Heavy metal element

(Redirected from Heavy metals)

Heavy metals is a controversial and ambiguous term[2] for metallic elements with relatively high densities, atomic weights, or atomic numbers. The criteria used, and whether metalloids are included, vary depending on the author and context and has been argued should not be used.[3][4] A heavy metal may be defined on the basis of density, atomic number or chemical behaviour. More specific definitions have been published, none of which have been widely accepted. The definitions surveyed in this article encompass up to 96 out of the 118 known chemical elements; only mercury, lead and bismuth meet all of them. Despite this lack of agreement, the term (plural or singular) is widely used in science. A density of more than 5 g/cm3 is sometimes quoted as a commonly used criterion and is used in the body of this article.

Crystals of osmium, a heavy metal nearly twice as dense as lead[1]

The earliest known metals—common metals such as iron, copper, and tin, and precious metals such as silver, gold, and platinum—are heavy metals. From 1809 onward, light metals, such as magnesium, aluminium, and titanium, were discovered, as well as less well-known heavy metals including gallium, thallium, and hafnium.

Some heavy metals are either essential nutrients (typically iron, cobalt, copper and zinc), or relatively harmless (such as ruthenium, silver and indium), but can be toxic in larger amounts or certain forms. Other heavy metals, such as arsenic, cadmium, mercury, and lead, are highly poisonous. Potential sources of heavy metal poisoning include mining, tailings, smelting, industrial waste, agricultural runoff, occupational exposure, paints and treated timber.

Physical and chemical characterisations of heavy metals need to be treated with caution, as the metals involved are not always consistently defined. As well as being relatively dense, heavy metals tend to be less reactive than lighter metals and have far fewer soluble sulfides and hydroxides. While it is relatively easy to distinguish a heavy metal such as tungsten from a lighter metal such as sodium, a few heavy metals, such as zinc, mercury, and lead, have some of the characteristics of lighter metals; and lighter metals such as beryllium, scandium, and titanium, have some of the characteristics of heavier metals.

Heavy metals are relatively rare in the Earth's crust but are present in many aspects of modern life. They are used in, for example, golf clubs, cars, antiseptics, self-cleaning ovens, plastics, solar panels, mobile phones, and particle accelerators.

Definitions

edit

Controversial terminology

edit

The International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC), which standardizes nomenclature, says "the term heavy metals is both meaningless and misleading".[2] The IUPAC report focuses on the legal and toxicological implications of describing "heavy metals" as toxins when there is no scientific evidence to support a connection. The density implied by the adjective "heavy" has almost no biological consequences and pure metals are rarely the biologically active substance.[5] This characterization has been echoed by numerous reviews.[6][7][8] The most widely used toxicology textbook, Casarett and Doull’s toxicology[9] uses "toxic metal" not "heavy metals".[5] Nevertheless many scientific and science related articles continue to use "heavy metal" as a term for toxic substances [10][11] To be an acceptable term in scientific papers, a strict definition has been encouraged.[12]

Use outside toxicology

edit

Even in applications other than toxicity, there no widely agreed criterion-based definition of a heavy metal. Reviews have recommended that it not be used.[10][13] Different meanings may be attached to the term, depending on the context. For example, a heavy metal may be defined on the basis of density,[14] the distinguishing criterion might be atomic number,[15] or the chemical behaviour.[16]

Density criteria range from above 3.5 g/cm3 to above 7 g/cm3.[17] Atomic weight definitions can range from greater than sodium (atomic weight 22.98);[17] greater than 40 (excluding s- and f-block metals, hence starting with scandium);[18] or more than 200, i.e. from mercury onwards.[19] Atomic numbers are sometimes capped at 92 (uranium).[20] Definitions based on atomic number have been criticised for including metals with low densities. For example, rubidium in group (column) 1 of the periodic table has an atomic number of 37 but a density of only 1.532 g/cm3, which is below the threshold figure used by other authors.[21] The same problem may occur with definitions which are based on atomic weight.[22]

Heat map of heavy metals in the periodic table
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
1  H He
2  Li Be B C N O F Ne
3  Na Mg Al Si P S Cl Ar
4  K Ca Sc Ti V Cr Mn Fe Co Ni Cu Zn Ga Ge As Se Br Kr
5  Rb Sr Y Zr Nb Mo Tc Ru Rh Pd Ag Cd In Sn Sb Te I Xe
6  Cs Ba   Lu Hf Ta W Re Os Ir Pt Au Hg Tl Pb Bi Po At Rn
7  Fr Ra   Lr Rf Db Sg Bh Hs Mt Ds Rg Cn Nh Fl Mc Lv Ts Og
 
  La Ce Pr Nd Pm Sm Eu Gd Tb Dy Ho Er Tm Yb
  Ac Th Pa U Np Pu Am Cm Bk Cf Es Fm Md No
 
Number of criteria met:
Number of elements:
  
10
3
  
9
5
  
8
14
  
6–7
56
  
4–5
14
  
1–3
4
  
0
3
  
nonmetals
19
This table shows the number of heavy metal criteria met by each metal, out of the ten criteria listed in this section i.e. two based on density, three on atomic weight, two on atomic number, and three on chemical behaviour.[n 1] It illustrates the lack of agreement surrounding the concept, with the possible exception of mercury, lead and bismuth.

Six elements near the end of periods (rows) 4 to 7 sometimes considered metalloids are treated here as metals: they are germanium (Ge), arsenic (As), selenium (Se), antimony (Sb), tellurium (Te), and astatine (At).[31][n 2] Oganesson (Og) is treated as a nonmetal.

Metals enclosed by a dashed line have (or, for At and Fm–Ts, are predicted to have) densities of more than 5 g/cm3.

