B $BIT9gM}@-$N:d(B

  • $B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$,@bF@NO$r;}$DM}M3(B
    • $B$o$l$o$l$OO"B3BN$K@~0z$-$r$9$k$N$,6l$B8=>u$N0LCV$b$"$$$^$$$GWs0UE*$G$"$k$,!"(B $B$o$l$o$l$O$D$$L@3N$GF;FAE*$KMJ8n$G$-$k$b$N$H9M$($F$7$^$&(B
  • $B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$,@bF@NO$r;}$DNN0h(B
    • $BF;FAE*??M}(B--$B!_(B
    • $B47=,(B($BF;FA(B)--$B"$(B
    • $BK!N'(B--$B!{(B ($B$?$@$77hDjE*$J@bF@NO$r;}$D$H$O8@$($J$$(B)

$BBhO;@a(B $BF;FAE*$J$b$C$H$b$i$7$5$H;v

  • $B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$r$b$C$H$b$i$7$/=R$Y$k$?$a$K$O!"(B $B!V9T0Y(BA$B$r5v$9$H9T0Y(BN$B$^$G(B($B$[$\(B)$B3N$B2a5n$NNc$KAJ$($k"*$7$+$7!"$=$l$[$I@bF@NO$,$"$k$o$1$G$O$J$$!#(B
  • $B%*%i%s%@$N0B3Z;`@/:v"*$"$^$j$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O$b$C$H$b$i$7$/$J$$(B
  • $B$=$NB>$NLdBjE@(B: $B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O4V@\@UG$$HD>@\@UG$$N6hJL$rL5;k$7$F$$$k!#(B

    $BBh<7@a(B $B8+$+$1$Hu(B

    • $B$9$Y$j:dO@K!$O!"u$,2~3W0F(B($B9T0Y(BA)$B$h$j$bF;FAE*$KM%$l$F$$$k$3$H$r(B $BL5HcH=$KA0Ds$7$F$$$k$3$H$,B?$$$N$G!"(B $B$^$:$=$NE@$,LdBj$K$5$l$k$Y$-$G$"$k!#(B

    $B;29MJ88%0lMw(B

    • Govert Den Hartogh, `The slippery slope argument', in A Companion to Bioethics, (ed. by Helga Kuhse & Peter Singer), Blackwell, 1998.
    • John Griffiths, `Assisted Suicide in the Netherlands: The Chabot Case', in The Modern Law Review, Vol. 58 (1995), pp. 232-49.
    • Frederick Schauer, `Slippery Slopes', in Harvard Law Review, Vol. 99 (1985), pp. 361-83.
    • Wibren van der Burg, `The Slippery Slope Argument', in Ethics, Vol. 102 (1991), pp. 42-65.
    • Wibren van der Burg, `The Slippery Slope Arguments', in Encyclopedia of Bioethics Revised Edition (W. T. Reich ed., Macmillan, 1995)
    • Douglas Walton, Slippery slope arguments, Oxford Clarendon Press, 1992.
    • Bernard Williams, `Which Slopes Are Slippery?', in Moral Dillemmas in Modern Medicine, ed. Michael Lockwood (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985), pp. 126-37.
      ($BK.Lu(B: $B%P!<%J!<%I!&%&%#%j%"%`%:!"(B $B!V$I$N:dF;$,3j$j$d$9$$$+!W(B($BLx_7M-8cLu(B)$B!"(B $B%^%$%1%k!&%m%C%/%&%C%IJTCx!&2CLPD>$B9>8}Ao!"!V(B$B0B3Z;`LdBj(B$B!W!"(B $B!X$B9u:j9d!"!V%K%k%9!&%[%k%?%C%0(B $B!V%R%H0dEA;R<#NE(B: $B3j$j:d$r2<$k$+(B?$B!W!W!"(B $B!X@8L?!&4D6-!&2J3X5;=QNQM}8&5f;qNA=8(BII$B!Y!"(B $B@iMUBg3XIaJW2JL\!V2J3X5;=Q$NH/C#$H8=Be$B9u:j9d!"(B $B!V(B$B!V0dEA;R<#NE3j$j:dO@!W$O8m$C$?HcH=$+(B? --$B%K%k%9!&%[%k%?%C%0!V%R%H0dEA;R<#NE(B: $B3j$j:d$r2<$k$+(B?$B!W(B $B$N8!F$(B--$B!W!"(B $B!X%R%H%2%N%`2r@O8&5f$H$B9u:j9d!"!V@8L?!&0dEA;RA`:n$KE,MQ$5$l$?!V3j$j:dO@!W(B $B$N0UL#$rB*$($k$?$a$K(B --W$B!&%t%!%s!&%G%"!&%P!<%0!&!V3j$j:dO@!W(B $B$N>R2p$r7s$M$F!W!"(B $B!X%R%H%2%N%`2r@O8&5f$H$B>>2&@/9@!"(B $B!V(B$B%R%H%2%N%`2r@O7W2h$=$N$b$N$rLd$&$3$H(B --$B2r@O8e$N=tLdBj$r8!F$$9$kA0$K(B--$B!W!"(B $B!X%R%H%2%N%`2r@O8&5f$H
    • $BLx_7M-8c(B$B!"!V@8L?NQM}$H8=BeNQM}3X2qJT!X8=BeNQM}$N2]Bj!Y!"98MN=qK<!"(B1990$BG/(B

    $B$^$@F~

  • Burgess, J.A. (1993). The great slippery slope argument. Journal of Medical Ethics, 19, 169-74.
  • Holtug, N. (1993). Human gene therapy: Down the slippery slope? Bioethics, 7(5), 402-19.
  • Lamb, D. (1988). Down the sloppery slope. Arguing in applied ethics. New York: Croom Helm.
  • Whitman, J.P. (1994). The many guises of the slippery slope argument. Social Theory and Practice, 20, 85-97.
    • KODAMA Satoshi <[email protected]>
    Last modified: Sun Mar 12 06:54:30 JST 2000