�G���g�����X�ւ͂������N���b�N�@�@�@�@�@�@���E�����N��

���E�̒��̓��{
�����L���O�i�U�j����E��w

Ranking of the world by Teiichi Aoyama
�ŽR��� �����s�s��w���_�����@�r�c���݂� �‹������������ږ�
�f�ړ��F�Q�O�P�S�N�R���P�Q�� �@�Ɨ��n���f�B�A�@E-wave�@Tokyo�@�@���f�]�ڋ�

�i�ꊇ �X�N���[���j
�P�j�K���E�s�K �Q�j����E�񓹁E���s�E�j�� �R�j�o�ρE�J���E�i���@ �S�j���� 5�j�‹��E�ό��@ �U)����@ �V�j�R���E�j �W�j���a�E���S
�X�j�H�ƈ��S�ۏ� �P�O�j���N�E��� �P�P)�n�k�E�Ôg�E���� �P�Q�j�Đ��”\�G�l �P�R)�m�[�x���� 14)��t�E�{�����e�B�A�E�e�� 15)�@��
�o�T�ƔN���͊e�w�W�Ƀ����N�@���E�n�} �@�����{���v�ǐ��E�@����
����
���p���̍��������񎏁uTimes Higher Education�v�����N�i17�N�j9���ɔ��\�������E��w�����L���O�ł́A����͐��E��46�ʁB��N�i16�N�j39�ʂ���̑啝�_�E��
PISA�w�͓��B�x
�iOECD 2012�j