The United States Pharmacopeia includes a test for heavy metals that involves precipitating metallic impurities as their coloured sulfides.[23] On the basis of this type of chemical test, the group would include the transition metals and post-transition metals.[16]

A different chemistry-based approach advocates replacing the term "heavy metal" with two groups of metals and a gray area. Class A metal ions prefer oxygen donors; class B ions prefer nitrogen or sulfur donors; and borderline or ambivalent ions show either class A or B characteristics, depending on the circumstances.[32] The distinction between the class A metals and the other two categories is sharp. The class A and class B terminology is analogous to the "hard acid" and "soft base" terminology sometimes used to refer to the behaviour of metal ions in inorganic systems.[33] The system groups the elements by   where   is the metal ion electronegativity and   is its ionic radius. This index gauges the importance of covalent interactions vs ionic interactions for a given metal ion.[34] This scheme has been applied to analyze biologically active metals in sea water for example,[12] but it has not been widely adopted.[35]

Origins and use of the term

edit

The heaviness of naturally occurring metals such as gold, copper, and iron may have been noticed in prehistory and, in light of their malleability, led to the first attempts to craft metal ornaments, tools, and weapons.[36]

In 1817 the German chemist Leopold Gmelin divided the elements into nonmetals, light metals, and heavy metals.[37] Light metals had densities of 0.860–5.0 g/cm3; heavy metals 5.308–22.000.[38] The term heavy metal is sometimes used interchangeably with the term heavy element. For example, in discussing the history of nuclear chemistry, Magee[39] notes that the actinides were once thought to represent a new heavy element transition group whereas Seaborg and co-workers "favoured ... a heavy metal rare-earth like series ...".

The counterparts to the heavy metals, the light metals, are defined by The Minerals, Metals and Materials Society as including "the traditional (aluminium, magnesium, beryllium, titanium, lithium, and other reactive metals) and emerging light metals (composites, laminates, etc.)"[40]

Biological role

edit
Amount of heavy metals in
an average 70 kg human body
Element Milligrams[41]
Iron 4000 4000
 
Zinc 2500 2500
 
Lead[n 3] 120 120
 
Copper 70 70
 
Tin[n 4] 30 30
 
Vanadium 20 20
 
Cadmium 20 20
 
Nickel[n 5] 15 15
 
Selenium[n 6] 14 14
 
Manganese 12 12
 
Other[n 7] 200 200
 
Total 7000

Trace amounts of some heavy metals, mostly in period 4, are required for certain biological processes. These are iron and copper (oxygen and electron transport); cobalt (complex syntheses and cell metabolism); zinc (hydroxylation);[46][failed verification] vanadium and manganese (enzyme regulation or functioning); chromium (glucose utilisation); nickel (cell growth); arsenic (metabolic growth in some animals and possibly in humans) and selenium (antioxidant functioning and hormone production).[47] Periods 5 and 6 contain fewer essential heavy metals, consistent with the general pattern that heavier elements tend to be less abundant and that scarcer elements are less likely to be nutritionally essential.[48] In period 5, molybdenum is required for the catalysis of redox reactions; cadmium is used by some marine diatoms for the same purpose; and tin may be required for growth in a few species.[49] In period 6, tungsten is required by some archaea and bacteria for metabolic processes.[50] A deficiency of any of these period 4–6 essential heavy metals may increase susceptibility to heavy metal poisoning[51] (conversely, an excess may also have adverse biological effects). An average 70 kg human body is about 0.01% heavy metals (~7 g, equivalent to the weight of two dried peas, with iron at 4 g, zinc at 2.5 g, and lead at 0.12 g comprising the three main constituents), 2% light metals (~1.4 kg, the weight of a bottle of wine) and nearly 98% nonmetals (mostly water).[52][n 8]

A few non-essential heavy metals have been observed to have biological effects. Gallium, germanium (a metalloid), indium, and most lanthanides can stimulate metabolism, and titanium promotes growth in plants[53] (though it is not always considered a heavy metal).

Toxicity

edit

Heavy metals are often assumed to be highly toxic or damaging to the environment.[54] Some are, while certain others are toxic only if taken in excess or encountered in certain forms. Inhalation of certain metals, either as fine dust or most commonly as fumes, can also result in a condition called metal fume fever.

Environmental heavy metals

edit

Chromium, arsenic, cadmium, mercury, and lead have the greatest potential to cause harm on account of their extensive use, the toxicity of some of their combined or elemental forms, and their widespread distribution in the environment.[55] Hexavalent chromium, for example, is highly toxic[citation needed] as are mercury vapour and many mercury compounds.[56] These five elements have a strong affinity for sulfur; in the human body they usually bind, via thiol groups (–SH), to enzymes responsible for controlling the speed of metabolic reactions. The resulting sulfur-metal bonds inhibit the proper functioning of the enzymes involved; human health deteriorates, sometimes fatally.[57] Chromium (in its hexavalent form) and arsenic are carcinogens; cadmium causes a degenerative bone disease; and mercury and lead damage the central nervous system.[citation needed]

Lead is the most prevalent heavy metal contaminant.[58] Levels in the aquatic environments of industrialised societies have been estimated to be two to three times those of pre-industrial levels.[59] As a component of tetraethyl lead, (CH
3
CH
2
)
4
Pb
, it was used extensively in gasoline from the 1930s until the 1970s.[60] Although the use of leaded gasoline was largely phased out in North America by 1996, soils next to roads built before this time retain high lead concentrations.[61] Later research demonstrated a statistically significant correlation between the usage rate of leaded gasoline and violent crime in the United States; taking into account a 22-year time lag (for the average age of violent criminals), the violent crime curve virtually tracked the lead exposure curve.[62]

Other heavy metals noted for their potentially hazardous nature, usually as toxic environmental pollutants, include manganese (central nervous system damage);[63] cobalt and nickel (carcinogens);[64] copper,[65] zinc,[66] selenium[67] and silver[68] (endocrine disruption, congenital disorders, or general toxic effects in fish, plants, birds, or other aquatic organisms); tin, as organotin (central nervous system damage);[69] antimony (a suspected carcinogen);[70] and thallium (central nervous system damage).[65][n 9][n 10]

Other heavy metals

edit

A few other non-essential heavy metals have one or more toxic forms. Kidney failure and fatalities have been recorded arising from the ingestion of germanium dietary supplements (~15 to 300 g in total consumed over a period of two months to three years).[65] Exposure to osmium tetroxide (OsO4) may cause permanent eye damage and can lead to respiratory failure[74] and death.[75] Indium salts are toxic if more than few milligrams are ingested and will affect the kidneys, liver, and heart.[76] Cisplatin (PtCl2(NH3)2), an important drug used to kill cancer cells, is also a kidney and nerve poison.[65] Bismuth compounds can cause liver damage if taken in excess; insoluble uranium compounds, as well as the dangerous radiation they emit, can cause permanent kidney damage.[77]

Exposure sources

edit

Heavy metals can degrade air, water, and soil quality, and subsequently cause health issues in plants, animals, and people, when they become concentrated as a result of industrial activities.[78][79] Common sources of heavy metals in this context include vehicle emissions;[80] motor oil;[81] fertilisers;[82] glassworking;[83] incinerators;[84] treated timber;[85] aging water supply infrastructure;[86] and microplastics floating in the world's oceans.[87] Recent examples of heavy metal contamination and health risks include the occurrence of Minamata disease, in Japan (1932–1968; lawsuits ongoing as of 2016);[88] the Bento Rodrigues dam disaster in Brazil,[89] high levels of lead in drinking water supplied to the residents of Flint, Michigan, in the north-east of the United States[90] and 2015 Hong Kong heavy metal in drinking water incidents.

Formation, abundance, occurrence, and extraction

edit
 
Heavy metals in the Earth's crust:
abundance and main occurrence or source[n 11]
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
1  H He
2  Li Be B C N O F Ne
3  Na Mg Al Si P S Cl Ar
4  K Ca Sc Ti V Cr Mn Fe Co Ni Cu Zn Ga Ge As Se Br Kr
5  Rb Sr Y Zr Nb Mo Ru Rh Pd Ag Cd In Sn Sb Te  I  Xe
6  Cs Ba   Lu Hf Ta W Re Os Ir Pt Au Hg Tl Pb Bi
7   
  La Ce Pr Nd Sm Eu Gd Tb Dy Ho Er Tm Yb
  Th U
 
   Most abundant (56,300 ppm by weight)
   Rare (0.01–0.99 ppm)
   Abundant (100–999 ppm)
   Very rare (0.0001–0.0099 ppm)
   Uncommon (1–99 ppm)
 
Heavy metals left of the dividing line occur (or are sourced) mainly as lithophiles; those to the right, as chalcophiles except gold (a siderophile) and tin (a lithophile).

Heavy metals up to the vicinity of iron (in the periodic table) are largely made via stellar nucleosynthesis. In this process, lighter elements from hydrogen to silicon undergo successive fusion reactions inside stars, releasing light and heat and forming heavier elements with higher atomic numbers.[94]

Heavier heavy metals are not usually formed this way since fusion reactions involving such nuclei would consume rather than release energy.[95] Rather, they are largely synthesised (from elements with a lower atomic number) by neutron capture, with the two main modes of this repetitive capture being the s-process and the r-process. In the s-process ("s" stands for "slow"), singular captures are separated by years or decades, allowing the less stable nuclei to beta decay,[96] while in the r-process ("rapid"), captures happen faster than nuclei can decay. Therefore, the s-process takes a more or less clear path: for example, stable cadmium-110 nuclei are successively bombarded by free neutrons inside a star until they form cadmium-115 nuclei which are unstable and decay to form indium-115 (which is nearly stable, with a half-life 30,000 times the age of the universe). These nuclei capture neutrons and form indium-116, which is unstable, and decays to form tin-116, and so on.[94][97][n 12] In contrast, there is no such path in the r-process. The s-process stops at bismuth due to the short half-lives of the next two elements, polonium and astatine, which decay to bismuth or lead. The r-process is so fast it can skip this zone of instability and go on to create heavier elements such as thorium and uranium.[99]

Heavy metals condense in planets as a result of stellar evolution and destruction processes. Stars lose much of their mass when it is ejected late in their lifetimes, and sometimes thereafter as a result of a neutron star merger,[100][n 13] thereby increasing the abundance of elements heavier than helium in the interstellar medium. When gravitational attraction causes this matter to coalesce and collapse, new stars and planets are formed.[102]

The Earth's crust is made of approximately 5% of heavy metals by weight, with iron comprising 95% of this quantity. Light metals (~20%) and nonmetals (~75%) make up the other 95% of the crust.[91] Despite their overall scarcity, heavy metals can become concentrated in economically extractable quantities as a result of mountain building, erosion, or other geological processes.[103]

Heavy metals are found primarily as lithophiles (rock-loving) or chalcophiles (ore-loving). Lithophile heavy metals are mainly f-block elements and the more reactive of the d-block elements. They have a strong affinity for oxygen and mostly exist as relatively low density silicate minerals.[104] Chalcophile heavy metals are mainly the less reactive d-block elements, and period 4–6 p-block metals and metalloids. They are usually found in (insoluble) sulfide minerals. Being denser than the lithophiles, hence sinking lower into the crust at the time of its solidification, the chalcophiles tend to be less abundant than the lithophiles.[105]

In contrast, gold is a siderophile, or iron-loving element. It does not readily form compounds with either oxygen or sulfur.[106] At the time of the Earth's formation, and as the most noble (inert) of metals, gold sank into the core due to its tendency to form high-density metallic alloys. Consequently, it is a relatively rare metal.[107][failed verification] Some other (less) noble heavy metals—molybdenum, rhenium, the platinum group metals (ruthenium, rhodium, palladium, osmium, iridium, and platinum), germanium, and tin—can be counted as siderophiles but only in terms of their primary occurrence in the Earth (core, mantle and crust), rather the crust. These metals otherwise occur in the crust, in small quantities, chiefly as chalcophiles (less so in their native form).[108][n 14]

Concentrations of heavy metals below the crust are generally higher, with most being found in the largely iron-silicon-nickel core. Platinum, for example, comprises approximately 1 part per billion of the crust whereas its concentration in the core is thought to be nearly 6,000 times higher.[109][110] Recent speculation suggests that uranium (and thorium) in the core may generate a substantial amount of the heat that drives plate tectonics and (ultimately) sustains the Earth's magnetic field.[111][n 15]

Broadly speaking, and with some exceptions, lithophile heavy metals can be extracted from their ores by electrical or chemical treatments, while chalcophile heavy metals are obtained by roasting their sulphide ores to yield the corresponding oxides, and then heating these to obtain the raw metals.[113][n 16] Radium occurs in quantities too small to be economically mined and is instead obtained from spent nuclear fuels.[116] The chalcophile platinum group metals (PGM) mainly occur in small (mixed) quantities with other chalcophile ores. The ores involved need to be smelted, roasted, and then leached with sulfuric acid to produce a residue of PGM. This is chemically refined to obtain the individual metals in their pure forms.[117] Compared to other metals, PGM are expensive due to their scarcity[118] and high production costs.[119]