���w �lj�� �Ȋw
��w
�i2012-2013�j
��w
�i2015-2016�j
�@�@�@�@7�@�@�@�@�@�@�@�@�@�@�@�@�@�@4�@�@�@�@�@�@�@�@�@�@�@4 ���{�̍ō������N�@27 ���{�̍ō������N�@43
1�@��C 1�@��C 1�@��C
2�@�V���K�|�[�� 2�@���` 2�@���`
3�@���` 3�@�V���K�|�[�� 3�@�V���K�|�[��
4�@��k 4�@���{ 4�@���{�@
5�@�؍� 5�@�؍� 5�@�t�B�������h�@
6�@�}�J�I 6�@�t�B�������h 6�@�G�X�g�j�A�@
7�@���{ 7�@��k 7�@�؍�
8�@���q�e���V 7�@�J�i�_ 8�@�x�g�i��
9�@�X�C�X 7�@�A�C�������h 9�@�|�[�����h
10�@�I�����_ 10�@�|�[�����h 10�@���q�e���V
11�@�G�X�g�j�A 11�@���q�e���V 10�@�J�i�_
12�@�t�B�������h 11�@�G�X�g�j�A 12�@��k
13�@�J�i�_ 13�@�I�[�X�g�����A 13�@�h�C�c
13�@�|�[�����h 13�@�m�y 14�@�I�����_
15�@�x���M�[ 15�@�I�����_ 14�@�A�C�������h
16�@�h�C�c 16�@�}�J�I 16�@�}�J�I
17�@�x�g�i�� 16�@�x���M�[ 17�@�I�[�X�g�����A
18�@�I�[�X�g���A 16�@�X�C�X 18�@�m�y
19�@�I�[�X�g�����A 19�@�h�C�c 19�@�X�C�X
20�@�A�C�������h 19�@�x�g�i�� 20�@�X���x�j�A
20�@�X���x�j�A 21�@�t�����X 20�@�C�M���X
22�@�f���}�[�N 22�@�m���E�F�[ 22�@�`�F�R
22�@�m�y 23�@�C�M���X 23�@�I�[�X�g���A
24�@�`�F�R 24�@�A�����J 24�@�x���M�[
25�@�t�����X 25�@�f���}�[�N 25�@���g�r�A
26�@�C�M���X 26�@�`�F�R 26�@�t�����X
27�@�A�C�X�����h 27�@�C�^���A 27�@�f���}�[�N
28�@���g���B�A 28�@�I�[�X�g���A 28�@�A�����J
29�@���N�Z���u���O 29�@���g���B�A 29�@�X�y�C��
30�@�m���E�F�[ 30�@���N�Z�� 30�@���g�A�j�A
31�@�|���g�K�� 30�@�|���g�K�� 31�@�m���E�F�[
32�@�C�^���A 30�@�X�y�C�� 32�@�C�^���A
33�@�X�y�C�� 30�@�n���K���[ 32�@�n���K���[
34�@���V�A 34�@�C�X���G�� 34�@���N�Z��
34�@�X���o�L�A 35�@�N���A�`�A 34�@�N���A�`�A
36�@�A�����J 36�@�A�C�������h 36�@�|���g�K��
37�@���g�A�j�A 36�@�X�E�F�[�f�� 37�@���V�A
38�@�X�E�F�[�f�� 38�@�X���x�j�A 38�@�X�E�F�[�f��
39�@�n���K���[ 39�@���g�A�j�A 39�@�A�C�X�����h
40�@�N���A�`�A 39�@�M���V�� 40�@�X���o�L�A
41�@�C�X���G�� 41�@���V�A 41�@�C�X���G��
42�@�M���V�� 42�@�g���R 42�@�M���V��
43�@�Z���r�A 43�@�X���o�L�A 43�@�g���R
44�@�g���R 44�@�L�v���X 44�@�t�`�d
45�@���[�}�j�A 45�@�Z���r�A 45�@�u���K���A
46�@�L�v���X 46�@�t�`�d 46�@�Z���r�A
47�@�u���K���A 47�@�^�C 46�@�`��
48�@�t�`�d 48�@�`�� 48�@�^�C
49�@�J�U�t�X�^�� 49�@�R�X�^���J 49�@���[�}�j�A
50�@�^�C 50�@���[�}�j�A 50�@�L�v���X
51�@�`�� 51�@�u���K���A 51�@�R�X�^���J
52�@�}���[�V�A 52�@���L�V�R 52�@�J�U�t�X�^��
53�@���L�V�R 53�@�����e�l�O�� 53�@�}���[�V�A
54�@�����e�l�O�� 54�@�E���O�A�C 54�@�E���O�A�C
55�@�E���O�A�C 55�@�u���W�� 55�@���L�V�R
56�@�R�X�^���J 56�@�`���j�W�A 56�@�����e�l�O��
57�@�A���o�j�A 57�@�R�����r�A 57�@�����_��
58�@�u���W�� 58�@�����_�� 58�@�A���[���`��
59�@�A���[���`�� 59�@�}���[�V�A 59�@�u���W��
59�@�`���j�W�A 60�@�C���h�l�V�A 60�@�R�����r�A
61�@�����_�� 60�@�A���[���`�� 61�@�`���j�W�A
62�@�R�����r�A 62�@�A���o�j�A 62�@�A���o�j�A
62�@�J�^�[�� 63�@�J�U�t�X�^�� 63�@�J�^�[��
64�@�C���h�l�V�A 64�@�J�^�[�� 64�@�C���h�l�V�A
65�@�y���[ 65�@�y���[ 65�@�y���[
�S�f�[�^�\��
1 California Institute of
Technology (Caltech)�č�
2 Univ. of Oxford�p��
2 Stanford Univ.�č�
4 Harvard Univ.�č�
5 Massachusetts Institute of
Technology (MIT)�č�
6 Princeton Univ.�č�
7 Univ. of Cambridge�p��
8 Imperial College London�p��
9 Univ. of California, Berkeley�č�
10 Univ. of Chicago�č�
11 Yale Univ.�č�
12 ETH Zurich Swiss Federa
l Institute of Technology Zurich
13 Univ. of California,
Los Angeles (UCLA)�č�
14 Columbia Univ.�č�
15 Univ. of Pennsylvania�č�
16 Johns Hopkins Univ.�č�
17 Univ. College London (UCL)�p��
18 Cornell Univ.�č�
19 Northwestern Univ.�č�
20 Univ. of Michigan�č�
21 Univ. of Toronto�J�i�_
22 Carnegie Mellon Univ.
�č�
23 Duke Univ.�č�
24 Univ. of Washington�č�
25 Georgia Institute of
Technology (Georgia Tech)�č�
25 Univ. of Texas at Austin�č�
27 The Univ. of Tokyo ���{
28 Univ. of Melbourne
29 National Univ. of Singapore (NUS)
30 Univ. of British Columbia �J�i�_
31 Univ. of Wisconsin-Madison
32 Univ. of Edinburgh�p��
33 Univ. of Illinois at Urbana Champaign�č�
34 McGill Univ.
35 The Univ. of Hong Kong
35 Univ. of California, Santa Barbara�č�
37 Australian National Univ.
38 Univ. of California, San Diego�č�
39 London School of Economics
and Political Science (LSE)�p��
40 ?cole Polytechnique F?d?rale de Lausanne
41 New York Univ. (NYU)
42 Univ. of North Carolina at Chapel Hill�č�
42 Karolinska Institute
44 Univ. of California, Davis�č�
44 Washington Univ. in St Louis�č�
46 Peking Univ.
47 Univ. of Minnesota�č�
48 Ludwig-Maximilians-Universit?t Munchen
49 Univ. of Manchester�p��
50 Pohang Univ. of Science and
Technology (Postech)
51 Brown Univ.
52 Tsinghua Univ.
53 Ohio State Univ.
54 Kyoto Univ.���{
54 Boston Univ.
56 Univ. of Southern California
57 King's College London
58 KU Leuven
59 ?cole Normale Sup?rieure
59 Seoul National Univ.
61 Pennsylvania State Univ.
62 Univ. of Sydney
62 ?cole Polytechnique
64 Leiden Univ.
65 Hong Kong Univ. of Science and Technology
65 Univ. of Queensland Australia
67 Utrecht Univ.
68 Korea Advanced Institute of
Science and Technology (KAIST)
69 Purdue Univ.
70 Wageningen Univ. and Research Center
70 Georg-August-Universit?t G?ttingen
72 Erasmus Univ. Rotterdam
72 Univ. of Massachusetts�č�
74 Univ. of Bristol
75 Rice Univ.
76 Univ. of Pittsburgh�č�
77 Delft Univ. of Technology
78 Universit?t Heidelberg
79 Emory Univ.
80 Durham Univ.
81 Universit? Pierre et Marie Curie
82 Lund Univ.
83 Univ. of Amsterdam
84 Univ. of Montreal
85 Univ. of New South Wales
86 Nanyang Technological Univ.
87 Tufts Univ.�č�
88 McMaster Univ.
89 Univ. of Groningen
89 Univ. of Zurich
91 Univ. of Colorado Boulder�č�
92 Universit? Paris-Sud
93 Ghent Univ.
94 Univ. of Notre Dame
94 Michigan State Univ.�č�
96 Univ. of California, Irvine�č�
97 Univ. of Maryland, College Park�č�
98 Univ. of Arizona�č�
99 Monash Univ.
99 Rutgers, The State Univ. of New Jersey�č�
99 Humboldt-Universit?t zu Berlin
102 Univ. of Rochester
103 Univ. of York�č�
104 Case Western Reserve Univ.�č�
105 Technische Universit?t Munchen
106 Uppsala Univ.
106 Vanderbilt Univ.
108 Univ. of St Andrews�p��
109 Univ. of Helsinki
110 Univ. of Sussex�p��
110 Univ. of Sheffield
110 Trinity College Dublin
113 Univ. of Cape Town
114 Eindhoven Univ. of Technology
115 Maastricht Univ.
116 Aarhus Univ.
117 Stockholm Univ.
118 Univ. of Virginia�č�
119 Royal Holloway, Univ. of London�p��
120 Univ. of Nottingham
121 Univ. of Alberta
122 Univ. of Florida�č�
122 Univ. of California, Santa Cruz�č�
124 Chinese Univ. of Hong Kong
124 Univ. of Warwick
124 Dartmouth College
127 Radboud Univ. Nijmegen
128 Freie Universit?t Berlin
128 Tokyo Institute of Technology���{
130 Univ. of Copenhagen
130 Univ. of Southampton�p��
130 Universit? de Lausanne
133 Univ. of Geneva
134 Univ. of Utah
134 Indiana Univ.
134 National Taiwan Univ.
137 Hebrew Univ. of Jerusalem
137 Tohoku Univ.���{
139 Univ. of Glasgow
140 KTH Royal Institute of Technology
140 VU Univ. Amsterdam
142 Univ. of Leeds
142 Universit?t Basel
144 Albert-Ludwigs-Universit?t Freiburg
145 Lancaster Univ.
145 Queen Mary, Univ. of London
147 Osaka Univ.���{
148 Arizona State Univ.
149 Technical Univ. of Denmark
150 Boston College
151 Karlsruhe Institute of Technology
151 Univ. of Bern
153 Univ. of Exeter
154 Univ. of California, Riverside
154 RWTH Aachen Univ.
156 Yeshiva Univ.
156 Texas A&M Univ.
158 Univ. of Birmingham
158 Tel Aviv Univ.
158 Univ. of Sao Paulo
161 Univ. of Auckland
162 Univ. of Vienna
162 Stony Brook Univ.
164 Universit? Catholique de Louvain
165 Univ. of Delaware
166 Universit? Paris Diderot - Paris 7
167 The Univ. of Texas at Dallas
168 George Washington Univ.
169 Univ. of Iowa
170 ?cole Normale Sup?rieure de Lyon
171 Universit?t Bonn
171 Univ. of Liverpool
171 Univ. of Ottawa
174 Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
174 Georgetown Univ.
176 Univ. of Reading
176 Univ. of Aberdeen
176 Univ. of Adelaide
176 Univ. of East Anglia
180 Newcastle Univ.
180 Universit? Joseph Fourier, Grenoble
182 City Univ. of Hong Kong
183 Yonsei Univ.
184 Colorado School of Mines
184 Univ. of Illinois at Chicago�č�
184 William & Mary
187 Univ. of Twente
187 Univ. College Dublin
189 Medical Univ. of South Carolina�č�
190 Wake Forest Univ.
190 Univ. of Western Australia
192 Univ. of Antwerp
193 Technion Israel Institute of Technology
193 Iowa State Univ.�č�
193 Univ. of Miami�č�
196 Univ. of Leicester
196 Univ. of Victoria
198 Univ. at Buffalo
199 Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universitat Frankfurt am Main
200 Birkbeck, Univ. of London
1 California Institute of Technology