Gold, a siderophile, is most commonly recovered by dissolving the ores in which it is found in a cyanide solution.[120] The gold forms a dicyanoaurate(I), for example: 2 Au + H2O +½ O2 + 4 KCN → 2 K[Au(CN)2] + 2 KOH. Zinc is added to the mix and, being more reactive than gold, displaces the gold: 2 K[Au(CN)2] + Zn → K2[Zn(CN)4] + 2 Au. The gold precipitates out of solution as a sludge, and is filtered off and melted.[121]

Uses

edit

Heavy metals are present in nearly all aspects of modern life. Iron may be the most common as it accounts for 90% of all refined metals. Platinum may be the most ubiquitous given it is said to be[by whom?] found in, or used to produce, 20% of all consumer goods.[122]

Some common uses of heavy metals depend on the general characteristics of metals such as electrical conductivity and reflectivity or the general characteristics of heavy metals such as density, strength, and durability. Other uses depend on the characteristics of the specific element, such as their biological role as nutrients or poisons or some other specific atomic properties. Examples of such atomic properties include: partly filled d- or f- orbitals (in many of the transition, lanthanide, and actinide heavy metals) that enable the formation of coloured compounds;[123] the capacity of most heavy metal ions (such as platinum,[124] cerium[125] or bismuth[126]) to exist in different oxidation states and are used in catalysts;[127] strong exchange interactions in 3d or 4f orbitals (in iron, cobalt, and nickel, or the lanthanide heavy metals) that give rise to magnetic effects;[128] and high atomic numbers and electron densities that underpin their nuclear science applications.[129] Typical uses of heavy metals can be broadly grouped into the following six categories.[130][n 17]

Weight- or density-based

edit
 
In a cello (example shown above) or a viola the C-string sometimes incorporates tungsten; its high density permits a smaller diameter string and improves responsiveness.[131]

Some uses of heavy metals, including in sport, mechanical engineering, military ordnance, and nuclear science, take advantage of their relatively high densities. In underwater diving, lead is used as a ballast;[132] in handicap horse racing each horse must carry a specified lead weight, based on factors including past performance, so as to equalize the chances of the various competitors.[133] In golf, tungsten, brass, or copper inserts in fairway clubs and irons lower the centre of gravity of the club making it easier to get the ball into the air;[134] and golf balls with tungsten cores are claimed to have better flight characteristics.[135] In fly fishing, sinking fly lines have a PVC coating embedded with tungsten powder, so that they sink at the required rate.[136] In track and field sport, steel balls used in the hammer throw and shot put events are filled with lead in order to attain the minimum weight required under international rules.[137] Tungsten was used in hammer throw balls at least up to 1980; the minimum size of the ball was increased in 1981 to eliminate the need for what was, at that time, an expensive metal (triple the cost of other hammers) not generally available in all countries.[138] Tungsten hammers were so dense that they penetrated too deeply into the turf.[139]

The higher the projectile density, the more effectively it can penetrate heavy armor plate ... Os, Ir, Pt, and Re ... are expensive ... U offers an appealing combination of high density, reasonable cost and high fracture toughness.

AM Russell and KL Lee
Structure–property relations
in nonferrous metals
(2005, p. 16)

Heavy metals are used for ballast in boats,[140] aeroplanes,[141] and motor vehicles;[142] or in balance weights on wheels and crankshafts,[143] gyroscopes, and propellers,[144] and centrifugal clutches,[145] in situations requiring maximum weight in minimum space (for example in watch movements).[141]

In military ordnance, tungsten or uranium is used in armour plating[146] and armour piercing projectiles,[147] as well as in nuclear weapons to increase efficiency (by reflecting neutrons and momentarily delaying the expansion of reacting materials).[148] In the 1970s, tantalum was found to be more effective than copper in shaped charge and explosively formed anti-armour weapons on account of its higher density, allowing greater force concentration, and better deformability.[149] Less-toxic heavy metals, such as copper, tin, tungsten, and bismuth, and probably manganese (as well as boron, a metalloid), have replaced lead and antimony in the green bullets used by some armies and in some recreational shooting munitions.[150] Doubts have been raised about the safety (or green credentials) of tungsten.[151]

Because denser materials absorb more of certain types of radioactive emissions such as gamma rays than lighter ones, heavy metals are useful for radiation shielding and to focus radiation beams in linear accelerators and radiotherapy applications.[152]

Strength- or durability-based

edit
 
The Statue of Liberty. A stainless steel alloy[153] armature provides structural strength; a copper skin confers corrosion resistance.[n 18]

The strength or durability of heavy metals such as chromium, iron, nickel, copper, zinc, molybdenum, tin, tungsten, and lead, as well as their alloys, makes them useful for the manufacture of tools, machinery,[155] appliances,[156] utensils,[157] pipes,[156] railroad tracks,[158] buildings[159] and bridges,[160] automobiles,[156] locks,[161] furniture,[162] ships,[140] planes,[163] coinage[164] and jewellery.[165] They are also used as alloying additives for enhancing the properties of other metals.[n 19] Of the two dozen elements that have been used in the world's monetised coinage only two, carbon and aluminium, are not heavy metals.[167][n 20] Gold, silver, and platinum are used in jewellery[n 21] as are, for example, nickel, copper, indium, and cobalt in coloured gold.[170] Low-cost jewellery and children's toys may be made, to a significant degree, of heavy metals such as chromium, nickel, cadmium, or lead.[171]

Copper, zinc, tin, and lead are mechanically weaker metals but have useful corrosion prevention properties. While each of them will react with air, the resulting patinas of either various copper salts,[172] zinc carbonate, tin oxide, or a mixture of lead oxide, carbonate, and sulfate, confer valuable protective properties.[173] Copper and lead are therefore used, for example, as roofing materials;[174][n 22] zinc acts as an anti-corrosion agent in galvanised steel;[175] and tin serves a similar purpose on steel cans.[176][failed verification]

The workability and corrosion resistance of iron and chromium are increased by adding gadolinium; the creep resistance of nickel is improved with the addition of thorium.[citation needed] Tellurium is added to copper (tellurium copper) and stainless steel to improve their machinability; and to lead to make it harder and more acid-resistant.[177]

Biological and chemical

edit
 
Cerium(IV) oxide is used as a catalyst in self-cleaning ovens.[178]

The biocidal effects of some heavy metals have been known since antiquity.[179] Platinum, osmium, copper, ruthenium, and other heavy metals, including arsenic, are used in anti-cancer treatments, or have shown potential.[180] Antimony (anti-protozoal), bismuth (anti-ulcer), gold (anti-arthritic), and iron (anti-malarial) are also important in medicine.[181] Copper, zinc, silver, gold, or mercury are used in antiseptic formulations;[182] small amounts of some heavy metals are used to control algal growth in, for example, cooling towers.[183] Depending on their intended use as fertilisers or biocides, agrochemicals may contain heavy metals such as chromium, cobalt, nickel, copper, zinc, arsenic, cadmium, mercury, or lead.[184]

Selected heavy metals are used as catalysts in fuel processing (rhenium, for example), synthetic rubber and fibre production (bismuth), emission control devices (palladium and platinum), and in self-cleaning ovens (where cerium(IV) oxide in the walls of such ovens helps oxidise carbon-based cooking residues).[185] In soap chemistry, heavy metals form insoluble soaps that are used in lubricating greases, paint dryers, and fungicides (apart from lithium, the alkali metals and the ammonium ion form soluble soaps).[186]

Colouring and optics

edit
 
Neodymium sulfate (Nd2(SO4)3), used to colour glassware[187]

The colours of glass, ceramic glazes, paints, pigments, and plastics are commonly produced by the inclusion of heavy metals (or their compounds) such as chromium, manganese, cobalt, copper, zinc, zirconium, molybdenum, silver, tin, praseodymium, neodymium, erbium, tungsten, iridium, gold, lead, or uranium.[188] Tattoo inks may contain heavy metals, such as chromium, cobalt, nickel, and copper.[189] The high reflectivity of some heavy metals is important in the construction of mirrors, including precision astronomical instruments. Headlight reflectors rely on the excellent reflectivity of a thin film of rhodium.[190]

Electronics, magnets, and lighting

edit
 
The Topaz Solar Farm, in southern California, features nine million cadmium-tellurium photovoltaic modules covering an area of 25.6 square kilometres (9.9 square miles).

Heavy metals or their compounds can be found in electronic components, electrodes, and wiring and solar panels where they may be used as either conductors, semiconductors, or insulators. Molybdenum powder is used in circuit board inks.[191] Ruthenium(IV) oxide coated titanium anodes are used for the industrial production of chlorine.[192] Home electrical systems, for the most part, are wired with copper wire for its good conducting properties.[193] Silver and gold are used in electrical and electronic devices, particularly in contact switches, as a result of their high electrical conductivity and capacity to resist or minimise the formation of impurities on their surfaces.[194] Hafnium oxide, an insulator, is used as a voltage controller in microchips; tantalum oxide, another insulator, is used in capacitors in mobile phones.[195] Heavy metals have been used in batteries for over 200 years, at least since Volta invented his copper and silver voltaic pile in 1800.[196]

Magnets are often made of heavy metals such as manganese, iron, cobalt, nickel, niobium, bismuth, praseodymium, neodymium, gadolinium, and dysprosium. Neodymium magnets are the strongest type of permanent magnet commercially available. They are key components of, for example, car door locks, starter motors, fuel pumps, and power windows.[197]

Heavy metals are used in lighting, lasers, and light-emitting diodes (LEDs). Flat panel displays incorporate a thin film of electrically conducting indium tin oxide. Fluorescent lighting relies on mercury vapour for its operation. Ruby lasers generate deep red beams by exciting chromium atoms in aluminum oxide; the lanthanides are also extensively employed in lasers. Gallium, indium, and arsenic;[198] and copper, iridium, and platinum are used in LEDs (the latter three in organic LEDs).[199]

Nuclear

edit
 
An X-ray tube with a rotating anode, typically a tungsten-rhenium alloy on a molybdenum core, backed with graphite[200][n 23]

Niche uses of heavy metals with high atomic numbers occur in diagnostic imaging, electron microscopy, and nuclear science. In diagnostic imaging, heavy metals such as cobalt or tungsten make up the anode materials found in x-ray tubes.[203] In electron microscopy, heavy metals such as lead, gold, palladium, platinum, or uranium have been used in the past to make conductive coatings and to introduce electron density into biological specimens by staining, negative staining, or vacuum deposition.[204] In nuclear science, nuclei of heavy metals such as chromium, iron, or zinc are sometimes fired at other heavy metal targets to produce superheavy elements;[205] heavy metals are also employed as spallation targets for the production of neutrons[206] or isotopes of non-primordial elements such as astatine (using lead, bismuth, thorium, or uranium in the latter case).[207]