2 University of Oxford
3 Stanford University
4 University of Cambridge
5 Massachusetts Institute of Technology
6 Harvard University
7 Princeton University
8 Imperial College London
9 ETH Zurich ? Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich
Switzerland
10 University of Chicago
11 Johns Hopkins University
12 Yale University
13 University of California, Berkeley
14 University College London
15 Columbia University
16 University of California, Los Angeles
17 University of Pennsylvania
18 Cornell University
19 University of Toronto
Canada
20 Duke University
21 University of Michigan
22 Carnegie Mellon University
23 London School of Economics and Political Science
United Kingdom
24 University of Edinburgh
25 Northwestern University
26 National University of Singapore
Singapore
27 King�fs College London
United Kingdom
28 Karolinska Institute
Sweden
29 LMU Munich
Germany
30 New York University
31 ?cole Polytechnique F?d?rale de Lausanne
Switzerland
32 University of Washington
United States of America
33 University of Melbourne
Australia
34 University of British Columbia
Canada
35 KU Leuven
Belgium
36 University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
37 Heidelberg University
Germany
38 McGill University
Canada
39 University of California, San Diego
39 University of California, Santa Barbara
41 Georgia Institute of Technology
42 Peking University
China
43 University of Tokyo
Japan
44 University of California, Davis
44 University of Hong Kong
Hong Kong
46 University of Texas at Austin
47 Tsinghua University
China
47 Wageningen University and Research Center
Netherlands
49 Humboldt University of Berlin
Germany
50 University of Wisconsin-Madison
United States of America
51 Brown University
United States of America
52 Australian National University
Australia
53 Technical University of Munich
Germany
54 ?cole Normale Sup?rieure
France
55 Nanyang Technological University
Singapore
56 University of Manchester
United Kingdom
56 University of Sydney
Australia
58 University of Amsterdam
Netherlands
59 Hong Kong University of Science and Technology
Hong Kong
60 University of Queensland
Australia
60 Washington University in St Louis
United States of America
62 Utrecht University
Netherlands
63 University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
United States of America
64 Boston University
65 Delft University of Technology
Netherlands
65 University of Minnesota
67 Leiden University
Netherlands
68 University of Southern California
69 University of Bristol
United Kingdom
70 Durham University
71 Erasmus University Rotterdam
Netherlands
72 Free University of Berlin
Germany
73 Monash University
Australia
74 University of Groningen
Netherlands
75 Pennsylvania State University
76 University of Glasgow
76 University of Helsinki
Finland
78 University of T?bingen
Germany
79 University of Pittsburgh
80 University of Warwick
81 Uppsala University
Sweden
82 University of Copenhagen
Denmark
82 University of New South Wales
Australia
84 University of Freiburg
Germany
85 Seoul National University
South Korea
86 University of St Andrews
87 Vanderbilt University
88 Kyoto University
Japan
88 Maastricht University
Netherlands
90 Emory University
90 Lund University
Sweden
90 Ohio State University
93 University of Exeter
94 University of Bonn
94 Georgetown University
94 McMaster University
Canada
97 University of Sheffield
United Kingdom
98 Queen Mary University of London
99 University of G?ttingen
Germany
99 Michigan State University
�쐬�E�o�T�F�ŽR���@�����s�s��w���_�����@�@�@�@�@�m�y�F�j���[�W�[�����h �@�t�`�d�F�A���u�񒷍��A�M



�y�f�[�^�̏o�T�z

���E�����L���O ���E�����L���O

��l�������
CO2�r�o��

�o�T�F��l�������CO2�r�o��
��l�������ʂ���
�r�o�ʁikg/�l�E�N�j

�o�T�F��l�������ʂ��ݔr�o�ʁikg/�l�E�N�j
�����Ƃɒr�c���݂��i�‹������������j��g/�l�E���ɕϊ�

�ό������� �@2013�N���ό������̓����L���O���f�ڂ��Ă��܂�(�Ώۍ�: 140����)�B�X�C�X�ɖ{����u�����E�o�σt�H�[����(WEF)��2�N�Ɉ�x���\���Ă���u���s�E�ό������̓��|�[�g(The Travel & Tourism Competitiveness Report)�v����ɍ쐬�B�u�ό��r�W�l�X�v�u���ƋK���v�u�l�I�E�����I�����v�����C���ɒ������Ă���B
�‹��ۑS�x
Environmental Sustainability Index(�‹������”\���w�W)

�o�T�F�v�d�e�A�쐬�F�ŽR���@

�@