Notes

edit
  1. ^ Criteria used were density:[17] (1) above 3.5 g/cm3; (2) above 7 g/cm3; atomic weight: (3) > 22.98;[17] (4) > 40 (excluding s- and f-block metals);[18] (5) > 200;[19] atomic number: (6) > 20; (7) 21–92;[20] chemical behaviour: (8) United States Pharmacopeia;[23][24][25] (9) Hawkes' periodic table-based definition (excluding the lanthanides and actinides);[16] and (10) Nieboer and Richardson's biochemical classifications.[26] Densities of the elements are mainly from Emsley.[27] Predicted densities have been used for At, Fr and FmTs.[28] Indicative densities were derived for Fm, Md, No and Lr based on their atomic weights, estimated metallic radii,[29] and predicted close-packed crystalline structures.[30] Atomic weights are from Emsley,[27] inside back cover
  2. ^ Metalloids were, however, excluded from Hawkes' periodic table-based definition given he noted it was "not necessary to decide whether semimetals [i.e. metalloids] should be included as heavy metals."[16]
  3. ^ Lead, a cumulative poison, has a relatively high abundance due to its extensive historical use and human-caused discharge into the environment.[42]
  4. ^ Haynes shows an amount of < 17 mg for tin[43]
  5. ^ Iyengar records a figure of 5 mg for nickel;[44] Haynes shows an amount of 10 mg[43]
  6. ^ Selenium is a nonmetal.
  7. ^ Encompassing 45 heavy metals occurring in quantities of less than 10 mg each, including As (7 mg), Mo (5), Co (1.5), and Cr (1.4)[45]
  8. ^ Of the elements commonly recognised as metalloids, B and Si were counted as nonmetals; Ge, As, Sb, and Te as heavy metals.
  9. ^ Ni, Cu, Zn, Se, Ag and Sb appear in the United States Government's Toxic Pollutant List;[71] Mn, Co, and Sn are listed in the Australian Government's National Pollutant Inventory.[72]
  10. ^ Tungsten could be another such toxic heavy metal.[73]
  11. ^ Trace elements having an abundance much less than the one part per trillion of Ra and Pa (namely Tc, Pm, Po, At, Ac, Np, and Pu) are not shown. Abundances are from Lide[91] and Emsley;[92] occurrence types are from McQueen.[93]
  12. ^ In some cases, for example in the presence of high energy gamma rays or in a very high temperature hydrogen rich environment, the subject nuclei may experience neutron loss or proton gain resulting in the production of (comparatively rare) neutron deficient isotopes.[98]
  13. ^ The ejection of matter when two neutron stars collide is attributed to the interaction of their tidal forces, possible crustal disruption, and shock heating (which is what happens if you floor the accelerator in a car when the engine is cold).[101]
  14. ^ Iron, cobalt, nickel, germanium and tin are also siderophiles from a whole of Earth perspective.[93]
  15. ^ Heat escaping from the inner solid core is believed to generate motion in the outer core, which is made of liquid iron alloys. The motion of this liquid generates electrical currents which give rise to a magnetic field.[112]
  16. ^ Heavy metals that occur naturally in quantities too small to be economically mined (Tc, Pm, Po, At, Ac, Np and Pu) are instead produced by artificial transmutation.[114] The latter method is also used to produce heavy metals from americium onwards.[115]
  17. ^ Some violence and abstraction of detail was applied to the sorting scheme in order to keep the number of categories to a manageable level.
  18. ^ The skin has largely turned green due to the formation of a protective patina composed of antlerite Cu3(OH)4SO4, atacamite Cu4(OH)6Cl2, brochantite Cu4(OH)6SO4, cuprous oxide Cu2O, and tenorite CuO.[154]
  19. ^ For the lanthanides, this is their only structural use as they are otherwise too reactive, relatively expensive, and moderately strong at best.[166]
  20. ^ Welter[168] classifies coinage metals as precious metals (e.g., silver, gold, platinum); heavy metals of very high durability (nickel); heavy metals of low durability (copper, iron, zinc, tin, and lead); and light metals (aluminium).
  21. ^ Emsley[169] estimates a global loss of six tonnes of gold a year due to 18-carat wedding rings slowly wearing away.
  22. ^ Sheet lead exposed to the rigours of industrial and coastal climates will last for centuries[132]
  23. ^ Electrons impacting the tungsten anode generate X-rays;[201] rhenium gives tungsten better resistance to thermal shock;[202] molybdenum and graphite act as heat sinks. Molybdenum also has a density nearly half that of tungsten thereby reducing the weight of the anode.[200]

References

edit
  1. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 288, 374
  2. ^ a b Duffus 2002.
  3. ^ Pourret, Olivier; Bollinger, Jean-Claude; Hursthouse, Andrew (2021). "Heavy metal: a misused term?" (PDF). Acta Geochimica. 40 (3): 466–471. Bibcode:2021AcGch..40..466P. doi:10.1007/s11631-021-00468-0. S2CID 232342843.
  4. ^ Hübner, Astin & Herbert 2010
  5. ^ a b Duffus 2002, p. 795.
  6. ^ Ali & Khan 2018.
  7. ^ Nieboer & Richardson 1980.
  8. ^ Baldwin & Marshall 1999.
  9. ^ Goyer & Clarkson 1996, p. 839.
  10. ^ a b Pourret, Bollinger & Hursthouse 2021.
  11. ^ Hübner, Astin & Herbert 2010, p. 1513
  12. ^ a b Rainbow 1991, p. 416
  13. ^ Nieboer & Richardson 1980, p. 21
  14. ^ Morris 1992, p. 1001
  15. ^ Gorbachev, Zamyatnin & Lbov 1980, p. 5
  16. ^ a b c d Hawkes 1997
  17. ^ a b c d Duffus 2002, p. 798
  18. ^ a b Rand, Wells & McCarty 1995, p. 23
  19. ^ a b Baldwin & Marshall 1999, p. 267
  20. ^ a b Lyman 2003, p. 452
  21. ^ Duffus 2002, p. 797
  22. ^ Liens 2010, p. 1415
  23. ^ a b The United States Pharmacopeia 1985, p. 1189
  24. ^ Raghuram, Soma Raju & Sriramulu 2010, p. 15
  25. ^ Thorne & Roberts 1943, p. 534
  26. ^ Nieboer & Richardson 1980, p. 4
  27. ^ a b Emsley 2011
  28. ^ Hoffman, Lee & Pershina 2011, pp. 1691, 1723; Bonchev & Kamenska 1981, p. 1182
  29. ^ Silva 2010, pp. 1628, 1635, 1639, 1644
  30. ^ Fournier 1976, p. 243
  31. ^ Vernon 2013, p. 1703
  32. ^ Nieboer & Richardson 1980, p. 5
  33. ^ Nieboer & Richardson 1980, pp. 6–7
  34. ^ Nieboer & Richardson 1980, p. 9
  35. ^ Hübner, Astin & Herbert 2010, pp. 1511–1512
  36. ^ Raymond 1984, pp. 8–9
  37. ^ Habashi 2009, p. 31
  38. ^ Gmelin 1849, p. 2
  39. ^ Magee 1969, p. 14
  40. ^ The Minerals, Metals and Materials Society 2016
  41. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 35, passim
  42. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 280, 286; Baird & Cann 2012, pp. 549, 551
  43. ^ a b Haynes 2015, pp. 7–48
  44. ^ Iyengar 1998, p. 553
  45. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 47, 331, 138, 133, passim
  46. ^ Nieboer & Richardson 1978, p. 2
  47. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 604, 31, 133, 358, 47, 475
  48. ^ Valkovic 1990, pp. 214, 218
  49. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 331, 89, 552
  50. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 571
  51. ^ Venugopal & Luckey 1978, p. 307
  52. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 24, passim
  53. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 192, 197, 240, 120, 166, 188, 224, 269, 299, 423, 464, 549, 614, 559
  54. ^ Duffus 2002, pp. 794, 799
  55. ^ Baird & Cann 2012, p. 519
  56. ^ Kozin & Hansen 2013, p. 80
  57. ^ Baird & Cann 2012, pp. 519–520, 567; Rusyniak et al. 2010, p. 387
  58. ^ Di Maio 2001, p. 208
  59. ^ Perry & Vanderklein 1996, p. 208
  60. ^ Love 1998, p. 208
  61. ^ Hendrickson 2016, p. 42
  62. ^ Reyes 2007, pp. 1, 20, 35–36
  63. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 311
  64. ^ Wiberg 2001, pp. 1474, 1501
  65. ^ a b c d Tokar et al. 2013
  66. ^ Eisler 1993, pp. 3, passim
  67. ^ Lemly 1997, p. 259; Ohlendorf 2003, p. 490
  68. ^ State Water Control Resources Board 1987, p. 63
  69. ^ Scott 1989, pp. 107–108
  70. ^ International Antimony Association 2016
  71. ^ United States Government 2014
  72. ^ Australian Government 2016
  73. ^ United States Environmental Protection Agency 2014
  74. ^ Cole & Stuart 2000, p. 315
  75. ^ Clegg 2014
  76. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 240
  77. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 595
  78. ^ Namla, Djadjiti; Mangse, George; Koleoso, Peter O.; Ogbaga, Chukwuma C.; Nwagbara, Onyinye F. (2022). "Assessment of Heavy Metal Concentrations of Municipal Open-Air Dumpsite: A Case Study of Gosa Dumpsite, Abuja". Innovations and Interdisciplinary Solutions for Underserved Areas. Lecture Notes of the Institute for Computer Sciences, Social Informatics and Telecommunications Engineering. Vol. 449. pp. 165–174. doi:10.1007/978-3-031-23116-2_13. ISBN 978-3-031-23115-5.
  79. ^ Stankovic & Stankovic 2013, pp. 154–159
  80. ^ Ndiokwere, C.L. (January 1984). "A study of heavy metal pollution from motor vehicle emissions and its effect on roadside soil, vegetation and crops in Nigeria". Environmental Pollution Series B, Chemical and Physical. 7 (1): 35–42. doi:10.1016/0143-148X(84)90035-1.
  81. ^ https://blog.nationalgeographic.org/2015/08/03/heavy-metals-in-motor-oil-have-heavy-consequences/ Heavy Metals in Motor Oil Have Heavy Consequences
  82. ^ "Fear In The Fields -- How Hazardous Wastes Become Fertilizer -- Spreading Heavy Metals On Farmland Is Perfectly Legal, But Little Research Has Been Done To Find Out Whether It's Safe".
  83. ^ https://hazwastehelp.org/ArtHazards/glassworking.aspx Art Hazards
  84. ^ Wang, P.; Hu, Y.; Cheng, H. (2019). "Municipal solid waste (MSW) incineration fly ash as an important source of heavy metal pollution in China". Environmental Pollution. 252 (Pt A): 461–475. Bibcode:2019EPoll.252..461W. doi:10.1016/j.envpol.2019.04.082. PMID 31158674. S2CID 145832923.
  85. ^ Bradl 2005, pp. 15, 17–20
  86. ^ Harvey, Handley & Taylor 2015, p. 12276
  87. ^ Howell et al. 2012; Cole et al. 2011, pp. 2589–2590
  88. ^ Amasawa et al. 2016, pp. 95–101
  89. ^ Massarani 2015
  90. ^ Torrice 2016
  91. ^ a b Lide 2004, pp. 14–17
  92. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 29, passim
  93. ^ a b McQueen 2009, p. 74
  94. ^ a b Cox 1997, pp. 73–89
  95. ^ Cox 1997, pp. 32, 63, 85
  96. ^ Podosek 2011, p. 482
  97. ^ Padmanabhan 2001, p. 234
  98. ^ Rehder 2010, pp. 32, 33
  99. ^ Hofmann 2002, pp. 23–24
  100. ^ Hadhazy 2016
  101. ^ Choptuik, Lehner & Pretorias 2015, p. 383
  102. ^ Cox 1997, pp. 83, 91, 102–103
  103. ^ Berry & Mason 1959, pp. 210–211; Rankin 2011, p. 69
  104. ^ Hartmann 2005, p. 197
  105. ^ Yousif 2007, pp. 11–12
  106. ^ Berry & Mason 1959, p. 214
  107. ^ Yousif 2007, p. 11
  108. ^ Wiberg 2001, p. 1511
  109. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 403
  110. ^ Litasov & Shatskiy 2016, p. 27
  111. ^ Sanders 2003; Preuss 2011
  112. ^ Natural Resources Canada 2015
  113. ^ MacKay, MacKay & Henderson 2002, pp. 203–204
  114. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 525–528, 428–429, 414, 57–58, 22, 346–347, 408–409; Keller, Wolf & Shani 2012, p. 98
  115. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 32 et seq.
  116. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 437
  117. ^ Chen & Huang 2006, p. 208; Crundwell et al. 2011, pp. 411–413; Renner et al. 2012, p. 332; Seymour & O'Farrelly 2012, pp. 10–12
  118. ^ Crundwell et al. 2011, p. 409
  119. ^ International Platinum Group Metals Association n.d., pp. 3–4
  120. ^ McLemore 2008, p. 44
  121. ^ Wiberg 2001, p. 1277
  122. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 260, 401
  123. ^ Jones 2001, p. 3
  124. ^ Berea, Rodriguez-lbelo & Navarro 2016, p. 203
  125. ^ Alves, Berutti & Sánchez 2012, p. 94
  126. ^ Yadav, Antony & Subba Reddy 2012, p. 231
  127. ^ Masters 1981, p. 5
  128. ^ Wulfsberg 1987, pp. 200–201
  129. ^ Bryson & Hammond 2005, p. 120 (high electron density); Frommer & Stabulas-Savage 2014, pp. 69–70 (high atomic number)
  130. ^ Landis, Sofield & Yu 2011, p. 269
  131. ^ Prieto 2011, p. 10; Pickering 1991, pp. 5–6, 17
  132. ^ a b Emsley 2011, p. 286
  133. ^ Berger & Bruning 1979, p. 173
  134. ^ Jackson & Summitt 2006, pp. 10, 13
  135. ^ Shedd 2002, p. 80.5; Kantra 2001, p. 10
  136. ^ Spolek 2007, p. 239
  137. ^ White 2010, p. 139
  138. ^ Dapena & Teves 1982, p. 78
  139. ^ Burkett 2010, p. 80
  140. ^ a b Moore & Ramamoorthy 1984, p. 102
  141. ^ a b National Materials Advisory Board 1973, p. 58
  142. ^ Livesey 2012, p. 57
  143. ^ VanGelder 2014, pp. 354, 801
  144. ^ National Materials Advisory Board 1971, pp. 35–37
  145. ^ Frick 2000, p. 342
  146. ^ Rockhoff 2012, p. 314
  147. ^ Russell & Lee 2005, pp. 16, 96
  148. ^ Morstein 2005, p. 129
  149. ^ Russell & Lee 2005, pp. 218–219
  150. ^ Lach et al. 2015; Di Maio 2016, p. 154
  151. ^ Preschel 2005; Guandalini et al. 2011, p. 488
  152. ^ Scoullos et al. 2001, p. 315; Ariel, Barta & Brandon 1973, p. 126
  153. ^ Wingerson 1986, p. 35
  154. ^ Matyi & Baboian 1986, p. 299; Livingston 1991, pp. 1401, 1407
  155. ^ Casey 1993, p. 156
  156. ^ a b c Bradl 2005, p. 25
  157. ^ Kumar, Srivastava & Srivastava 1994, p. 259
  158. ^ Nzierżanowski & Gawroński 2012, p. 42
  159. ^ Pacheco-Torgal, Jalali & Fucic 2012, pp. 283–294, 297–333
  160. ^ Venner et al. 2004, p. 124
  161. ^ Technical Publications 1958, p. 235: "Here is a rugged hard metal cutter ... for cutting ... through ... padlocks, steel grilles and other heavy metals."
  162. ^ Naja & Volesky 2009, p. 41
  163. ^ Department of the Navy 2009, pp. 3.3–13
  164. ^ Rebhandl et al. 2007, p. 1729
  165. ^ Greenberg & Patterson 2008, p. 239
  166. ^ Russell & Lee 2005, pp. 437, 441
  167. ^ Roe & Roe 1992
  168. ^ Welter 1976, p. 4
  169. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 208
  170. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 206
  171. ^ Guney & Zagury 2012, p. 1238; Cui et al. 2015, p. 77
  172. ^ Brephol & McCreight 2001, p. 15
  173. ^ Russell & Lee 2005, pp. 337, 404, 411
  174. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 141, 286
  175. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 625
  176. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 555, 557
  177. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 531
  178. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 123
  179. ^ Weber & Rutula 2001, p. 415
  180. ^ Dunn 2009; Bonetti et al. 2009, pp. 1, 84, 201
  181. ^ Desoize 2004, p. 1529
  182. ^ Atlas 1986, p. 359; Lima et al. 2013, p. 1
  183. ^ Volesky 1990, p. 174
  184. ^ Nakbanpote, Meesungnoen & Prasad 2016, p. 180
  185. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 447, 74, 384, 123
  186. ^ Elliot 1946, p. 11; Warth 1956, p. 571
  187. ^ McColm 1994, p. 215
  188. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 135, 313, 141, 495, 626, 479, 630, 334, 495, 556, 424, 339, 169, 571, 252, 205, 286, 599
  189. ^ Everts 2016
  190. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 450
  191. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 334
  192. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 459
  193. ^ Moselle 2004, pp. 409–410
  194. ^ Russell & Lee 2005, p. 323
  195. ^ Emsley 2011, p. 212
  196. ^ Tretkoff 2006
  197. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 73, 141, 141, 141, 355, 73, 424, 340, 189, 189
  198. ^ Emsley 2011, pp. 192, 242, 194
  199. ^ Baranoff 2015, p. 80; Wong et al. 2015, p. 6535
  200. ^ a b Ball, Moore & Turner 2008, p. 177
  201. ^ Ball, Moore & Turner 2008, pp. 248–249, 255
  202. ^ Russell & Lee 2005, p. 238
  203. ^ Tisza 2001, p. 73
  204. ^ Chandler & Roberson 2009, pp. 47, 367–369, 373; Ismail, Khulbe & Matsuura 2015, p. 302
  205. ^ Ebbing & Gammon 2017, p. 695
  206. ^ Pan & Dai 2015, p. 69
  207. ^ Brown 1987, p. 48

Sources

edit

Further reading

edit

Definition and usage

  • Ali H. & Khan E. 2017, "What are heavy metals? Long-standing controversy over the scientific use of the term 'heavy metals'—proposal of a comprehensive definition", Toxicological & Environmental Chemistry, pp. 1–25, doi:10.1080/02772248.2017.1413652. Suggests defining heavy metals as "naturally occurring metals having atomic number (Z) greater than 20 and an elemental density greater than 5 g cm−3".
  • Duffus J. H. 2002, "'Heavy metals'—A meaningless term?", Pure and Applied Chemistry, vol. 74, no. 5, pp. 793–807, doi:10.1351/pac200274050793. Includes a survey of the term's various meanings.
  • Hawkes S. J. 1997, "What is a 'heavy metal'?", Journal of Chemical Education, vol. 74, no. 11, p. 1374, doi:10.1021/ed074p1374. A chemist's perspective.
  • Hübner R., Astin K. B. & Herbert R. J. H. 2010, "'Heavy metal'—time to move on from semantics to pragmatics?", Journal of Environmental Monitoring, vol. 12, pp. 1511–1514, doi:10.1039/C0EM00056F. Finds that, despite its lack of specificity, the term appears to have become part of the language of science.

Toxicity and biological role

Formation

Uses

  • Koehler C. S. W. 2001, "Heavy metal medicine", Chemistry Chronicles, American Chemical Society, accessed 11 July 2016
  • Morowitz N. 2006, "The heavy metals", Modern Marvels, season 12, episode 14, HistoryChannel.com
  • Öhrström L. 2014, "Tantalum oxide", Chemistry World, 24 September, accessed 4 October 2016. The author explains how tantalum(V) oxide banished brick-sized mobile phones. Also available as a podcast.
edit